| Matter of Cipry Auto., Inc. v New York State Dept. of MotorVehs. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 03121 [72 AD3d 816] |
| April 13, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Cipry Automotive, Inc., et al.,Petitioners, v New York State Department of Motor Vehicles et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York, N.Y. (Michael S. Belohlavek and CarolFischer of counsel), for respondents.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review four determinations of the New York StateDepartment of Motor Vehicles Administrative Appeals Board, two dated January 25, 2005, andtwo dated February 22, 2005, respectively, which confirmed the findings of two administrativelaw judges that the petitioners violated 15 NYCRR 79.24 (e) by failing to test vehicles accordingto high-enhanced emissions dynamometer test procedures, revoked the petitioners' motor vehicleinspection station license and certified inspector's license, and directed the petitioners to paycivil penalties.
Adjudged that the amended petition is denied, the determinations are confirmed, and theproceeding is dismissed on the merits, with costs.
Following a hearing on March 4, 2004, resulting from an inspection station desk auditconducted by Kenneth Minnick, an inspector for the New York State Department of MotorVehicles (hereinafter the DMV), the petitioners Cipry Automotive, Inc. (hereinafter Cipry), alicensed motor vehicle inspection station, and its station manager, Peter Christensen, a certifiedinspector, were found to have violated 15 NYCRR 79.24 (e) by failing to test vehicles accordingto high-enhanced emissions dynamometer test procedures. The administrative law judge(hereinafter ALJ) who conducted that hearing revoked Cipry's motor vehicle inspection stationlicense and Christensen's certified inspector's license, and directed the petitioners to pay civilpenalties. In two determinations dated January 25, 2005, the DMV Administrative AppealsBoard upheld these findings and penalties on administrative appeal.
Following a hearing on September 2, 2004, resulting from a subsequent inspection stationdesk audit conducted by Inspector Minnick, the petitioners were found, for a second time, tohave violated 15 NYCRR 79.24 (e) by failing to test vehicles according to high-enhancedemissions dynamometer test [*2]procedures. The ALJ whoconducted the second hearing revoked Cipry's motor vehicle inspection station license andChristensen's certified inspector's license, and directed the petitioners to pay civil penalties. Thepetitioners filed administrative appeals but failed to submit a copy of the hearing transcript to theDMV Administrative Appeals Board. In two determinations dated February 22, 2005, the DMVAdministrative Appeals Board limited the appeals to the issue of whether the penalties imposedwere excessive, and affirmed these penalties.
The petitioners commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review thedeterminations of the DMV Administrative Appeals Board. We confirm the determinations.
With respect to the determinations dated January 25, 2005, a review of the record clearlydemonstrates that the findings of the ALJ are supported by substantial evidence (see Matterof Pell v Board of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale &Mamaroneck, Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 231-232 [1974]; Matter of MadisonAutomotive Serv. Ctr. v Adduci, 195 AD2d 899 [1993]; Matter of Ralph Oldsmobile vAdduci, 170 AD2d 454 [1991]). The testimonial and documentary evidence presented byInspector Minnick was not substantively challenged to any great degree during the hearing, andthe petitioners offered no affirmative evidence to contest the charges.
With respect to the determinations dated February 22, 2005, the petitioners' failure to submita copy of the hearing transcript to the DMV Administrative Appeals Board precludes this Courtfrom addressing whether substantial evidence supported these administrative determinations(see Matter of Brady v Department of Motor Vehs., 98 NY2d 625 [2002]; Matter of Herskovic v New York StateDept. of Motor Vehs., 57 AD3d 995 [2008]; Matter of Richmond Hill Serv. Sta. vNew York State Dept. of Motor Vehs., 92 AD2d 688, 688-689 [1983]).
Under the circumstances of this case, the penalties imposed were not so disproportionate tothe offenses so as to be shocking to one's sense of fairness (see Matter of Pell v Board ofEduc. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, WestchesterCounty, 34 NY2d at 233-235; Matter of Empire Auto Care, Inc. v New York State Dept. of MotorVehs., 55 AD3d 730 [2008]). Covello, J.P., Florio, Eng and Chambers, JJ., concur.