| Matter of Revere v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 06121 [75 AD3d 860] |
| July 15, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Terrence Revere et al., Petitioners, vCommissioner of Taxation and Finance et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Julie S. Mereson of counsel), forCommissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.
Malone Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this court pursuant to TaxLaw § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal which, amongother things, sustained an assessment of personal income tax imposed under Tax Law article 22.
Petitioners, husband and wife, were employees of Revco Construction Corporation, whichpetitioner Candace Revere owned and petitioner Terrence Revere operated. As a result of anaudit in 2003 of Revco's withholding tax returns, which revealed that Revco had madesubstantial payments to petitioners for which tax had not been withheld and which were notreported on Revco's W-2 forms or withholding tax returns, the Department of Taxation andFinance issued a withholding tax assessment to Revco and to the wife, as the responsible personfor the company, and imposed penalties and interest. Revco agreed with the tax assessment andthereafter submitted, among other things, revised W-2 forms for the periods covered by the audit.After Revco issued the revised W-2 forms, petitioners filed amended joint income tax returns forthe 1997 through 2001 tax years, adding the previously unreported income and claimingwithholding credits based on the amended W-2 forms. The wife filed a separate amended incometax return for 2002 in which she also claimed the withholding tax credit. According topetitioners, the payments were not originally reported because the wife had diverted the money[*2]from Revco, allegedly without the husband's knowledge, inorder to support her gambling addiction.
Following an audit of petitioners' personal tax returns, the Department disallowed thewithholding tax credits and ultimately issued petitioners a notice of deficiency in the amount of$539,013.61 for their joint tax returns for the years 1997 through 2001, and issued the wife anotice of deficiency in the amount of $136,021.51 on her separate return for the year 2002. Thedeficiency notices included penalties based on negligent or intentional failure to withhold.
Petitioners thereafter sought a redetermination of the deficiency amounts in the Division ofTaxation. After a hearing, the Administrative Law Judge (hereinafter ALJ) sustained the noticeof deficiencies, concluding that petitioners had received payments from Revco for which no taxhad been withheld, and denied the husband's claim for innocent spouse relief. The ALJdetermined that petitioners were liable for the negligence penalty, as initially assessed, but notthe fraud penalty, as was sought by the Division. After petitioners and the Division filedexceptions to the ALJ's determination, respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal sustained the ALJ'sdeterminations with respect to the withholding tax, interest due and denial of innocent spouserelief, and reversed the ALJ's denial of fraud penalties. Petitioners then commenced this CPLRarticle 78 proceeding to review the Tribunal's determination.
Petitioners bore the burden of proving by clear and convincing evidence that the deficiencyassessment was erroneous (see Tax Law § 689 [e]; Matter of Levin vGallman, 42 NY2d 32, 34 [1977]; Matter of Suburban Restoration Co. v Tax AppealsTrib. of State of N.Y., 299 AD2d 751, 752 [2002]), and a determination by the Tribunal thatis supported by substantial evidence will not be disturbed (see Matter of Callicutt v NewYork State Commr. of Taxation & Fin., 241 AD2d 778, 779 [1997]; Matter of Hopper vCommissioner of Taxation & Fin., 224 AD2d 733, 737 [1996], lv denied 88 NY2d808 [1996]). In that regard, an employee may not claim a withholding tax credit unless the taxwas "actually deducted and withheld" by his or her employer (Tax Law § 673; seeByers v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 351 Fed Appx 161 [8th Cir 2009]; UnitedStates v Kuntz, 259 F2d 871, 872 [2d Cir 1958]). Here, the Tribunal rejected petitioners'claim that the tax was actually withheld by Revco. "Withholding . . . occurs at thetime of payment to the employee of his [or her] net wages" (Begier v IRS, 496US 53, 60-61 [1990] [emphasis added and citation omitted]). Taxes actually withheld by theemployer are credited to the employee when the net wages are paid (see Slodov v UnitedStates, 436 US 238, 243 [1978]; see also 20 NYCRR 171.1 [b]), and petitioners didnot submit any evidence to support their claim that taxes were withheld by Revco at the time thatthe payments at issue were made to them. We find no merit in petitioners' argument that the TaxCommission was precluded from pursuing deficiencies against petitioners' personal income taxreturns because the wife was found to be personally liable for Revco's deficiencies as aresponsible person under Tax Law § 685 (g). We are not persuaded that petitioners' taxliability is absolved here because a "responsible person" for the company failed to pay the tax onbehalf of the employer (see e.g. Church v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 810 F2d19, 20 [2d Cir 1987]; Frederick v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 327 Fed Appx332, 333-334 [3d Cir 2009]). Accordingly, and deferring to the Tribunal's competence ininterpreting the statute it is charged with administering, we find its determination with respect topetitioners' liability to be supported by a rational basis (see Matter of Fuchsberg & Fuchsberg v Commissioner of Taxation &Fin., 13 AD3d 831, 833 [2004]).
We also find that the record supports the Tribunal's determination that the Tax [*3]Commission met its burden of demonstrating petitioners' fraudulentintent by clear and convincing evidence (see Tax Law § 689 [e] [1]; Matter ofKucherov v Chu, 147 AD2d 877, 878 [1989]). The only records petitioners provided for theRevco audit were bank records, canceled checks and withholding tax returns for Revco's otheremployees—notably, they did not provide any journals or payroll records. Petitionersunderreported their own income by millions of dollars over a period of several years and then,after the failure to withhold taxes on that income had been brought to their attention by theRevco audit, they claimed the withholding credit on their amended personal returns withoutnotifying the auditor. Notably, the wife, who was purportedly solely responsible for petitioners'finances, did not testify at the hearing. The husband had previously operated anotherconstruction business before starting Revco and admitted to having withholding tax problems inthe past. Revco went out of business after it was audited and the husband started anotherconstruction business, which he owns and in which he controls all of the finances. The Tribunaldid not credit the hearsay evidence that the wife's secret gambling addiction caused her tosquander Revco's profits. Nor did it find the husband's professed complete ignoranceof—and disinterest in—Revco's substantial profits, and the disposal thereof, logicalor credible. According deference to the Tribunal's credibility determinations (see Matter of Rubin v Tax Appeals Trib. ofState of N.Y., 29 AD3d 1089, 1092 [2006]; Matter of Suburban Restoration Co. vTax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 299 AD2d at 752), we find that the record supports itsfinding of clear and convincing evidence of fraud.
Finally, as to the husband's claim for innocent spouse relief, we note that the applicablestatutory law evolved during the period in question (see Tax Law § 651 [former(b) (5) (A)]; § 654); however, the determinative issue for purposes of the instant claim hasremained essentially the same. As the party seeking innocent spouse relief, the husband herebore the burden of establishing, among other things, that at the time the underlying amendedjoint income tax returns were signed, he did not know or have reason to know of theunderstatements (compare Tax Law § 651 [former (b) (5) (A)]; § 654; 26USC § 6015 [b] [1] [C]; [c] [2]; Matter of Rubin v Tax Appeals Trib. of State ofN.Y., 29 AD3d at 1090; Cheshire v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 282 F3d326, 332-334 [5th Cir 2002], cert denied 537 US 881 [2002]). His claim of intentionalignorance regarding the preparation of his joint tax returns was not credited by the Tribunal andis not a legal defense to the assessed deficiencies. "The 'innocent spouse' exemption was notdesigned to protect willful blindness or to encourage the deliberate cultivation of ignorance"(Friedman v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 53 F3d 523, 525 [2d Cir 1995]). "Inshort, an innocent spouse is one who despite having made reasonable efforts to investigate theaccuracy of the joint return remains ignorant of its illegitimacy" (id.). By his ownadmission, the husband made little or no effort to investigate the accuracy of the tax returnsbecause he did not want to be involved. The record does not reflect what action, if any, thehusband took to insure that his amended joint returns accurately accounted for the tax due on thepreviously unreported income that was revealed by the Revco audit. Consequently, substantialevidence supports the Tribunal's determination to deny the husband innocent spouse status.
Mercure, J.P., Peters, Spain and Kavanagh, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.