| Matter of Hicks |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 03447 [72 AD3d 1085] |
| April 27, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of the Estate of John Henry Hicks, Deceased. GenesisHolding of Nassau, LLC, Appellant; Lois M. Rosenblatt, Public Administrator of QueensCounty, Respondent. |
—[*1] Gerard J. Sweeney, Rego Park, N.Y. (John W. Steigler of counsel), for respondent.
In a probate proceeding in which Genesis Holding of Nassau, LLC, petitioned to be relievedof purchasing certain real property from a decedent's estate, the petitioner appeals (1), as limitedby its brief, from so much of an order of the Surrogate's Court, Queens County (Nahman, S.),dated September 2, 2008, as granted the motion of Lois M. Rosenblatt, Public Administrator ofQueens County, for summary judgment dismissing the petition, and (2) from an order of thesame court dated March 27, 2009, which denied its motion for leave to renew its opposition tothe prior motion.
Ordered that the order dated September 2, 2008, is reversed insofar as appealed from, on thelaw, the motion of Lois M. Rosenblatt, Public Administrator of Queens County, for summaryjudgment dismissing the petition is denied, and upon searching the record, summary judgment isawarded in favor of the petitioner and the petition is granted; and it is further,
Ordered that the appeal from the order dated March 27, 2009, is dismissed as academic inlight of our determination on the appeal from the order dated September 2, 2008; and it isfurther,
Ordered that one bill of costs is awarded to the petitioner.
In 1968, the subject property, located at 143-04 Farmers Boulevard in Jamaica (hereinafterthe property), was acquired by the decedent John Henry Hicks (hereinafter John) and his wifeBirta Sue Hicks (hereinafter Birta). In 1973, John and Birta transferred ownership of the propertyto "Birta Realty Corp.," a corporation in which they were the sole shareholders (each owning 10shares of stock), and of which John was the sole director and officer. In 1996, Birta Realty Corp.(hereinafter Birta Realty) was dissolved by proclamation. In 2001 Birta died, and in 2002, Johndied. On June 21, 2007, the respondent Lois M. Rosenblatt, Public Administrator of QueensCounty (hereinafter the Public Administrator), was appointed administrator of John's estate(hereinafter the Estate).[*2]
On October 25, 2007, the Public Administrator auctionedthe property, and the petitioner, Genesis Holding of Nassau, LLC (hereinafter Genesis Holding),was the highest bidder. Genesis Holding agreed to purchase the property from the Estate for thesum of $735,000. A contract of sale was entered into by the Public Administrator on behalf ofthe Estate and Genesis Holding. In the contract, the seller was listed as "LOIS M.ROSENBLATT, Public Administrator of Queens County, as Administratrix of the Estate of JohnHenry Hicks, deceased," and the contract contains no mention of Birta Realty. The contractrequired the Public Administrator to convey "such title as any reputable New York TitleInsurance Co. and its underwriters would be willing to approve and insure in accordance withtheir standard form of title policy." The contract of sale made the closing time of the essence,and, upon the signing of the contract, Genesis Holding gave the Public Administrator a downpayment in the sum of $73,500.
After Genesis Holding failed to tender performance on the time-of-the-essence date, thePublic Administrator declared it to be in default, and later sold the property to another buyer.Genesis Holding commenced this proceeding in the Surrogate's Court seeking to be relieved ofits obligations under the contract and the return of its down payment, arguing, inter alia, that titleto the property was in Birta Realty, not the Estate, and that the title insurer required proof thatthe Estate was authorized by Birta Realty to convey the property. The Surrogate's Court grantedthe Public Administrator's motion for summary judgment dismissing the petition, holding thatthe Public Administrator "had the power to liquidate the assets of the corporation in its capacityas fiduciary for the decedent who was the sole surviving officer and shareholder of Birta Realty."We reverse, and upon searching the record, award summary judgment to Genesis Holding andgrant its petition.
A seller holding a buyer in breach of a time-of-the-essence contract bears the burden on amotion for summary judgment to demonstrate that she was ready, willing, and able to perform onthe law day, and that the buyer failed to appear and proceed with the closing (see StendaRealty, LLC v Kornman, 67 AD3d 996, 998 [2009]; Pinhas v Comperchio, 50 AD3d1117 [2008]; Engelhardt v McGinnis, 2 AD3d 572 [2003]). Here, the PublicAdministrator not only failed to demonstrate that she was ready, willing, and able to convey titlein conformity with the contract, but her submissions established that she was in fact not able toconvey title because she lacked corporate authorization to do so. Title to Birta Realty's propertydid not pass to its shareholders upon dissolution; rather, it remained in the corporation's name."The directors of a dissolved corporation shall not be deemed to be trustees of its assets; title tosuch assets shall not vest in them, but shall remain in the corporation until transferred by it in itscorporate name" (Business Corporation Law § 1006 [a] [1]). "A dissolved corporation, itsdirectors, officers, and shareholders may continue to function for the purpose of winding up theaffairs of the corporation in the same manner as if the dissolution had not taken place" (BusinessCorporation Law § 1006 [a]).
The Public Administrator asserts that John Henry Hicks was the sole shareholder of BirtaRealty at the time of his death. However, the corporate records establish that Birta and John wereeach 50% shareholders. Although Birta predeceased John, there is no evidence that she evertransferred her shares to him inter vivos, and there is no evidence that her shares were distributedto John out of her estate. The Public Administrator also argues, in effect, that since John died asthe sole director, his estate is the proper entity to wind up the affairs of the corporation. To thecontrary, John's death merely created a vacancy on the board of directors (see BusinessCorporation Law § 705; White, New York Business Entities ¶ B705.01 [14th ed]).Since a corporation's dissolution does not change quorum or voting requirements for, inter alia,the filling of vacancies on the board of directors (see Business Corporation Law §1006 [a] [2]), and since no steps were taken to fill that vacancy pursuant to the BusinessCorporation Law § 705, Birta Realty had no directors or officers. Thus, since a mereshareholder lacks the authority to transfer a corporation's assets (see Manson v Curtis,223 NY 313, 323 [1918]; see also 14A NY Jur 2d Business Relationships § 846),the Public Administrator lacked the authority to transfer the subject property according to theterms of the contract, and was thus incapable of performing on law day. Under thesecircumstances, Genesis Holding was entitled to the return of its down payment despite failing toappear at the closing, tender performance, and give the Public Administrator an opportunity tocure (see Cohen v Kranz, 12 NY2d 242, 246 [1963]; Greene v Barrett, Nephews &Co., 238 NY 207 [1924]; Spivak v Farkas, 217 AD2d 430 [1995]).
The parties' remaining contentions either are academic in light of our determination, or [*3]without merit. Mastro, J.P., Lott, Austin and Sgroi, JJ., concur.