Matter of Mark T. v Joyanna U.
2010 NY Slip Op 00740 [70 AD3d 1068]
February 4, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 31, 2010


In the Matter of Mark T., Appellant, v Joyanna U. et al.,Respondents. (And Another Related Proceeding.)

—[*1]Christopher A. Pogson, Binghamton, for appellant.

John D. Cadore, Binghamton, for Joyanna U., respondent.

Teresa C. Mulliken, Harpersfield, for Paul V., respondent.

Carmen Garufi, Law Guardian, Binghamton.

Malone Jr., J. Appeal from an order of the Family Court of Broome County (Pines, J.),entered March 27, 2008, which, among other things, in a proceeding pursuant to Family Ct Actarticle 5, granted the motion of respondent Joyanna U. to dismiss the petition.

In December 1996, petitioner and respondent Joyanna U. (hereinafter the mother) engaged ina sexual relationship. At that time, the mother was also engaged in a sexual relationship withrespondent Paul V. (hereinafter respondent). The following month, after petitioner assaultedrespondent, petitioner was arrested and incarcerated. The mother and respondent were marriedseveral days later and the subject child was born on October 26, 1997. After respondent and themother divorced in 2007, petitioner commenced this paternity proceeding, seeking a DNA test toestablish that he was the biological father of the subject child and, in addition, petitioned forvisitation. The mother moved to dismiss the paternity petition based on the ground of equitableestoppel. After conducting a hearing, Family Court granted the motion and dismissed thevisitation petition. Petitioner appealed.[*2]

We first note that, upon this Court's initial considerationof this appeal, it was revealed at oral argument that the Law Guardian assigned to represent thechild on the appeal—who differed from the Law Guardian at Family Court—hadnot met with or spoken to the child. For that reason, we withheld decision and ordered that a newLaw Guardian be appointed (Matter ofMark T. v Joyanna U., 64 AD3d 1092 [2009]), who now appears on behalf of the child.

Turning to the merits, equitable estoppel may "preclude a man who claims to be a child'sbiological father from asserting his paternity when he acquiesced in the establishment of a strongparent-child bond between the child and another man" (Matter of Shondel J. v Mark D., 7 NY3d 320, 327 [2006];see Family Ct Act § 532 [a]). Here, because the child was born during hismarriage to the mother, the child is legally presumed to be respondent's biological child (seeDavid L. v Cindy Pearl L., 208 AD2d 502, 503 [1994]). Although petitioner nonethelessclaims that the mother told him that he was the child's father soon after the child's birth,petitioner waited nearly 11 years to file the instant paternity petition, despite having knowledgethat respondent was holding himself out as the child's father (see e.g. Matter of Richard W. vRoberta Y., 240 AD2d 812, 814 [1997], lv denied 90 NY2d 809 [1997]). Moreover,petitioner was incarcerated for at least 7 out of the 10 years of the child's life before thisproceeding and, consequently, only recently began spending time with him.

Meanwhile, during the last 11 years, respondent believed that he was the child's father,raised and cared for the child, and treated him no differently from the other four children of themarriage. Although the mother and respondent are now divorced, respondent exercises visitationwith the child and is obligated to pay the mother child support. Indeed, until the mother recentlytold the child that petitioner could be his father, the child believed that respondent was his fatherand he bears respondent's surname. Despite the Law Guardian's persuasive contention to thecontrary, considering the facts of this case, including the "recognized and operative parent-childrelationship" that the child maintains with respondent (Matter of Lorie F. v Raymond F.,239 AD2d 659, 660 [1997]), we cannot say that Family Court erred in finding that an orderdirecting genetic testing to establish paternity would be contrary to the child's best interests(see Matter of Peter BB. v Robin CC., 256 AD2d 889, 890 [1998]; Matter of RichardW. v Roberta Y., 240 AD2d at 814-815; Purificati v Paricos, 154 AD2d 360,361-362 [1989]).

Spain, J.P., Lahtinen, Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.