Matter of Wilcox v Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.
2010 NY Slip Op 00613 [69 AD3d 1264]
January 28, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 10, 2010


In the Matter of the Claim of Clyde F. Wilcox, Respondent, vNiagara Mohawk Power Corporation et al., Appellants.Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent.

—[*1]Gitto & Niefer, L.L.P, Binghamton (Jason M. Carlton of counsel), for appellants. PeterW. Hill, Oneonta, for Clyde F. Wilcox, respondent.

Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Iris A. Steel of counsel), forWorkers' Compensation Board, respondent.

Kavanagh, J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed August 5,2008, which ruled that apportionment did not apply to claimant's workers' compensation award.

Claimant sustained a work-related injury to his right ankle in December 2004, 12 years afterundergoing surgery on the same ankle for a condition that was wholly unrelated to hisemployment. In support of claimant's application for workers' compensation benefits followingthe 2004 incident, claimant's treating physician opined that claimant suffered a 45% scheduleloss of use of his right foot and did not attribute any portion of the loss to the noncompensable1992 injury. A medical examiner who evaluated claimant on behalf of the self-insured employerand its third-party administrator (hereinafter collectively referred to as the employer) agreed thatclaimant had a 45% schedule loss of use, but concluded that such loss was 50% attributable toclaimant's earlier injury. After a hearing, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge granted claimanta 45% schedule loss of use award and rejected the employer's claim of apportionment. That[*2]determination was upheld by the Workers' CompensationBoard, prompting this appeal by the employer.

We affirm. Apportionment may be applicable in a schedule loss of use case if the medicalevidence establishes that the claimant's prior injury—had it beencompensable—would have resulted in a schedule loss of use finding (see Matter of Scally v Ravena CoeymansSelkirk Cent. School Dist., 31 AD3d 836, 838 [2006]). Here, however, the Boarddetermined that there was insufficient medical evidence on which to base such a conclusion. Inthat regard, medical records and reports relevant to claimant's 1992 surgery were unavailable,and neither expert was provided with any objective documentation indicating to what extent, ifany, claimant's use of his right foot or range of motion had been impaired as a result of the priorinjury. Consequently, although the medical examiner who evaluated claimant for the employeropined that claimant had a preexisting 22.5% loss of use, claimant's treating physician testifiedthat any opinion regarding a preexisting loss of use would be entirely speculative. Thusconfronted with conflicting medical evidence, the Board was authorized to credit the opinion ofone expert over that of another (seeMatter of Peterson v Faculty Student Assn., 57 AD3d 1139, 1141 [2008], lvdismissed 12 NY3d 777 [2009]; Matter of Dimitriadis v One Source, 53 AD3d 704, 705 [2008]).

Moreover, notwithstanding the existence of a prior noncompensable condition, a review ofthe record reveals that claimant was fully employed and able to perform all of his job dutiesbefore December 2004. Accordingly, substantial evidence supports the Board's determinationthat apportionment is not warranted (see Matter of Krebs v Town of Ithaca, 293 AD2d883, 883-884 [2002], lv denied 100 NY2d 501 [2003]).

Peters, J.P., Rose, Lahtinen and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed,without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.