| Matter of Wells (Madison Consulting, Inc.\MCommissioner ofLabor) |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 07090 [77 AD3d 993] |
| October 7, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Dwight J. Wells, Respondent.Madison Consulting, Inc., Appellant. Commissioner of Labor, Respondent. (And AnotherRelated Claim.) |
—[*1] McNamee, Lochner, Titus & Williams, P.C., Albany (Francis J. Smith of counsel), forDwight J. Wells, respondent. Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel), forCommissioner of Labor, respondent.
Garry, J. Appeals from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filedAugust 15, 2008, which, among other things, ruled that Madison Consulting, Inc. was liable foradditional unemployment insurance contributions on remuneration paid to claimant and thosesimilarly situated.
Madison Consulting, Inc. is engaged in the business of providing management andoperational consulting services to large financial institutions. Following September 11, 2001,Madison was hired by various institutions to provide consultants to work on projects targeted atuncovering potential money laundering activities and also to prepare suspicious activity reports.Madison, in turn, retained claimant and other like individuals to assist in identifying suchactivities and preparing such reports. In connection with their assignments, claimant and theseindividuals entered into independent consulting agreements with Madison. After claimant was nolonger working for Madison, he filed a claim for unemployment insurance benefits. [*2]Following extended proceedings, the Unemployment InsuranceAppeal Board concluded that claimant and other similarly situated individuals who providedconsulting services were employees of Madison. Accordingly, it issued decisions awardingclaimant unemployment insurance benefits and assessing Madison for additional unemploymentinsurance contributions on remuneration paid to claimant and others similarly situated. Madisonappeals.
We affirm. Initially, we note that the existence of an employment relationship is a factualissue for the Board to resolve and its determination will be upheld if supported by substantialevidence (see Matter of Concourse Ophthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736[1983]; Matter of Brevis Music Inc.[Commissioner of Labor], 54 AD3d 1084, 1085 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 712[2008]). Where professionals are involved, the relevant inquiry is "whether the purportedemployer retains overall control of important aspects of the services performed" (Matter of Piano School of N.Y. City[Commissioner of Labor], 71 AD3d 1358, 1359 [2010]; see Matter of ConcourseOphthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d at 736; Matter of Parisi [Commissioner of Labor], 54 AD3d 456, 457[2008]).
In the instant case, it was established that claimant contacted Madison after hearing about theposition from another consultant and that Madison conducted an interview to ascertain ifclaimant was suited for the job. Madison, in turn, sent claimant a written contract setting hiscompensation at $350 per day and referred him to the client who performed a background check,provided training and directed his daily work activities. Under the terms of the contract, claimantwas precluded from otherwise working for Madison's client companies or partners during theterm of the assignment and for one year thereafter, was subject to client confidentialityagreements and was entitled to reimbursement of certain business expenses. In order to obtainpayment, claimant was required to complete a time sheet provided by Madison to be submitted attimes it directed. In addition, although Madison did not provide formal training, it suppliedclaimant with informational booklets on its clients' policies and procedures, had a representativeconduct site visits to periodically meet with the consultants and responded to client complaintsabout consultants' work.
This Court has acknowledged that " 'an organization which screens the services ofprofessionals, pays them at a set rate and then offers their services to clients exercises sufficientcontrol to create an employment relationship' " (Matter of Singh [Thomas A. Sirianni, Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor], 43 AD3d 498, 499 [2007], quoting Matter of Kimberg [Hudacs], 188AD2d 781, 781 [1992]; see Matter of Atelek [Head Hunters HairDesign—Commissioner of Labor], 278 AD2d 560, 560 [2000]). The recordreveals that Madison did more than this, as indicated by its interaction with the consultants,responsibility for their work and the terms of the written contract. The fact that the contract wasentitled an "Independent Consultant Agreement" is not dispositive (see Matter of Kaplan[Tupperware Distrib.—Commissioner of Labor], 257 AD2d 951, 952 [1999], lvdismissed 93 NY2d 920 [1999]). Accordingly, as substantial evidence supports the Board'sdecisions, we decline to disturb them, notwithstanding evidence in the record that would supporta contrary conclusion (see Matter ofDeSantis [Commissioner of Labor], 54 AD3d 1103, 1104-1105 [2008]). Madison'sremaining arguments have been considered and have been found to be lacking in merit.
Spain, J.P., Lahtinen, Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.