| Whisenant v Farazi |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 08468 [67 AD3d 535] |
| November 17, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Houston Whisenant, Respondent, v Rafiul Farazi et al.,Appellants. |
—[*1]
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Paul Wooten, J.), entered March 17, 2009, whichdenied defendants' motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint, unanimouslyreversed, on the law, and the motion granted. The Clerk is directed to enter judgment in favor ofdefendants dismissing the complaint.
Defendants met their initial burden of establishing prima facie that plaintiff did not sustain aserious injury to his left ankle through their examining orthopedist's affirmed report, whichshowed quantified range-of-motion findings within normal limits, and plaintiff's depositiontestimony which indicated little or no restriction of his daily activities due to thehospital-diagnosed ankle sprain. The burden having shifted, plaintiff's orthopedist's finding ofrange-of-motion limitations in plaintiff's left ankle was not sufficiently contemporaneous withthe accident to be probative of the claim (see e.g. Valentin v Pomilla, 59 AD3d 184, 185 [2009]; Thompson v Abbasi, 15 AD3d 95,97-98 [2005]). Plaintiff's testimony as to physical therapy attendance was unsupported by anydocumentation, and references by plaintiff's orthopedist to such therapy in his affirmed reportconstituted impermissible hearsay (seee.g. Toulson v Young Han Pae, 13 AD3d 317, 319 [2004]). There were admitted gaps intreatment, and plaintiff's orthopedist's offer of an explanation regarding the gaps, grounded, inpart, on plaintiff's lack of insurance and lack of financial means, was hearsay, and did notsatisfactorily explain the cessation of treatment under the circumstances (see generally Pommells v Perez, 4NY3d 566 [2005]). Plaintiff's MRI scan, which, according to the radiologist, evidencedpartial tears to two ligaments in plaintiff's left ankle, was taken three years post-accident, tooremote to be probative of plaintiff's accident-related claim, particularly since the radiologistoffered no opinion as to a causal connection between the ligament tears and the accident (see e.g. Dembele v Cambisaca, 59AD3d 352 [2009]). Plaintiff's orthopedist's opinion that the ligament tears were caused bythe accident was not medically explained.
Plaintiff's serious injury claim predicated on an alleged inability to engage in substantiallyall his daily activities for 90 of the first 180 days post-accident was refuted by his owntestimony. Plaintiff testified that he was confined to the house for two days, missed only threedays of work and had some ankle pain when walking long distances, playing tennis and [*2]swimming. Further, plaintiff failed to offer the requisite competentmedical proof to substantiate his serious injury under the 90/180 day category (see DeSouza v Hamilton, 55 AD3d352 [2008]).
Plaintiff's belated claim of serious injury under the significant disfigurement category ofInsurance Law § 5102 (d) was not pleaded, and is therefore waived. In any event, thephotographic evidence in the record, allegedly showing the abrasion scar, is unclear and of noprobative value. Concur—Saxe, J.P., Nardelli, Buckley, Acosta and Friedman, JJ.[Prior Case History: 2009 NY Slip Op 30564(U).]