Sullivan v Woods
2010 NY Slip Op 01566 [70 AD3d 1286]
February 25, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 31, 2010


Kenneth M. Sullivan et al., Respondents, v Jason C. Woods, Sr.,Appellant.

—[*1]O'Connor, O'Connor, Bresee & First, P.C., Albany (George J. Hoffman, Jr. of counsel),for appellant.

Schur & Casale, P.L.L.C., Mayfield (Ronald R. Schur of counsel), for respondents.

Lahtinen, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Catena, J.), entered October 21,2008 in Montgomery County, which, among other things, granted plaintiffs' cross motion forpermission to move the location of an easement.

Plaintiffs and defendant own adjoining parcels of land in the Town of Root, MontgomeryCounty. In 1964, plaintiffs' predecessor in title reserved an easement in favor of defendant'spredecessor "for ingress and egress over the present roadway" to allow access from the camp ondefendant's property over plaintiffs' property to a public road. After years of dispute regardingthe extent and scope of the easement, plaintiffs commenced this action for, among other things,declaratory judgment pursuant to RPAPL article 15. Defendant asserted various counterclaims.Following some disclosure, defendant moved for summary judgment declaring that he has aneasement over the existing roadway. Plaintiffs cross-moved for an order allowing them torelocate part of the roadway by which defendant accessed his camp. Supreme Court, as relevanton appeal, granted defendant summary judgment on his counterclaim that he has an expresseasement over plaintiffs' property and also granted plaintiffs summary judgment on their requestto move part of the roadway. Defendant appeals.

"[W]here the intention in granting an easement is to afford only a right of ingress and egress,it is the right of passage, and not any right in a physical passageway itself, that is granted to theeasement holder" (Lewis v Young, 92 NY2d 443, 449 [1998]; Marek vWoodcock, 277 [*2]AD2d 864, 865 [2000], lvdismissed 96 NY2d 792 [2001]). "[U]nder certain circumstances and 'in the absence of ademonstrated intent to provide otherwise, a landowner burdened by an express easement ofingress and egress may [change it]' " (Chekijian v Mans, 34 AD3d 1029, 1031 [2006],lv denied 8 NY3d 806 [2007], quoting Lewis v Young, 92 NY2d at 449). Indetermining whether there is an intent to provide for more than the right of passage, we look firstto the words used in creating the easement (see Chekijian v Mans, 34 AD3d at 1031).Where, as here, there is merely a general reference to an existing road, without more, an intentfor a fixed location of the easement is not inferred (see id. at 1031; Green vBlum, 13 AD3d 1037, 1038 [2004]; see also Lewis v Young, 92 NY2d at 453-454;cf. Estate Ct., LLC v Schnall, 49 AD3d 1076, 1078 [2008] [relocation not permittedwhere judgment establishing prescriptive easement "expressly defined it by reference to a surveymap showing the precise path of the easement in detail, including exact distances and coursesand with reference to monuments, adjacent properties, highwater lines and other landmarks"]).

However, determining that a landowner is not precluded as a matter of law from relocatingthe easement does not end the analysis. Next, a "balancing test" must be employed in which the"landowner, consonant with the beneficial use and development of its property, can move thatright of way, so long as the landowner bears the expense of the relocation, and so long as thechange does not frustrate the parties' intent or object in creating the right of way, does notincrease the burden on the easement holder, and does not significantly lessen the utility of theright of way" (Lewis v Young, 92 NY2d at 452). Where the landowner seeks to establishthe right to relocate an easement in a summary judgment motion, the landowner, consistent withwell-settled procedures, has the initial burden of satisfactorily establishing that the elements ofthe balancing test all support relocating the easement to the place desired by the landowner as amatter of law (see generally Winegrad v New York Univ. Med. Ctr., 64 NY2d 851, 853[1985]).

Plaintiffs failed to meet their initial burden. The affidavit of plaintiff Kenneth M. Sullivanmerely states that he "does intend to move the easement in the future, and will do so consistentwith the law." His attorney repeats the relevant elements, but makes no effort beyond conclusorystatements to show how those elements are satisfied. The reproduction of a survey mapcontained in the record, which was attached to the attorney's affirmation and purports to showthe proposed relocation of part of the road, is of such poor quality as to be of virtually noassistance and certainly does not establish all the relevant elements as a matter of law.Accordingly, plaintiffs' cross motion should not have been granted (see Green v Blum,13 AD3d at 1038).

Mercure, J.P., Spain, Rose and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is modified, onthe law, with costs to defendant, by reversing so much thereof as granted plaintiffs' cross motionfor summary judgment permitting the easement to be moved; cross motion denied; and, as somodified, affirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.