| Matter of Fedak v Judge |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 02146 [71 AD3d 892] |
| March 16, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Stefanie Nicole Fedak et al.,Respondents-Appellants, v Jonathan J. Judge, Appellant-Respondent, and Board ofElections in the City of New York, Respondent. |
—[*1]
In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102 to invalidate an independentnominating petition nominating Jonathan J. Judge as the candidate of the People's Voice Party ina special election to be held on March 23, 2010, for the public office of Member of the NewYork City Council, 44th Council District, Jonathan J. Judge appeals from (1) an order of theSupreme Court, Kings County (Martin, J.), dated March 9, 2010, which denied his application todismiss the proceeding, and (2) a final order of the same court dated March 9, 2010, which, uponthe order and after a hearing, granted the petition and directed that his name be removed from theballot, and Stephanie Nicole Fedak and David G. Greenfield cross-appeal from so much of thefinal order as determined that David G. Greenfield would not have been permitted to proceed asan aggrieved candidate if the petition were dismissed insofar as asserted by Stephanie NicoleFedak.
Ordered that the appeal from the order is dismissed, without costs or disbursements; and it isfurther,
Ordered that the cross appeal is dismissed, as Stephanie Nicole Fedak and David G.Greenfield are not aggrieved by the final order cross-appealed from, without costs ordisbursements (see CPLR 5511); and it is further,
Ordered that the final order is affirmed on the appeal, without costs or disbursements.
The appeal from the intermediate order must be dismissed. No appeal lies as of right from anorder which does not decide a motion made on notice (see CPLR 5701 [a] [2]), and wedecline to grant leave to appeal since the right of direct appeal from the intermediate orderterminated with the entry of the final order in the proceeding (see Matter of Aho, 39NY2d 241, 248 [1976]; Matter of Myersv Baisley, 65 AD3d 649 [2009]). The issues raised on the appeal from the order arebrought up for review and have been considered on the appeal from the final order (seeCPLR 5501 [a] [1]).
Election Law § 1-106 states, in relevant part, that "[a]ll papers required to be filedpursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall, unless otherwise provided, be filed between thehours of nine a.m. and five p.m." (Election Law § 1-106 [1]).[*2]
On February 19, 2010, the objector, Stephanie NicoleFedak, filed a general objection to an independent nominating petition filed with the Board ofElections in the City of New York (hereinafter the Board of Elections) by Jonathan J. Judge forthe public office of Member of the New York City Council for the 44th Council District. Thegeneral objection was stamped "received" by the Board of Elections at 8:54 a.m., or six minutesbefore the prescribed time for filing set forth in Election Law § 1-106 (1). Subsequently,Fedak and David G. Greenfield, a candidate for the same public office sought by Judge,commenced the instant proceeding to invalidate Judge's independent nominating petition. TheSupreme Court denied Judge's application to dismiss the proceeding on the ground that Fedak'sgeneral objection was not timely filed, granted the petition to invalidate, and directed thatJudge's name be removed from the ballot.
The issue raised on appeal is whether the filing of the general objection at 8:54 a.m. renderedit invalid and, therefore, requires the dismissal of the proceeding to invalidate, insofar as assertedby Fedak. We hold that, under the particular circumstances of this case, the filing of the generalobjection was not untimely. The filing of the general objection in this case was made on a daythat was within the applicable period for filing objections and at a time when the Board ofElections was open for business (see Election Law § 3-214 [3]), and the generalobjection was accepted for filing by an employee of the Board of Elections. Moreover, this is nota case involving a late filing. Rather, the filing occurred before the deadline for the filing ofobjections (see Matter of Cozzolino v Columbia County Bd. of Elections, 218 AD2d 921[1995]; see also Matter of Serrano v Cuttita, 159 AD2d 328 [1990]). Further, we notethat Election Law § 1-106 (1) permits a person to file certain papers, including objections,by mail at any time, but that those papers "required to be filed with the board of elections of thecity of New York must actually be received by such city board of elections on or before the lastday to file." In the case of filing by mail, the official act of filing need not occur between thehours of 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. in order to be valid and, thus, a potentially affected party is notprejudiced by such a filing even though the papers sought to be filed may not have been acceptedfor filing by the Board of Elections as a matter of official business during those hours, as long asthey have been received prior to the deadline. The circumstances at bar are analogous and,therefore, we affirm the final order.
In light of the foregoing, we need not reach the parties' remaining contentions. Covello, J.P.,Florio, Miller, and Eng, JJ., concur.