| Matter of Handley v New York State Teachers' RetirementSys. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 04667 [74 AD3d 1384] |
| June 3, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Brett A. Handley, Respondent-Appellant, v NewYork State Teachers' Retirement System, Appellant-Respondent. (Proceeding No. 1.) In theMatter of Kenneth M. Ford, Respondent-Appellant, v New York State Teachers' RetirementSystem, Appellant-Respondent. (Proceeding No. 2.) In the Matter of Theresa Phillips,Respondent-Appellant, v New York State Teachers' Retirement System, Appellant-Respondent.(Proceeding No. 3.) In the Matter of Niel Tebbano, Respondent-Appellant, v New York StateTeachers' Retirement System, Appellant-Respondent. (Proceeding No. 4.) In the Matter ofThomas M. White, Respondent-Appellant, v New York State Teachers' Retirement System,Appellant-Respondent. (Proceeding No. 5.) |
—[*1]
Stein, J. Cross appeals from five judgments of the Supreme Court (Ceresia Jr., J.), enteredAugust 13, 2008 in Albany County, which, among other things, granted petitioners' applications,in five proceedings pursuant to CPLR article 78, to annul determinations of respondentrecalculating their retirement benefits and/or denying credit for certain years of service.
For varying periods of time, petitioners all rendered services in relation to Project Lead TheWay, Inc. (hereinafter PLTW), a not-for-profit corporation created in 1997 to promotepre-engineering courses for middle and high school students. Prior to the times in question,petitioners were each employees of one or more public school systems covered by respondent.After obtaining positions with PLTW, each petitioner continued to be reported as an employee ofa participating employer in respondent and were accumulating retirement service credit.However, after an investigation, respondent determined that petitioners were not entitled toservice credit during such periods because they were not employees of participating employersor, alternatively, because they were not providing teaching services within the meaning ofEducation Law § 501.
Petitioners individually commenced these CPLR article 78 proceedings[FN1]seeking, among other things, to annul and vacate respondent's preliminary and finaldeterminations. Supreme Court granted the petitions, finding that respondent acted arbitrarilyand capriciously in denying petitioners service credit and/or reducing their retirement benefits.Specifically, Supreme Court determined that petitioners were providing teaching services withinthe meaning of Education Law § 501 during the applicable time periods and thatrespondent had failed to consider whether the participating employers had a good faith basis fordesignating petitioners as employees eligible for retirement credit. Supreme Court thereforeremitted the matters to respondent. Respondent now appeals.[FN2][*2]
We reverse. As we recently articulated in two related andfactually similar cases, the presence or absence of good faith on the part of the employer isirrelevant in determining whether retirement credits were properly conferred (see Matter of Blais v New York StateTeachers' Retirement Sys., 68 AD3d 1266, 1268 [2009]; Matter of Jensen-Dooling v New YorkState Teachers' Retirement Sys., 68 AD3d 1264, 1265-1266 [2009], lv denied14 NY3d 705 [2010]; see generally Education Law § 525 [3]). It was thereforeerror for Supreme Court to remit the instant matters to respondent to determine whether theeducational institutions involved had a good faith basis for considering petitioners to be theiremployees.
The actual transactions between the contracting parties—and not the labels assigned totheir relationships pursuant to a contract or otherwise—determine whether anemployer-employee relationship exists (see Matter of Blais v New York State Teachers'Retirement Sys., 68 AD3d at 1268). Thus, the issue now before us distills towhether—even assuming that petitioners were providing teaching services within themeaning of Education Law § 501—a rational basis exists in the record to supportrespondent's determinations that petitioners were not employees of the applicable educationalinstitutions (see 68 AD3d at 1268-1269). We conclude that such a basis exists on therecord before us.
Recognizing that, although there were a number of circumstances common to eachpetitioner, their situations also had distinct characteristics, respondent conducted separateinvestigations of each petitioner and the educational institutions claiming to employ them. Indoing so, respondent reviewed, among other things, contracts between petitioners, theeducational institutions and/or PLTW which outlined the terms of employment, petitioners' jobdescriptions, questionnaires completed by the educational institutions and PLTW's promotionalmaterials, tax returns and cost projection reports. After notifying each petitioner of itspreliminary determination that he or she was not entitled to retirement credit for the period underreview, respondent invited petitioners to submit written information and documentation thatmight refute such determinations. Upon reviewing those submissions, respondent issued finaldeterminations adhering to the preliminary determinations. Our own review of the recordcompels us to conclude that respondent reasonably determined that petitioners were notemployees of the participating public employers.
For example, the record reveals that the salaries, benefits and expenses of all of thepetitioners were ultimately paid by PLTW, and their job responsibilities involved developing andpromoting the PLTW program nationally and were not specific to their school districts. With theexception of petitioner Niel Tebbano, none of the petitioners maintained offices at the facilitiesof the participating employers; they either worked from home or from PLTW's offices.[FN3][*3]Additionally, petitioners all received their job assignmentsfrom PLTW. In some cases, there was undisputed evidence that they were supervised by PLTWemployees; in those cases in which such evidence did not exist, there was nothing in the recordto indicate that the employee was supervised by the participating employer.
In our view, under all the circumstances, notwithstanding the existence of some contraryevidence (see Matter of Interlandi[Cremosa Foods Co., LLC—Commissioner of Labor], 70 AD3d 1150, 1151[2010]; Matter of Brosnahan v New York State Employees' Retirement Sys., 174 AD2d954, 955-956 [1991], lv denied 78 NY2d 858 [1991]), there is ample support in therecord for respondent's determinations that petitioners were not employees of the participatingpublic employers (see Matter ofWannen [Andrew Garrett Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 57 AD3d 1029,1030-1031 [2008]; Matter of Noel [LifeAlert Emergency Response, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 38 AD3d 1082, 1083[2007]). Thus, such determinations were neither arbitrary nor capricious (see Matter of Pell vBoard of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck,Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 231 [1974]; Matter of Blais v New York StateTeachers' Retirement Sys., 68 AD3d at 1268; Matter of Wright [Central Transp.,Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 58 AD3d 988, 989 [2009], lv dismissed 12NY3d 843 [2009]).
In light of the foregoing, respondent's contention that it correctly determined that petitionerswere not "teachers" within the meaning of Education Law § 501 (4) and (19) is academic.
Cardona, P.J., Spain, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgments arereversed, on the law, without costs, and petitions dismissed. [Prior Case History: 2008 NYSlip Op 32189(U).]
Footnote 1: These five proceedings havebeen joined together by an order of this Court for appeal purposes.
Footnote 2: Although petitioners initiallycross-appealed from that portion of each judgment that remitted the matter to respondent, ratherthan granting the relief requested in the petition, they have not perfected their cross appeals and,thus, have abandoned them.
Footnote 3: Notably, however in the case ofTebbano, although the employment agreement stated that he would be considered an employeeof the Mohonasen Central School District, he forfeited the right to receive vacation benefitspursuant to a contract between the school district and its administrators. Additionally, time spentby Tebbano in his position as Director of Operations for PLTW did not count toward hisseniority or tenure. When Tebbano began performing services in connection with PLTW, theMohonasen Central School District Board of Education filled his former position of Director ofCurriculum and Development.