| Matter of Robinson v Fischer |
| 2009 NY Slip Op 09770 [68 AD3d 1687] |
| December 30, 2009 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| In the Matter of Andrew Robinson, Appellant, v Brian Fischer,Commissioner, New York State Department of Correctional Services,Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Rajit S. Dosanjh of counsel), forrespondent-respondent.
Appeal from a judgment (denominated order) of the Supreme Court, Erie County (ShirleyTroutman, A.J.), entered June 26, 2008 in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78. Thejudgment dismissed the petition.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously modified on the lawby granting the petition in part, annulling those parts of the determination finding that petitionerviolated inmate rules 100.10 (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [1] [i]) and 104.11 (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [5][ii]) and by vacating the recommended loss of good time and as modified the judgment isaffirmed without costs, and the matter is remitted to respondent for further proceedings inaccordance with the following memorandum: Petitioner appeals from a judgment dismissing hispetition in which he sought to annul the determination finding that he violated various inmaterules. We note at the outset that, at the commencement of the tier III hearing, petitioner pleadedguilty to violating inmate rule 104.13, creating a disturbance (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [5] [iv]), andwe therefore do not address that charge. Petitioner also was charged with violating inmate rule100.10, assaulting an inmate (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [1] [i]); inmate rule 104.11, engaging inviolent conduct (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [5] [ii]); and inmate rule 107.10, interfering with anemployee (7 NYCRR 270.2 [B] [8] [i]). Before the hearing was conducted, petitioner hadrequested that the victim of the purported assault be called as a witness. Although the employeeassistant form in the record before us indicates that the witness refused to testify, no witnessrefusal form was signed and no reason for the refusal to testify was set forth on the employeeassistant form. At the hearing, petitioner again requested that the victim be called as a witness.At the request of the Hearing Officer, a correction officer asked the witness whether he wouldtestify. The correction officer reported to the Hearing Officer that the witness refused to testify,but the correction officer provided no reason for the refusal nor is there any indication in therecord that the witness was asked why he refused to testify.
We agree with petitioner that the Hearing Officer's failure to make any attempt to ascertainthe reason for the refusal of the witness to testify violated petitioner's rights under 7 [*2]NYCRR 254.5 (a) (see e.g. Matter of Barnes v LeFevre, 69NY2d 649, 650 [1986]; Matter ofAlvarez v Goord, 30 AD3d 118 [2006]; Matter of Martinez v Goord, 15 AD3d 737, 738 [2005]). "Underthe circumstances presented here, where petitioner does not dispute that the evidence in therecord was sufficient to sustain the determination, the appropriate remedy is to remit the matterfor a new hearing in which petitioner should be provided with the reason for the witness's refusalto testify" (Martinez, 15 AD3d at 738; see Alvarez, 30 AD3d at 120-121). Asnoted, petitioner pleaded guilty to the charge of creating a disturbance and we therefore confirmthe determination with respect to that charge. We also confirm the determination with respect tothe charge of interfering with an employee inasmuch as that conduct occurred after the assault,and we agree with respondent that the witness would not have had relevant testimony to offer onthat charge. We therefore modify the judgment by granting the petition in part, annulling thoseparts of the determination finding that petitioner violated inmate rules 100.10 and 104.11 and byvacating the recommended loss of good time, and we remit the matter to respondent for a newhearing on the remaining two charges and for reconsideration of the recommended loss of goodtime. Present—Hurlbutt, J.P., Martoche, Smith, Carni and Pine, JJ.