| Matter of Diaz v Fischer |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 00752 [70 AD3d 1082] |
| February 4, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Frederick Diaz, Petitioner, v Brian Fischer, asCommissioner of Correctional Services, Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of the SupremeCourt, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondent which foundpetitioner guilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules.
In April 2008, petitioner, a prison inmate, was served with a misbehavior report charginghim with assaulting staff, engaging in violent conduct, interfering with an employee anddisturbing the order of the facility after he allegedly attacked a correction officer withoutprovocation. A tier III disciplinary hearing was held, after which petitioner was found guilty ofall charges. However, that determination was reversed on administrative appeal and a newhearing ordered. Following the rehearing, petitioner was again found guilty of all charges and hissubsequent administrative appeal was unavailing. He thereafter commenced this CPLR article 78proceeding and we now annul.
Inmates charged with violating prison disciplinary rules have a constitutional right to callwitnesses, provided that those witnesses may offer testimony that is material and not redundant,and doing so does not pose a threat to institutional safety or correctional goals (see Matter of Caldwell v Goord, 34AD3d 1173, 1174-1175 [2006]; Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30 AD3d 118, 119-120 [2006]). Here,petitioner attempted to call, among others, an investigator from the Inspector General's officeand a psychologist who examined petitioner shortly after the [*2]incident. Petitioner's defense at both hearings was that, contrary tothe accusation that he assaulted the correction officer without provocation, he was actuallyattacked by the officer in retaliation for his work with the grievance office. Petitioner explainedto the Hearing Officer that the investigator commenced an investigation of the incident shortlyafter its occurrence and, in addition to questioning those witnesses who testified at the firsthearing, was planning to interview inmate witnesses who had refused to testify due to fear ofretaliation. However, the Hearing Officer denied the investigator as a witness on the ground thathe was "not in the area of the alleged incident."[FN*]The Hearing Officer also denied testimony from the psychologist, despite the fact that the firstdetermination finding petitioner guilty had been administratively reversed based on the fact thatthe record failed to indicate how petitioner's mental health status was considered. Inasmuch asthese witnesses may have provided testimony that was material, their absence substantiallyprejudiced petitioner's ability to present his defense and the Hearing Officer denied theirtestimony for reasons other than institutional safety, we find such denial to be error (seeMatter of Caldwell v Goord, 34 AD3d at 1174-1175; Matter of Reyes v Goord, 20 AD3d 830, 831 [2005]). Furthermore,as the deprivation constituted a violation of petitioner's constitutional right to call witnesses,rather than merely his statutory right, we find the appropriate remedy to be expungement (seeMatter of Caldwell v Goord, 34 AD3d at 1175; Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30 AD3dat 120).
In light of our holding, petitioner's remaining contentions, including that the determinationwas not supported by substantial evidence, have been rendered academic.
Cardona, P.J., Peters, Spain, Lahtinen and Stein, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determinationis annulled, without costs, petition granted and respondent is directed to expunge all referencesto this matter from petitioner's institutional record.
Footnote *: We note that investigators fromthe Inspector General's office routinely testify in prison disciplinary hearings (see Matter of McLean v Fischer, 63AD3d 1468, 1469 [2009]; Matterof Vizcaino v Selsky, 26 AD3d 574, 574 [2006], lv denied 7 NY3d 708 [2006];Matter of Antinuche v Goord, 16AD3d 743, 744 [2005]), as do other witnesses who have gained information throughinvestigation, rather than personal observation (see Matter of Rivera v Selsky, 43 AD3d 1210, 1210 [2007]; Matter of Mendez v Goord, 21 AD3d1191, 1192 [2005]).