| Matter of Roberson v Bezio |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 01405 [70 AD3d 1226] |
| February 18, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Edward Roberson, Petitioner, v Norman Bezio, asDirector of Special Housing and Inmate Disciplinary Programs,Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
Cardona, P.J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order ofthe Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of the Commissioner ofCorrectional Services which found petitioner guilty of violating certain prison disciplinary rules.
After an inmate (hereinafter the victim) was assaulted and identified petitioner as one of hisattackers in a photo array, petitioner was charged in a misbehavior report with creating adisturbance, assaulting an inmate, engaging in violent conduct and being out of place. He wasfound guilty of the charges following a tier III disciplinary hearing. The determination was lateraffirmed on administrative appeal with a modified penalty, and this CPLR article 78 proceedingensued.
Upon review of this record, we conclude that petitioner was improperly denied theopportunity to call the victim as a witness at the hearing in violation of his constitutional right todo so as codified in 7 NYCRR 254.5. In setting forth that conditional right, the regulationprovides that, where a hearing officer denies an inmate's request for a witness, the officer "shallgive the inmate a written statement stating the reasons for the denial, including the specific threatto institutional safety or correctional goals" (7 NYCRR 254.5 [a]; see Matter of Laureano v[*2]Kuhlmann, 75 NY2d 141, 146 [1990]; Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30 AD3d118, 119 [2006]). Here, the victim clearly had information relevant to the charges and, ifpermitted to do so, petitioner could have questioned him regarding the statement he made tocorrection officers immediately after the attack, as well as the victim's later identification of himfrom a photo array. In denying petitioner's request in writing, however, the Hearing Officer citedsafety and security concerns related to an ongoing criminal investigation and the desire toprevent possible intimidation of the victim. Notably, the record fails to support the claim that thegoal of protecting institutional safety was furthered by denying the victim as a witness and, infact, respondent acknowledges herein that petitioner should not have been prevented fromcalling this witness. Moreover, insofar as the victim's testimony could have been taken out ofpetitioner's presence (see 7 NYCRR 254.5 [b]), the prevention of witness intimidationwas not a viable alternative reason for denying petitioner's request under the circumstancespresented herein.
Turning to the issue of remedy, we agree with respondent that the matter must be remittedfor a new hearing (see Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30 AD3d at 121). Given that theHearing Officer put forth a good faith reason for the denial, we find that there was no "clearconstitutional violation" requiring expungement (id. at 121; compare Matter of Caldwell v Goord,34 AD3d 1173, 1175 [2006]). Therefore, inasmuch as we find that there was a violation ofpetitioner's regulatory right to call witnesses, a new hearing is appropriate.
In light of the above disposition, it is unnecessary to consider petitioner's remainingchallenges.
Peters, Spain, Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination is annulled,without costs, and matter remitted to the Department of Correctional Services for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.