| Diplomat Props., L.P. v Komar Five Assoc., LLC |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 03476 [72 AD3d 596] |
| April 29, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Diplomat Properties, L.P., Respondent, v Komar FiveAssociates, LLC, Appellant, et al., Defendant. |
—[*1] Proskauer Rose LLP, New York (Herman L. Goldsmith of counsel), forrespondent.
Orders, Supreme Court, New York County (Herman Cahn, J.), entered August 6, 2008,December 12, 2008, and February 27, 2009, which, respectively, granted plaintiff's motion todismiss defendant Komar Five Associates, LLC's affirmative defenses and counterclaims; to theextent appealed from as limited by the brief, denied defendant's motion for renewal; and grantedplaintiff's motion for summary judgment declaring that it was entitled to retain defendant'scontract deposit and denied defendant's cross motion for summary judgment dismissing thecomplaint, unanimously affirmed, with costs.
On May 3, 2007, plaintiff and defendant Komar Five Associates, LLC executed anagreement for the purchase and sale of the Diplomat Hotel and Convention Center and relatedfacilities in Hollywood and Hallandale Beach, Florida, for $690 million. Upon execution of thepurchase and sale agreement (the contract), defendant delivered a $20 million deposit todefendant escrow agent, First American Title Insurance Company. The contract provided that theclosing would occur on August 1, 2007, but that upon notice from defendant and an additional$10 million deposit, defendant purchaser had the right to extend the closing date for up to 60days.
Defendant subsequently requested an extension of the closing date. In connection therewith,the parties executed a first amendment to the contract, dated July 26, 2007, in which defendantacknowledged that (1) its due diligence period had ended on June 4, 2007; (2) it had had asufficient opportunity to conduct due diligence and waived any objections it had raised or couldhave raised under section 6.12;[FN1](3) it would not terminate the contract under section 6.12 [*2]and, therefore, would not be entitled to a return of the deposit undersection 6.12; (4) it was satisfied with and accepted the property; and (5) it was proceeding withthe purchase of the property in its "as-is, where-is" state and condition, subject to the terms andconditions set forth in the contract. Defendant agreed to waive, release, rescind and terminateany and all allegations, assertions, claims and demands that it was not afforded sufficient accessto and/or did not receive adequate information to conduct its due diligence investigations of theproperty. A new closing date was set for October 31, 2007.
As the closing approached, plaintiff asserts that it contacted defendant numerous times toprepare for the closing. Plaintiff received no response. Defendant concedes that it did notrespond, but maintained that no response was required since plaintiff was in breach of thecontract.
By letter dated October 30, 2007, defendant informed plaintiff that it would not appear onthe scheduled closing date "because of the numerous breaches of [plaintiff] under the [contract],"including an agreement plaintiff allegedly had entered into with the City of Hallandalespecifying that future development of the property be phased-in over a 10-year period, inviolation of section 3.8 of the contract.[FN2]Defendant stated that it still desired to acquire the property, but demanded an "abatement and anoffset from the purchase price equal to the damages sustained by [it]." The letter concluded, "Inthe event that you do not immediately notify us of your acknowledgment of your obligation togrant such an abatement, and the adjournment of the closing until such abatement is agreed upon,we shall pursue all of our rights to enforce the Agreement and the law of the State of New Yorkand acquire title to the Property pursuant to the Agreement with an abatement and offset aspermitted pursuant to the law of the State of New York."
On October 31, 2007, plaintiff appeared at the closing, ready, willing and able to close.Defendant failed to appear and failed to wire the balance of the purchase price to plaintiff, andplaintiff commenced this action on or about the same date.
Defendant purchaser is bound by the exclusive remedy provisions set forth in the parties'contract, having failed to adduce any facts from which a trier of fact could find that plaintiffseller engaged in misconduct "smack[ing] of intentional wrongdoing" (Banc of Am. Sec. LLC v [*3]Solow Bldg. Co. II, L.L.C., 47 AD3d 239, 244 [2007][internal quotation marks and citation omitted]). The City of Hallandale confirmed twice that,notwithstanding any discussions that may have taken place as to the way the development of theproperty that was the subject of the contract might proceed, there was no actual or proposedagreement concerning any development restriction between the City or its agencies and plaintiff,at any time preceding defendant's default under the contract. Thus, there was no breach ofplaintiff's obligation, pursuant to section 3.8 (a) of the contract, to disclose the existence of a"Material Agreement[ ]." Further, due diligence materials furnished to defendant referred todevelopment of the property as proceeding in "phases." This $690 million project was notscheduled to be completed and ready for occupancy until 2017. As defendant, in the firstamendment to the contract, expressly warranted that it had had a sufficient opportunity toconduct due diligence and that it waived any objections it had raised or could have raised, it willnot now be heard to complain.
Similarly unavailing is defendant's argument that plaintiff misrepresented its ability to obtainthe necessary approvals for the addition of 1,388 residential units on the golf course and that thisconstitutes a "material deviation" from the predevelopment work described in section 6.6 of thecontract. We note first that, as the motion court pointed out, section 6.6 defines thepredevelopment work in terms of an "approximately 349 unit hotel" and "a mix of uses at theexisting golf course," and the number 1,388 does not appear there or anywhere else in thecontract. In any event, defendant did not identify this alleged "breach" in the October 30, 2007letter that it asserts constituted the requisite notice and demand to cure under section 9.1 of thecontract. Defendant raised the argument for the first time in February 2008, long after theclosing. Moreover, plaintiff sought approval from the City, but there was no guarantee that itwould receive it. Indeed, witnesses testified that a land use planning amendment (LUPA) wasonly a partial, first-level entitlement, and that without City approval of the LUPA, the zoning,the site plan, and the design, "you've got nothing." Finally, since, as the record shows, it was notuntil November 2007, i.e., after the scheduled closing date, that plaintiff learned that the Citywas considering approving 900 rather than 1,388 units, the alleged "breach" cannot constitute alawful excuse for defendant's failure to close.
Defendant argues that its request for specific performance should have been construed as ademand for the return of its deposit under section 9.1 (a) of the contract. However, its October30, 2007 letter did not comply with the requirements of section 9.1 (b). That section providesthat in the event plaintiff failed to comply with its closing obligations as set forth in section 7.2or 7.4, defendant could seek performance if certain conditions were met. Defendant, which didnot appear at the closing, did not allege any breach of plaintiff's closing obligations under section7.2 or section 7.4. It alleged a violation of section 3.8 (a) and other provisions. Thus, it was notentitled to seek specific performance under section 9.1 (b).
The breach of fiduciary duty and tortious interference counterclaims were insufficientlypleaded (see SNS Bank v Citibank,7 AD3d 352, 354 [2004]; V. Ponte & Sons v American Fibers Intl., 222 AD2d 271,272 [1995]), as was the counterclaim for tortious interference with prospective business relations(see Snyder v Sony Music Entertainment, 252 AD2d 294, 299-300 [1999]).
None of the new "evidence" proffered by defendant in support of its motion to renewestablished that plaintiff acted in bad faith or that it breached the contract by entering into anagreement with the City to restrict development of the property or by misrepresenting thenumber of residential units to be built on the golf course.[*4]
As plaintiff established that it was ready, willing and ableto close on the closing date, and defendant failed to demonstrate a lawful excuse for its failure toclose, plaintiff was entitled to retain the contract deposit (Rivera v Konkol, 48 AD3d 347 [2008]). Defendant's argument thatplaintiff improperly terminated the contract by instituting this action on October 31, 2007 iswithout merit. Concur—Mazzarelli, J.P., Sweeny, Catterson, Acosta and Abdus-Salaam,JJ.
Footnote 1: Section 6.12 sets forth a limitedright to terminate during the due diligence period if, as a result of defendant's due diligenceinvestigation, it was determined in accordance with the contract procedures that a "MajorProperty Condition" existed.
Footnote 2: Section 3.8 (a) provides thatexcept as set forth on an annexed schedule, "there are no management, service, supply, ormaintenance or other contracts or agreements that are Material Agreements in effect with respectto the Property other than the Operating Agreements, the Occupancy Agreements, andagreements disclosed in the Title Commitment." "Material Agreement" is defined as any contractor agreement if the aggregate amount payable during any calendar year equaled or exceeded$100,000, or the term of such contract expired after the first anniversary of the closing date,provided that no such contract was deemed "material" if terminable on 60 days' or fewer days'notice.