| Cadlerock, L.L.C. v Renner |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 02849 [72 AD3d 454] |
| April 6, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Cadlerock, L.L.C., Appellant, v Jan Z. Renner,Respondent. |
—[*1] Goldstein & Greenlaw, LLP, Forest Hills (Andrew W. Schwarsin of counsel), forrespondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Marylin G. Diamond, J.), entered September 3,2009, which denied plaintiff's motion for summary judgment on its claim for recovery on apromissory note, unanimously affirmed, with costs.
Defendant sufficiently pleaded his statute of limitations affirmative defense (seeImmediate v St. John's Queens Hosp., 48 NY2d 671, 673 [1979]). Contrary to plaintiff'scontention, the promissory note, which required defendant to pay principal and interest paymentsmonthly for 20 years, after which the loan would have self-liquidated, was an installmentcontract (see Phoenix Acquisition Corp. v Campcore, Inc., 81 NY2d 138, 141-142[1993]), and, since the debt was not accelerated while defendant was making the monthlypayments, the applicable six-year statute of limitations (CPLR 213 [2]) began to run on the dateon which each installment became due and payable (see Phoenix Acquisition Corp. at141). Thus, the statute of limitations bars plaintiff from seeking to recover the amount of theinstallment payments, including any interest, that defendant defaulted on before April 18, 2002,when this action was commenced (see id.; Sce v Ach, 56 AD3d 457, 458-459 [2008]).
The defense of laches is unavailable in this action at law commenced within the period oflimitations (see Matter of AmericanDruggists' Ins. Co., 15 AD3d 268 [2005], lv dismissed 5 NY3d 746 [2005];Kahn v New York Times Co., 122 AD2d 655, 663 [1986]). However, we conclude that atriable issue of fact exists whether plaintiff's claims are barred by the doctrine of equitableestoppel, i.e., whether defendant justifiably relied on the nine years of inaction by plaintiff andits predecessors-in-interest to reasonably conclude that his monthly payments were sufficient tosatisfy his payment obligations under the note, and therefore was misled into paying a reducedamount for years without realizing that interest was accruing at the 14% interest rate (see Fundamental Portfolio Advisors, Inc. vTocqueville Asset Mgt., L.P., 7 NY3d 96, 106-107 [2006]; Triple Cities Constr. Co.v Maryland Cas. Co., 4 NY2d 443, 448 [1958]). Concur—Tom, J.P., Mazzarelli,Nardelli, Acosta and Renwick, JJ.