Matter of Zahm v National Fuel
2010 NY Slip Op 03018 [72 AD3d 1311]
April 15, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 9, 2010


In the Matter of the Claim of Linda Zahm, Respondent, v NationalFuel, Appellant. Workers' Compensation Board, Respondent.
—[*1]Hamberger & Weiss, Buffalo (Susan R. Duffy of counsel), for appellant. Andrew M.Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Estelle Kraushar of counsel), for Workers'Compensation Board, respondent.

Peters, J.P. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed December 5,2008, which ruled that claimant had a 20.4% schedule loss of use for binaural loss of hearing.

Claimant worked for the employer in numerous capacities—first as a data entry clerkand then in various customer-related positions—for 31 years until she retired in July 2005.A preemployment hearing examination conducted in 1974 revealed that claimant had ameasurable loss of hearing at that time. In August 2007, claimant filed this claim contending thatshe had sustained an occupational hearing loss due to long-term noise exposure "from being onthe telephone for years." Following a hearing, a workers' compensation law judge found thatclaimant had a 20.4% schedule loss of use for binaural loss of hearing. Upon review, theWorkers' Compensation Board affirmed, prompting this appeal by the employer.

While there is no dispute that claimant has suffered a hearing loss, the employer argues thatthe record as a whole fails to establish both that claimant was exposed to injurious noise duringthe course of her employment and that her documented hearing loss was causally related to heremployment. We agree and, accordingly, reverse the Board's decision.[*2]

Claimant was employed in three customer-relatedpositions between 1987 and her retirement in 2005, each of which entailed spending varyingportions of her day on the telephone with customers who sometimes were either irate or haddifficulty hearing. Although claimant provided estimates as to the number of hours she spent onthe telephone each day in the respective positions and the corresponding percentage of customerswho would yell or scream at her during these conversations, claimant's description of the actualnoise level, which was not measured, was simply too vague and imprecise to establish that it wasin fact injurious.

Moreover, even accepting that claimant was exposed to injurious noise while working forthe employer, we nonetheless agree that claimant failed to demonstrate a causal connectionbetween her hearing loss and her employment. Joel Bernstein, the otolaryngologist whoexamined claimant on behalf of the employer, opined that claimant's hearing loss was notcausally related to her employment because, even assuming she was exposed to hazardous noise,the overall extent of claimant's hearing loss and the frequency at which it occurs were not at allconsistent with noise-induced hearing loss. Although claimant's treating otolaryngologist, RobinLazar-Miller, was of the view that claimant's hearing loss was causally related to heremployment, Lazar-Miller's opinion was based upon the erroneous assumption that claimantspent all of her 31 years with the employer on the telephone eight hours each day and, duringthat entire time, was exposed to approximately 80 to 90 decibels of noise. As noted previously,however, the level of noise to which claimant was exposed was not quantified, and claimant'sown testimony contradicts Lazar-Miller's understanding of claimant's various job descriptionsand alleged level of noise exposure. When presented with a hypothetical that more closelymirrored claimant's actual duties and exposure, Lazar-Miller maintained that employment-relatednoise exposure remained the "most likely" cause of claimant's hearing loss, but neither her reportnor her testimony address—much less contradict—Bernstein's statement that theparticular level of claimant's hearing loss and the frequency at which it occurs is not consistentwith noise-induced hearing loss.

While conflicts in medical testimony indeed represent an issue for the Board to resolve (see Matter of Shkreli v Initial ContractServs., 55 AD3d 1067, 1068 [2008]), the issue here is the overall sufficiency ofclaimant's proof. Based upon our review of the record as a whole, we cannot say thatLazar-Miller's testimony was sufficient to establish the requisite causal connection betweenclaimant's loss of hearing and her employment (see Matter of Downer v NYNEX, 55 AD3d 1169 [2008]).

Lahtinen, Malone Jr., Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is reversed,without costs, and claim dismissed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.