Whiteman v Parsons Transp. Group of N.Y., Inc.
2010 NY Slip Op 02944 [72 AD3d 677]
April 6, 2010
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 9, 2010


Lisa Whiteman, Appellant,
v
Parsons TransportationGroup of New York, Inc., Doing Business as Parsons, Steinman, Boynton, Gronquist, &Birddsall, Inc., et al., Defendants, and Gandhi Engineering, Inc.,Respondent.

—[*1]Adam D. White, New York, N.Y., for appellant. Milber Makris Plousadis & Seiden,LLP, White Plains, N.Y. (Michael A. Heran of counsel), for respondent.

In an action to recover damages for personal injuries, the plaintiff appeals from an order ofthe Supreme Court, Kings County (Schack, J.), dated November 21, 2008, which granted themotion of the defendant Gandhi Engineering, Inc., to transfer venue of this action from KingsCounty to New York County and thereupon to consolidate this action with two related actionsentitled Fleck v City of New York and Chynsky v City of New York, pending inthe Supreme Court, New York County, under index Nos. 403251/04 and 111540/06,respectively.

Ordered that the order is modified, on the law, on the facts, and in the exercise of discretion,by deleting the provision thereof granting that branch of the motion which was to consolidate theactions, and substituting therefor a provision granting the motion only to the extent of directingthat the actions shall be tried jointly in the Supreme Court, New York County; as so modified,the order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.

Where common questions of law or fact exist, a motion pursuant to CPLR 602 (a) toconsolidate or for a joint trial should be granted absent a showing of prejudice to a substantialright of the party opposing the motion (see Mas-Edwards v Ultimate Servs., Inc., 45 AD3d 540 [2007]; Perini Corp. v WDF, Inc., 33 AD3d605, 606 [2006]; Nationwide Assoc. v Targee St. Internal Med. Group, P.C. ProfitSharing Trust, 286 AD2d 717 [2001]). Here, the action commenced in the Supreme Court,Kings County, shares defendants and questions of law and fact in common with two relatedactions pending in the Supreme Court, New York County (see Nigro v Pickett, 39 AD3d 720, 722 [2007]; Spector vZuckermann, 287 AD2d 704 [2001]). Furthermore, the plaintiff failed to show prejudice to asubstantial right if this action is transferred to New York County, and mere delay of the trial isnot a sufficient basis upon which to deny a motion for consolidation or a joint trial (see Alsol Enters., Ltd. v PremierLincoln-Mercury, Inc., 11 AD3d 494 [2004]; Zupich v Flushing Hosp. & Med.Ctr., 156 AD2d 677 [1989]). Moreover, in the absence of special circumstances, where theactions have been commenced in different counties, the place of trial should be in the countywhere venue of the first-commenced action currently lies (see Almoghazy v Gonzalez,233 AD2d 349, 350 [1996]; Levertov v Congregation Yetev Lev [*2]D'Satmar, 129 AD2d 680 [1987]; T T Enters. vGralnick, 127 AD2d 651, 652 [1987]). Since venue properly lies in New York County withrespect to the first of the three subject actions to be commenced, venue of the action commencedin the Supreme Court, Kings County, was properly transferred to New York County.

However, the respondent's motion to consolidate the three actions should have been grantedonly to the extent of directing a joint trial, particularly since the actions involve differentplaintiffs (see Perini Corp. v WDF, Inc., 33 AD3d at 606-607; Cola-Rugg Enters. vConsolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., 109 AD2d 726 [1985]; Mascioni v Consolidated R. R.Corp., 94 AD2d 738 [1983]). Mastro, J.P., Santucci, Dickerson, Belen and Austin, JJ.,concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.