| Vecciarelli v King Pharms., Inc. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 02658 [71 AD3d 595] |
| March 30, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Loretta Vecciarelli et al., Appellants, v KingPharmaceuticals, Inc., et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Jackson Lewis, LLP, White Plains (Mary A. Smith of counsel), for respondents.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Jane S. Solomon, J.), entered November 3, 2008,which granted defendants' motion for severance and separation of the action into five individualactions, with related relief, unanimously reversed, on the law and the facts and in the exercise ofdiscretion, without costs, and the motion denied without prejudice to renewal after completion ofdiscovery.
Where there is "a common nucleus of facts," severance requires a showing that a joint trialwill result in "prejudice or substantial delay" (see Sichel v Community Synagogue, 256AD2d 276, 276 [1998]). Defendants in this employment discrimination action had the burden ofmaking that showing (see Andresakis v Lynn, 236 AD2d 252 [1997]) in seekingseverance immediately after service of their answers. That burden was not sustained.
All of the plaintiffs were in the same department of the corporate defendant, and all werefired within the same year. All but one plead common-law torts. While plaintiffs' territoriescomprised diverse areas of New York and Connecticut, it has not yet been shown whether or notthe discriminatory conduct occurred in diverse counties or at the home office of the corporatedefendant, nor is there any showing that a geographically diverse group of witnesses will have toparticipate in the case. All but one of the plaintiffs allege conduct by the two individualdefendants. All of the plaintiffs allege an overall pattern and practice of discrimination to adegree at this initial postpleading phase.
The joint trial format can serve judicial efficiency and avoid the risk of inconsistent verdicts(Williams v Property Servs., 6 AD3d 255 [2004]). It is too early here for a determinationthat such a format will cause prejudice or substantial delay, or that there are "only the most [*2]superficial common factual grounds to be explored" among the fivecases (cf. Hickson v Mt. Sinai Med. Ctr., 87 AD2d 527, 527 [1982]).Concur—Saxe, J.P., Catterson, Moskowitz, Freedman and RomÁn JJ.