| American Ind. Paper Mills Supply Co., Inc. v County ofWestchester |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 06655 [65 AD3d 1173] |
| September 22, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| American Independent Paper Mills Supply Co., Inc.,Appellant, v County of Westchester et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Charlene M. Indelicato, County Attorney, White Plains, N.Y. (Stacey Dolgin-Kmetz,Thomas G. Gardiner, and Justin Adin of counsel), for respondents.
In an action for a judgment declaring that a transfer station fee imposed pursuant to Laws ofWestchester County § 826-a.306 (2) (b) is unconstitutional, the plaintiff appeals from ajudgment of the Supreme Court, Westchester County (Liebowitz, J.), entered January 28, 2008,which, after a nonjury trial, is in favor of the defendants and against it, dismissing the complaint.
Ordered that the judgment is modified, on the law, by deleting the provision thereofdismissing the complaint and substituting therefor a provision declaring that the plaintiff did notestablish that the transfer station fee imposed pursuant to Laws of Westchester County §826-a.306 (2) (b) is unconstitutional; as so modified, the judgment is affirmed, with costs to thedefendants.
In 1999 the Westchester County Board of Legislators enacted the Westchester County SolidWaste and Recyclables Collection Licensing Law (hereinafter the Solid Waste Law) to regulatethe collection and disposal of solid waste and recyclables in the county (see Laws ofWestchester County ch 826-a). Section 826-a.101 (1) (b) of Laws of Westchester County statesthat the Solid Waste Law was enacted in part to address the encroachment of organized crime onthe solid waste disposal industry. Pursuant to section 826-a.201, the defendant WestchesterCounty Solid Waste Commission (hereinafter the Commission) was created to implement andadminister the Solid Waste Law.
Laws of Westchester County § 826-a.306 (2) (b) imposes a per station annual feeranging from $12,500 to $20,000 on any licensee who owns, leases, operates, or controls atransfer station that processes recyclables. The plaintiff, which is a licensee, commenced thisaction for a declaration that the transfer station fee is unconstitutional.
In 2003 the Supreme Court dismissed the complaint as time-barred. This Court reversed in2005 (American Ind. Paper MillsSupply Co., Inc. v County of Westchester, 16 AD3d 443 [2005]). Thereafter, followinga nonjury trial based on the parties' submissions, the Supreme Court dismissed the complaint onthe merits.[*2]
On appeal, the plaintiff contends that the transfer stationfees are unconstitutionally excessive because, as a transfer station owner, it pays more in feesthan companies that only haul waste, even though the Commission does not inspect transferstations. This contention is without merit. As the Court of Appeals stated in LighthouseShores v Town of Islip (41 NY2d 7, 11 [1976]), "[t]he exceedingly strong presumption ofconstitutionality applies not only to enactments of the Legislature but to ordinances ofmunicipalities as well. While this presumption is rebuttable, unconstitutionality must bedemonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt." Transfer station owners and companies that only haulwaste are not similarly situated.
The record indicates that transfer station owners cause the Commission to incur theadditional costs of monitoring those stations, and the plaintiff's contrary claim that theCommission does not actually inspect the transfer stations has no basis in the record. TheCommission's executive director testified that Commission employees conduct transfer stationinvestigations and review transfer station records to ensure that only licensed companies aredumping waste there. Moreover, the plaintiff's own witness testified that the Commissionmonitors illegal dumping at the plaintiff's transfer station, that Commission employees havepersonally visited the station, and that the plaintiff's employees have contacted the Commissionfor the purpose of initiating investigations.
The plaintiff also contends that the transfer station fees are used to fund the Commission'sgeneral operations, and that this violates the rule that a license fee cannot be "greater than a sumreasonably necessary to cover the costs of issuance, inspection and enforcement" (ATM Onev Incorporated Vil. of Freeport, 276 AD2d 573, 574 [2000]). The fact, however, that atransfer station fee may be used to fund the Commission's general operations does notautomatically render the fee an unconstitutional tax.
In American Sugar Ref. Co. of N.Y. v Waterfront Commn. of N.Y. Harbor (55NY2d 11, 26-27 [1982]), the Court of Appeals explained that "[a] license fee has for its primarypurpose the regulation or restriction of a business deemed in need of public control, the cost ofsuch regulation being imposed upon the business benefitted or controlled, whereas the primarypurpose of a tax is to raise money for support of the government generally." Here, as evidencedby Laws of Westchester County § 826-a.101 (1) (b), the Solid Waste Law was enacted toeradicate the influence of organized crime on the solid waste hauling industry. Additionally, thecost of such regulation is imposed on the business benefitted or controlled by such regulation.
Additionally, Laws of Westchester County § 826-a.202 (2) (b) authorizes theCommission to "set such fees to fund the commission, its staff, salaries, fringe benefits and all ofthe commission's other costs and expenses." Any fees obtained are used only to fund oversight ofthe solid waste industry, and not for the support of government generally. Such funding methodsby both municipalities and the state have previously been deemed to be fees as opposed to taxes(see City of Buffalo v Stevenson, 207 NY 258, 262-263 [1913]; American Assn. ofBioanalysts v Axelrod, 106 AD2d 53, 55 [1985]).
Accordingly, the plaintiff failed to establish any constitutional infirmity. The plaintiff'sremaining contentions are without merit. The Supreme Court, however, should have issued adeclaration rather than dismiss the complaint (see Lanza v Wagner, 11 NY2d 317, 334[1962], appeal dismissed 371 US 74 [1962], cert denied 371 US 901 [1962];Ware v Valley Stream High School Dist., 150 AD2d 14, 22 [1989], mod 75NY2d 114 [1989]; Orange & Rockland Util. v Town of Clarkstown, 80 AD2d 846, 847[1981]). Spolzino, J.P., Dillon, Miller and Dickerson, JJ., concur.