Matter of Khan (Mirage Limousine Serv., Inc.\MCommissioner ofLabor)
2009 NY Slip Op 07180 [66 AD3d 1098]
October 8, 2009
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 9, 2009


In the Matter of Mohamed M. Khan, Respondent. MirageLimousine Service, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor, Respondent.

—[*1]Law Offices of G. Oliver Koppell & Associates, New York City (G. Oliver Koppell ofcounsel), for appellant.

McNamee, Lochner, Titus & Williams, P.C., Albany (Francis J. Smith of counsel), forMohamed M. Khan, respondent.

Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel), forCommissioner of Labor, respondent.

Kane, J. Appeals from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedJuly 25, 2008, which ruled that Mirage Limousine Service, Inc. was liable for unemploymentinsurance contributions on remuneration paid to claimant and others similarly situated.

Mirage Limousine Service, Inc. operates a black car limousine business that provides itsclients transportation to and from prescribed destinations. In separate decisions, theUnemployment Insurance Appeal Board determined that an employer-employee relationshipexisted between Mirage and claimant, a limousine driver, and others similarly situated andassessed Mirage additional unemployment insurance contributions. Mirage now appeals bothdecisions.[*2]

We affirm. Initially, Mirage contends that it was deprivedof its due process rights by the Administrative Law Judge's denial of its request for anadjournment of the initial hearing on this matter in order to obtain counsel. We disagree.Although notice of the hearing date was given only a week before the hearing, Mirage was awareof its need for counsel when it requested the hearing months earlier. A review of the recordindicates that Mirage was afforded the opportunity, both prior to and at the start of the hearing,to either withdraw from the hearing and obtain counsel, with the understanding that a defaultjudgment would be entered against it, or to continue with the hearing without representation. Itwas further explained that if Mirage withdrew its appearance from the hearing, it would then beable to move to reopen the matter once counsel had been obtained, and a new hearing would beheld if the motion were granted. Mirage then decided to proceed with the hearing withoutcounsel. Under these circumstances, we cannot conclude that Mirage was deprived of dueprocess (see Matter of Crisalli [Commissioner of Labor], 279 AD2d 925, 925 [2001];Matter of Palmer [Rescue Mission Alliance of Syracuse—Commissioner ofLabor], 273 AD2d 525, 525-526 [2000]).

Turning to the merits, "the existence of an employment relationship is a factual issue for theBoard to decide and its determination will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence" (Matter of Automotive Serv. Sys., Inc.[Commissioner of Labor], 56 AD3d 854, 855 [2008]; see Matter of Parisi [Commissioner ofLabor], 54 AD3d 456, 457 [2008]). Here, the record establishes that Mirage assignedjobs to the drivers, including specific pick-up and drop-off locations, had a required dress codeand did not allow the drivers to use a substitute driver to complete an assignment. Mirage alsoset the rate collected from the passengers and handled all voucher billing. In addition, Miragepaid the drivers a set percentage of the fares charged, regardless of whether the client had paid.Given these facts, substantial evidence supports the Board's decision that the limousine driverswere employees of Mirage and it will not be disturbed, despite evidence in the record whichmight support a contrary conclusion (see Matter of Odyssey Transp., LLC [Commissioner of Labor], 62AD3d 1175, 1176 [2009]; Matter of Automotive Serv. Sys., Inc. [Commissioner ofLabor], 56 AD3d at 855; Matter ofEliraky [Crosslands Transp., Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 21 AD3d 1197,1198 [2005]; Matter of SpectacularLimo Link, Inc. [Commissioner of Labor], 21 AD3d 1172, 1173 [2005]; Matter ofDe Paiva [Olympic Limousine—Commissioner of Labor], 270 AD2d 534, 534-535[2000]).

Mercure, J.P., Lahtinen, McCarthy and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.