Matter of Syracuse Univ. v Project Orange Assoc. Servs.Corp.
2010 NY Slip Op 02225 [71 AD3d 1432]
March 19, 2010
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 28, 2010


In the Matter of Syracuse University, Petitioner, v Project OrangeAssociates Services Corporation, Respondent.

—[*1]Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC, Syracuse (Jonathan B. Fellows of counsel), forpetitioner.

Read and Laniado, LLP, Albany (Sam M. Laniado of counsel), for respondent.

Proceeding pursuant to EDPL 207 (initiated in the Appellate Division of the Supreme Courtin the Fourth Judicial Department) to annul the determination of respondent authorizing thecondemnation of certain real property owned by petitioner.

It is hereby ordered that the determination is unanimously annulled on the law without costsand the petition is granted.

Memorandum: Petitioner, Syracuse University (SU), commenced this original proceedingpursuant to EDPL 207 seeking to annul the determination of respondent, Project OrangeAssociates Services Corporation (POASC), authorizing the condemnation of real propertyowned by SU on which a cogeneration facility and steam plants are located, as well as certainunderground steam distribution mains originating from the aforementioned facilities. We annulthe determination and grant the petition.

Pursuant to EDPL article 2, which governs the judicial review procedure in a condemnationcase, the scope of this Court's inquiry is "very limited" (Matter of City of New York [Grand Lafayette Props. LLC], 6 NY3d540, 546 [2006]). We must " 'either confirm or reject the condemnor's determination andfindings,' and [our] review is confined to whether (1) the proceeding was constitutionally sound;(2) the condemnor had the requisite authority; (3) its determination complied with [article 8 ofthe Environmental Conservation Law (State Environmental Quality Review Act)] and EDPLarticle 2; and (4) the acquisition will serve a public use" (id., citing EDPL 207 [C]; see Matter of Dudley v Town Bd. of Townof Prattsburgh, 59 AD3d 1103, 1103-1104 [2009]). A negative conclusion with respectto any one of those factors mandates rejection of the condemnor's determinations (see Matterof Kaur v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 72 AD3d 1, 8-9 [2009]).

A "public use, benefit or purpose" must exist to warrant the exercise of the power of eminentdomain (EDPL 204 [B] [1]), and here SU primarily contends that the purported public use of theacquisition is illusory. We agree. "What qualifies as a 'public purpose' or 'public use' [*2]is broadly defined as encompassing virtually any project that mayconfer upon the public a benefit, utility, or advantage" (Matter of 49 WB, LLC v Village of Haverstraw, 44 AD3d 226,235 [2007]; see Kaur, 72 AD3d at 9-11)."Whether a use to which property is to be devoted by a condemnor is, in fact, for the publicbenefit is a question to be determined by the courts based on the record" (49 WB, LLC,44 AD3d at 235; see Yonkers Community Dev. Agency v Morris, 37 NY2d 478, 485[1975], appeal dismissed 423 US 1010 [1975]). An "incidental private benefit will notinvalidate [a condemnor's] determination so long as the public purpose is dominant" (Matterof Waldo's, Inc. v Village of Johnson City, 74 NY2d 718, 721 [1989]; see Matter ofKaufmann's Carousel v City of Syracuse Indus. Dev. Agency, 301 AD2d 292, 303 [2002],lv denied 99 NY2d 508 [2003]), and it logically follows that a merely incidental publicbenefit coupled with a dominant private purpose will invalidate a condemnor's determination (see Matter of Aspen Cr. Estates, Ltd. vTown of Brookhaven, 47 AD3d 267, 275-276 [2007], affd 12 NY3d 735 [2009],cert denied 558 US —, 130 S Ct 96 [2009]; Kaur, 72 AD3d at23-25).

We agree with petitioner that the underlying basis for the exercise by the POASC of itseminent domain powers is undoubtedly the outdated business model of its affiliate, ProjectOrange Associates, LLC (POA). The record establishes that POA entered into a series of 40-yearlease agreements with SU in 1990 that allowed POA to construct a cogeneration facility onproperty owned by SU and to assume operation of two existing steam plants located there. Inexchange, POA agreed to sell steam at prices substantially below what SU was paying toproduce steam at the existing steam plants. SU both used that steam and sold excess steam toneighboring not-for-profit entities, all of which oppose the proposed condemnation. POA wasable to provide that steam at a reduced price because of its expected profits from the sale ofelectricity under a 40-year contract between POA and Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation(NIMO) that required NIMO to purchase electricity produced at the cogeneration facility. Thethreat of a NIMO bankruptcy in 1998 caused POA and NIMO to reach a settlement that allowedNIMO to discharge its obligation to purchase electricity from POA in exchange for a significantsettlement that permitted POA to provide SU with steam at a significantly reduced rate until July2008.

The record further establishes that, by 2008, POA took steps to renegotiate its leaseagreements with SU, which were unsustainable based on the demise of POA's contractualrelationship with NIMO. Indeed, POA commenced a declaratory judgment action against SU inconnection with one of its agreements with SU and in addition twice sought emergency judicialrelief adjusting the steam price, withheld payment to the contractor responsible for operating thecogeneration facility and disputed certain water and electric charges for the facility. In May2008, POASC was incorporated as an electric corporation under article 2 of the TransportationCorporations Law and, approximately one year later, provided notice of its intent to condemn thesubject property.

Based on the aforementioned facts, we conclude that the record establishes that the proposedcondemnation is the last in a series of attempts to free POA from an unfavorable contractualagreement with SU. Thus, at its core, the condemnor "is virtually the sole beneficiary of the[condemnation, and t]his alone is reason to invalidate the condemnation especially where, ashere, the public benefit is incrementally incidental to the private benefits" of the condemnation(Kaur, 72 AD3d at 23-25). We note inparticular that the cogeneration facility contributes a minimal amount of electricity to the totalenergy needs of this state, that there is 50% more generation than load in the area in whichPOASC is located, and that SU continued to operate the steam plants after POA's default.Consequently, we grant the petition (see generally Kelo v New London, 545 US 469,478 [2005]; 49 WB, LLC, 44 AD3d at 235-236; Matter of Steel Los III, LP v Power Auth. of State of N.Y., 21 Misc 3d707, 717 [2008]).[*3]

Although the issue is academic in light of the foregoingdetermination, we note that, as previously stated, POASC was incorporated as an electriccorporation (see Transportation Corporations Law § 3 [b]). Its powers of eminentdomain are thus restricted by Transportation Corporations Law § 11 (3-a), which providesin relevant part that an electric corporation "shall have power and authority to acquire such realestate as may be necessary for its corporate purposes," along with Transportation CorporationsLaw § 11 (3), which establishes the corporate purposes of an electric corporation. Thepurposes enumerated therein do not include steam distribution. We thus conclude in any eventthat POASC lacks statutory authority to acquire the subject steam plants (cf. Iroquois GasCorp. v Jurek, 30 AD2d 83, 87-88 [1968]; see generally Schulman v People, 10NY2d 249, 255-256 [1961]; Peasley v Reid, 57 AD2d 998, 999 [1977]).

In view of our determination, we do not address SU's remaining contentions, and we furthernote only that we have disregarded the supplemental affidavit of Timothy J. Sweet dated October20, 2009, which is outside the record on appeal (see Kaufmann's Carousel, 301 AD2d at305). Present—Scudder, P.J., Fahey, Lindley and Green, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.