| Matter of Grace (Astrocom Elecs., Inc.\MCommissioner ofLabor) |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 00425 [69 AD3d 1156] |
| January 21, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of David J. Grace et al., Respondents.Astrocom Electronics, Inc., Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
—[*1] James W. Cooper, Warrensburg, for David J. Grace and another, respondents.
Lahtinen, J. Appeals (1) from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board,filed June 11, 2008, which ruled that claimants were entitled to receive unemployment insurancebenefits, and (2) from a decision of said Board, filed October 6, 2008, which, uponreconsideration, adhered to its prior decision.
Claimant David J. Grace worked in the purchasing department for the employer for morethan a year and claimant Sheri A. Lepore worked as a sales representative for the employer formore than three years. Grace and Lepore had a personal relationship with each other which, theyalleged, subjected them to constant harassment in the workplace. After Grace received a poorperformance review, during which he was personally insulted, Grace complained to a member ofhuman resources, who suggested he file a complaint with the Department of Labor. Graceimmediately left work to file the complaint. Later that day, Lepore was called into a conferenceroom with the company's owners and was questioned about Grace's behavior. Apparently,Lepore was also advised that she should stay away from Grace or it would cause problems withher employment. After the meeting, Lepore broke out into hives and was forced to leave work.After both Grace and Lepore failed to return to work, both were considered by the employer tohave terminated their employment. Following hearings, an administrative law judge sustainedthe Department of Labor's initial determination disqualifying both claimants from receivingunemployment insurance benefits on the basis that they voluntarily separated from employmentwithout good cause. Subsequently, the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board reversed thatdetermination, finding that claimants were eligible for benefits because they had abandoned theiremployment for good cause. Upon reconsideration, the Board adhered to its prior decision. Theemployer appeals from both decisions and we now affirm.
Whether a claimant has voluntarily left employment is a factual issue to be resolved by theBoard, and its determination will not be disturbed so long as it is supported by substantialevidence, despite the existence of evidence which would have supported a contrary result (see Matter of Viera [City School Dist. ofCity of N.Y.—Commissioner of Labor], 48 AD3d 870, 871 [2008]; Matter of Kuryla [Finger LakesCommunity Coll.—Commissioner of Labor], 45 AD3d 1129, 1130-1131 [2007];Matter of Fahey[Youner—Commissioner of Labor], 41 AD3d 1124, 1125 [2007]). Here, theBoard credited Lepore's testimony that, subsequent to Grace leaving to file a complaint about theemployer, she was confined against her will and subjected to questioning and threats from theemployer and that this behavior constituted harassment which created a hostile workenvironment (compare Matter of Fradys [Commissioner of Labor], 308 AD2d 672, 673[2003]; Matter of Turano [Sweeney], 239 AD2d 747, 748 [1997]). Furthermore, whetherthe harassment of Lepore constituted retaliation against both her and Grace for the filing of hiscomplaint presented a credibility issue for the Board to resolve and, thus, we find that, havingcredited claimants' version of events, substantial evidence supports the Board's determinationthat good cause existed for Grace to leave his employment (see Matter of Miles [Commissioner of Labor], 54 AD3d 467, 468[2008]; Matter of Ramos [Commissioner of Labor], 306 AD2d 791 [2003]).
Finally, we find no merit to the employer's contention that it was deprived of due process,where it expressly was advised of and acknowledged that it understood its rights and theprocedures to be followed during the hearing and was given the opportunity to present evidenceand witnesses and cross-examine claimants (see Matter of Rogers [Commissioner of Labor], 38 AD3d 1117,1118 [2007]; Matter of Grogan [RoyalTemporaries, Inc./Stafkings—Commissioner of Labor], 19 AD3d 972, 973[2005]). The employer's remaining contentions have been considered and rejected.
Peters, J.P., Malone Jr., Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.