| Matter of Citizens Emergency Comm. to Preserve Preserv. vTierney |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 01572 [70 AD3d 576] |
| February 25, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| In the Matter of Citizens Emergency Committee to PreservePreservation, Respondent, v Robert B. Tierney, Chair of the New York City LandmarksPreservation Commission, et al., Appellants. |
—[*1] Whitney North Seymour, Jr., New York, for respondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Marilyn Shafer, J.), entered November 21, 2008,which granted the petition challenging respondents' failure to take any action on certain requestsfor landmark designation and directed the promulgation of new procedures for expediting suchrequests, unanimously reversed, on the law, without costs, the petition denied and this CPLRarticle 78 proceeding dismissed.
To establish standing, an association or organization such as petitioner "must show that atleast one of its members would have standing to sue" (New York State Assn. of Nurse Anesthetists v Novello, 2 NY3d207, 211 [2004]). In other words, petitioner must show that one or more of itsmembers—as distinct from the general public—has suffered an injury in fact, andmust demonstrate that the injury falls within the zone of interests protected by the legal authoritybeing invoked (Society of Plastics Indus. v County of Suffolk, 77 NY2d 761, 771-774[1991]). In environmental or preservation matters, standing may be established by proof thatagency action will directly harm the petitioner's members in their use or enjoyment of the naturalresources or area in question (seeMatter of Save the Pine Bush, Inc. v Common Council of City of Albany, 13 NY3d 297[2009]; Matter of Committee to Preserve Brighton Beach & Manhattan Beach v PlanningCommn. of City of N.Y., 259 AD2d 26, 32 [1999]).
Petitioner failed to demonstrate standing to sue. While the petition alleges that its membersare dedicated to preservation, "interest" and "injury" are not synonymous (see Matter of New York State PsychiatricAssn., Inc. v Mills, 29 AD3d 1058, 1059 [2006], lv denied 7 NY3d 708 [2006]).A general—or even special—interest in the subject matter is insufficient to conferstanding, absent an injury distinct from the public in the particular circumstances of the case(see Save the Pine Bush, 13 NY3d at 305-306; Matter of Heritage Coalition v City ofIthaca Planning & Dev. Bd., 228 AD2d 862, 864 [1996], lv denied 88 NY2d 809[1996]). The petition does not allege that petitioner's members have been affected differentlyfrom any other members of the public. To the contrary, it alleges that petitioner's members andmembers of the public are [*2]similarly affected by theCommission's action.
Even were we to find that petitioner has standing, the court erred in granting mandamus, asthere is no statutory requirement that the Commission adhere to a particular procedure indetermining whether to consider a property for designation (see New York Civ. Liberties Union v State of New York, 4 NY3d175, 184 [2005]; Saslow v Cephas, 198 AD2d 53 [1993], lv denied 83NY2d 757 [1994]). Indeed, the Commission's regulations on "Calendaring" provide that theCommission "may, upon the adoption of a motion, calendar an item to be considered forlandmark designation" (63 RCNY 1-02 [emphasis added]). We have previously rejected claimssimilar to that made here, recognizing the Commission's broad discretion in controlling itscalendar without the necessity of creating a public record in that respect (see Matter of Landmark West! vBurden, 15 AD3d 308, 309 [2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 713 [2005]). Contrary toSupreme Court's finding, respondents have articulated reasonable bases for the Commission'shandling of the specific properties and districts cited in the petition, with an explanation fordelays in the designation process. Accordingly, the court erred in holding the Commission'sconduct arbitrary and capricious with respect to five of the properties (see generally Matterof Teachers Ins. & Annuity Assn. of Am. v City of New York, 82 NY2d 35, 44 [1993]).Concur—Gonzalez, P.J., Mazzarelli, Nardelli, Acosta and Abdus-Salaam, JJ.