| Matter of Midgette v New York State Div. of Parole |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 01652 [70 AD3d 1039] |
| February 23, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Tyrone Midgette, Respondent, v NewYork State Division of Parole, Appellant. |
—[*1] Tyrone Midgette, Beacon, N.Y., respondent pro se.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the New YorkState Board of Parole dated September 24, 2007, denying the petitioner's application to bereleased to parole, the appeal is from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Dutchess County(Marlow, J.), dated January 7, 2009, which granted the petition, annulled the determination, andremitted the matter to the New York State Division of Parole for a reconstruction hearing as tothe petitioner's sentencing or, in the alternative, a de novo parole hearing at which it must affordthe petitioner a favorable inference on the issue of a sentencing recommendation.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed, on the law, without costs or disbursements, thepetition is denied, the determination is confirmed, and the proceeding is dismissed.
In this proceeding, the petitioner, Tyrone Midgette, challenges a September 24, 2007,determination of the New York State Board of Parole (hereinafter the Board), denying hisapplication to be released to parole. The petitioner contends that the failure of the Board toconsider the minutes of his sentencing proceeding was improper (see Executive Law§ 259-i [1] [a]; Matter of Edwards v Travis, 304 AD2d 576 [2003]). The SupremeCourt, after finding that the failure was indeed improper and that the minutes were unavailable,ordered a reconstruction hearing of the petitioner's sentencing proceeding or, in the alternative, ade novo parole hearing at which the Board must afford the petitioner a favorable inference on theissue of a sentencing recommendation. Subsequent to the judgment appealed from, however, thepetitioner again appeared before the Board and was again denied release. Consequently, theappeal must be dismissed as academic unless an exception to the mootness doctrine isapplicable. In that respect, the record contains an affidavit from a senior court reporter in theSupreme Court, New York County, stating that the minutes cannot be found. It is therefore likelythat the substantial issue with respect to the sentencing minutes will recur. Furthermore, thesubstantial issue of a favorable inference is likely to recur but evade review. Consequently, thiscase presents an exception to the mootness doctrine (see Matter of Lebron v Alexander,68 AD3d 1476 [2009]; Matter of McLaurin v New York State Bd. of Parole, 27 AD3d565, 566 [2006]; Matter of Standley v New York State Div. of Parole, 40 AD3d 1344,1345 [2007]).
A parole determination may be set aside only when the Board's determination to deny [*2]the petitioner early release evinced "irrationality bordering onimpropriety" (Matter of Russo v New York State Bd. of Parole, 50 NY2d 69, 77 [1980];see Matter of Silmon v Travis, 95 NY2d 470, 476 [2000]; Matter of Briguglio v NewYork State Bd. of Parole, 24 NY2d 21, 29 [1969]). The burden is on the petitioner to make aconvincing demonstration of entitlement to such relief (see Matter of McLain v New YorkState Div. of Parole, 204 AD2d 456 [1994]). The only issue raised on this appeal is whetherthe Board's failure to obtain the minutes of the petitioner's sentencing proceeding entitled thepetitioner to relief. We hold that it does not.
In the absence of any indication that the unavailable sentencing minutes contained anyrecommendation as to parole, the failure of the Board to obtain and consider those minutes didnot prejudice the petitioner (see Matter of Porter v Alexander, 63 AD3d 945, 946[2009]). Moreover, we note that the Board requested the minutes from the Supreme Court, NewYork County, before the hearing and made numerous unsuccessful requests as well followingthat hearing. Consequently, the Board is not responsible for the failure of the Supreme Court,New York County, to preserve the minutes (see Matter of Lebron v Alexander, 68 AD3d1476 [2009]; cf. L 2008, ch 141, § 1).
Finally, because any remaining undecided claims presented in the petition with respect to theBoard's determination are now academic, we need not remit that matter to the Supreme Court,Dutchess County. Fisher, J.P., Florio, Belen and Austin, JJ., concur.