Mulgrew v Board of Educ. of the City School Dist. of the City ofN.Y.
2010 NY Slip Op 05863 [75 AD3d 412]
July 1, 2010
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 1, 2010


Michael Mulgrew, as President of the United Federation ofTeachers, Local 2, et al., Respondents,
v
Board of Education of the City School Districtof the City of New York et al., Appellants.

—[*1]Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York (Alan G. Krams of counsel), forappellants.

Stroock & Stroock & Lavan LLP, New York (Charles G. Moerdler and Alan Klinger ofcounsel), for respondents.

David N. Grandwetter, Brooklyn, for amicus curiae.

Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Joan B. Lobis, J.), entered on or about March 26,2010, which granted the petition to the extent of declaring that respondents failed to comply withthe requirements of Education Law § 2590-h and that the votes of the Panel forEducational Policy (PEP) approving the phaseout or grade truncation of 19 schools were null andvoid, ordered respondents to reissue the educational impact statements (EISs) for the schools incompliance with Education Law § 2590-h, and permanently enjoined respondents fromprohibiting enrollment in the schools until they complied with Education Law § 2590-h,unanimously affirmed, without costs.

Petitioner United Federation of Teachers (UFT), which represents approximately 120,000educators working in New York City public schools, including 87,000 teachers, has standing tobring this proceeding (through its president) seeking the annulment of respondents'determination to phase out 19 schools on the ground that respondents failed to comply with thepre-phaseout procedures mandated by Education Law § 2590-h. Under thewell-established test for associational and organizational standing set forth by the Court ofAppeals, the UFT must demonstrate (1) that some or all of its members have standing to sue; (2)that the interests advanced in the case are sufficiently related to the UFT's organizationalpurposes to satisfy the court that the UFT is an appropriate representative of those interests; and(3) that the [*2]participation of the individual members is notrequired to assert the claim or to afford the UFT complete relief (Matter of Dental Socy. ofState of N.Y. v Carey, 61 NY2d 330, 332-334 [1984] [recognizing standing ofunincorporated association]; see alsoNew York State Assn. of Nurse Anesthetists v Novello, 2 NY3d 207, 211[2004]).[FN1]The UFT easily satisfies this test as to each of the 19 subject schools. At a minimum, the UFTwould derive standing from its chapter leader at each school, given that the chapter leader (or hisor her designee) is, pursuant to respondents' regulations, a mandatory member of the institution'sschool leadership team, the body constituting the "school-based management team" (SBMT)mandated by section 2590-h to participate in the consideration of a proposed phaseout. Inaddition, those UFT members who are employed at the schools proposed to be phased out havean interest in the matter that would give them standing to sue. Further, the interestsinvolved—school closure and the integrity of the school closure process—aregermane to the UFT's organizational purpose, thereby making the union an appropriaterepresentative of those interests. Finally, the participation in the proceeding of all interestedindividual members of the UFT is not necessary to afford complete relief, since the petitionseeks only to nullify the determinations to close the subject schools. Accordingly, based on theUFT's standing to advance the claims asserted in the petition, we may proceed to consider themerits of those claims.[FN2]

Whether the applicable standard of review is strict compliance or substantial compliance, thecourt properly determined that respondents' EIS for each school failed to comply with thesubstantive requirements of Education Law § 2590-h (2-a) (b). In particular, each EIS failsto indicate, as required by Education Law § 2590-h (2-a) (b) (i), the "ramifications of suchschool closing or significant change in school utilization upon the community" and, as requiredby section 2590-h (2-a) (b) (ii), "the impacts of the proposed school closing or significant changein school utilization to any affected students." Rather, each EIS merely indicates the number ofschool seats that will be eliminated as a result of the proposed phaseout, and states that the seatswill be recovered through the phase-in of other new schools or through available seats in existingschools in the district or city. While the statute does not specify the information that an EISshould include to portray the impact of a proposed phaseout on the community or the students,respondents do not discharge their obligation by providing nothing more than boilerplateinformation about seat availability. Granting that the statute affords respondents a considerablemeasure of discretion in this regard, respondents abused that discretion by limiting theinformation they provided to the obvious—that students at phased-out schools would beaccommodated at other schools to be determined. Plainly, the Legislature contemplated that theschool community would receive more information than this from the EIS (see AssemblyMem [*3]in Support, Bill Jacket, L 2009, ch 345, 2009McKinney's Session Laws of NY, at 1713 ["This process requires the Chancellor to develop andmake public (an EIS) that details the impacts of the proposed school closing or significantchange in school utilization"]). Even if each EIS provides adequate information regarding theability of other schools in the affected community district to accommodate affected students, asrequired by Education Law § 2590-h (2-a) (b) (vi), it fails to provide adequate informationregarding the ramifications of the proposed agency action on the community and the students.The discussion of one point does not obviate the need for a discussion of the other.

The court also properly determined that, in the case of each subject school, respondentsfailed to "hold a joint public hearing with the impacted community council and [SBMT]" asrequired by Education Law § 2590-h (2-a) (d).[FN3]As the court found, for the notion of a joint hearing to have any meaning, the members of thecommunity councils and SBMTs must be part of the process of structuring and conducting thosehearings. Contrary to respondents' contention, paragraph (d) of subdivision (2-a) requires themto include or consult with the community councils regarding the joint public hearings for allproposed school phaseouts, with no exception for high schools. Respondents were also requiredto give the community councils notice of the high school hearings. Moreover, the court properlydetermined that respondents failed to file a copy of each EIS with the impacted SBMT asrequired by Education Law § 2590-h (2-a) (c).

Based on the foregoing, the court properly annulled the PEP votes (see generally ChineseStaff & Workers Assn. v City of New York, 68 NY2d 359, 369 [1986]). Contrary torespondents' contention, the statutory violations are not "so insignificant as to be totallyinconsequential" (cf. Roosevelt Is. Residents Assn. v Roosevelt Is. OperatingCorp., 7 Misc 3d 1029[A], 2005 NY Slip Op 50811[U], *14 [2005]).Concur—Friedman, J.P., Nardelli, Moskowitz, Freedman and Manzanet-Daniels, JJ.[*4]

Motion seeking leave to file amicus curiae brief granted.[Prior Case History: 28 Misc 3d 204.]

Footnotes


Footnote 1: In view of the Court of Appeals'decision in Dental Socy. of State of N.Y. (supra), it is apparent that GeneralAssociations Law § 12 is not construed to condition an unincorporated association'sstanding on every individual member's having standing.

Footnote 2: The determination that the UFThas standing renders it unnecessary to consider the standing of the remaining named petitioners(see Saratoga County Chamber of Commerce v Pataki, 100 NY2d 801, 813 [2003],cert denied 540 US 1017 [2003]).

Footnote 3: For purposes of article 52-A ofthe Education Law (which includes section 2590-h), "[t]he term 'community council' shall meanthe community district education council of a community district established pursuant to section[2590-c] of this article" (Education Law § 2590-a [4]).


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.