| Matter of Brady v Town of Islip Zoning Bd. of Appeals |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 06836 [65 AD3d 1337] |
| September 29, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Dennis P. Brady et al.,Respondents, v Town of Islip Zoning Board of Appeals et al.,Appellants. |
—[*1] Shlimbaum & Shlimbaum, Islip, N.Y. (Lark J. Shlimbaum of counsel), forrespondents.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Town of IslipZoning Board of Appeals dated April 17, 2007, which, after a hearing, denied the petitioners'application for an area variance, the appeal is from a judgment of the Supreme Court, SuffolkCounty (Baisley, J.), dated March 31, 2008, which granted the petition, annulled thedetermination, and remitted the matter to the Town of Islip Zoning Board of Appeals forissuance of the requested area variance.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed, on the law, with costs, the determination is confirmed,the petition is denied, and the proceeding is dismissed on the merits.
In May 2004 the petitioners purchased a 10,000-square-foot parcel of real property(hereinafter the parcel) in the community of Seaview, on Fire Island, in the Town of Islip. Thearea in which the parcel is located contains no roads for cars, but only "walks." The zoningordinance of the Town of Islip prohibits in-ground swimming pools in the relevant zoningdistrict (see Town of Islip Town Code § 68-149.1 [A]), and limits above-groundswimming pools to lots of 12,000 square feet or larger (see Town of Islip Town Code§ 68-149.1 [C]). Prior to December 12, 2006, the ordinance provided for a renewabletemporary special exception that enabled a person with a specified neurological or musculardisease to erect and maintain an above-ground swimming pool for five years where the lot wasless than 12,000 square feet (see Town of Islip Town Code former § 68-149.2).Effective December 12, 2006, the Town of Islip Town Board (hereinafter the Town Board)repealed the section allowing for a special exception, and, at the same time, added subdivision(D) to Town of Islip Town Code § 68-149.1, which provides that "[a]bovegroundswimming pools shall be permitted as an accessory use on a parcel of land having less than12,000 square feet only after application is made to and granted by the Islip Town Zoning Boardof Appeals."
On December 18, 2006, the petitioners applied for a building permit to construct, inter alia, a12-foot by 30-foot above-ground swimming pool on their 10,000-square-foot lot. After thebuilding permit was denied, the petitioners filed an application with the Town of Islip ZoningBoard of Appeals (hereinafter the ZBA) seeking an area variance. The application attractedmuch public opposition and, after a public hearing, it was denied. The petitioners thencommenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78. The Supreme Court determined thatthe ZBA's determination was arbitrary and capricious, affected by an error of law, and an abuseof discretion. Consequently, the court granted the petition and remitted [*2]the matter to the ZBA to issue the requested variance. We reverse.
"The judicial responsibility is to review zoning decisions but not, absent proof of arbitraryand unreasonable action, to make them" (Matter of Cowan v Kern, 41 NY2d 591, 599[1977]; see Matter of Muth v Scheyer, 51 AD3d 799 [2008]; Matter of Merlotto vTown of Patterson Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 43 AD3d 926, 928 [2007]). Upon judicial review,the general rule is that, absent evidence of illegality, a court must sustain the determination if ithas a rational basis in the record before the zoning board (see Matter of Pecoraro v Board ofAppeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 608, 613 [2004]; Matter of Inlet Homes Corp.v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 769, 770 [2004]; Matter ofIfrah v Utschig, 98 NY2d 304, 308 [2002]; Matter of Twin County Recycling Corp. vYevoli, 90 NY2d 1000, 1002 [1997]; see also Matter of Gebbie v Mammina, 13NY3d 728 [2009]).
We disagree with the Supreme Court's conclusion that when the Town Board repealed thetemporary special exception, it signaled a relaxation of the law with respect to above-groundswimming pools on substandard lots. As the Supreme Court observed, the addition of TownCode § 68-149.1 (D) merely codified, in the local law, the authority of the ZBA to grantarea variances, a power it already held under Town Law § 267-b (3). Therefore, the onlychange in the law was to eliminate the special exception.
"Unlike a variance which gives permission to an owner to use property in a mannerinconsistent with a local zoning ordinance, a special exception gives permission to use propertyin a way that is consistent with the zoning ordinance, although not necessarily allowed as ofright" (Matter of Retail Prop. Trust v Board of Zoning Appeals of Town of Hempstead,98 NY2d 190, 195 [2002]; see Matter of North Shore Steak House v Board of Appeals ofInc. Vil. of Thomaston, 30 NY2d 238, 243 [1972]). "The inclusion of the permitted use inthe ordinance is tantamount to a legislative finding that the permitted use is in harmony with thegeneral zoning plan and will not adversely affect the neighborhood" (Matter of North ShoreSteak House v Board of Appeals of Inc. Vil. of Thomaston, 30 NY2d 238, 243 [1972];see Matter of Retail Prop. Trust v Board of Zoning Appeals of Town of Hempstead, 98NY2d 190, 195 [2002]). By removing the sole special exception applicable to above-groundswimming pools on Fire Island, the Town Board signaled that no swimming pool on a lot smallerthan 12,000 square feet was consistent with the general zoning plan.
In determining whether to grant an area variance, a zoning board must consider whether (1)an undesirable change will be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment tonearby properties will be created by the granting of the area variance, (2) the benefit sought bythe applicant can be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than anarea variance, (3) the requested area variance is substantial, (4) the proposed variance will havean adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood ordistrict if it is granted, and (5) the alleged difficulty was self-created (see Town Law§ 267-b [3] [b]).
Here, the ZBA properly applied the required balancing test and considered the relevantstatutory factors. Contrary to the determination of the Supreme Court, the denial of theapplication for an area variance had a rational basis and was not arbitrary or capricious. Theevidence before the ZBA established that there were no swimming pools on substandard lotswithin 600 feet of the petitioners' property. Moreover, within the relevant community ofapproximately 300 homes, there were only seven permanent above-ground swimming pools onsubstandard lots. Four of those predated the zoning regulations, one was on a lot that was 11,645square feet, and only two were allowed by variance. Contrary to the petitioners' contention, theZBA's granting of the two variances, neither of which involved lots that were near the subjectproperty, did not constitute a precedent from which the ZBA was required to explain a departure(cf. Matter of Tall Trees Constr. Corp. v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Huntington ,97 NY2d 86, 93 [2001]). The petitioners failed to establish that either case in which avariance was granted bore sufficient factual similarity to the subject application so as to warrantan explanation from the ZBA (see Matter of Conversions for Real Estate, LLC v Zoning Bd.of Appeals of Inc. Vil. of Roslyn, 31 AD3d 635, 636 [2006]; Matter of Spandorf v Boardof Appeals of Vil. of E. Hills, 167 AD2d 546, 547 [1990]).
Finally, the Supreme Court concluded that, since the petitioners' proposed pool satisfied thesetback requirement articulated in the Town of Islip Town Code, the petitioners' proposed poolwould have no greater impact on the community than a swimming pool on a standard sized lot.However, the degree of setback alone does not determine the impact to nearby properties. Tohold otherwise would [*3]render meaningless the Town Board'slegislative decision to limit above-ground swimming pools as of right to lots not less than 12,000square feet. Considering the unique nature of the Fire Island community, the ZBA'sdetermination that the proposed pool would constitute an overintensification of the developmenton the property and produce an undesirable change in the neighborhood was not irrational.Spolzino, J.P., Santucci, Florio and Lott, JJ., concur.