Kelsey v McNally
2010 NY Slip Op 07644 [77 AD3d 1230]
October 28, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 15, 2010


Bryn Kelsey, Respondent,
v
Aileen McNally,Appellant.

—[*1]Aileen McNally, Woodstock, appellant pro se.

Bryn Kelsey, Woodstock, respondent pro se.

Stein, J. Appeal from an order of the County Court of Ulster County (Bruhn, J.), enteredApril 29, 2009, which affirmed a judgment of the Justice Court of the Town of Woodstock.

Defendant paid $500 to plaintiff upon entering into a commercial lease agreement.[FN1]Both parties agree that $250 of this amount was for the first month's rent. However, defendantcontends that the remaining $250 was for the last month's rent and that no security deposit wasrequired, while plaintiff maintains that it was to be used as a security deposit. After thetermination of defendant's tenancy, plaintiff commenced this small claims action to recover thefinal month's rent in the amount of $250, plus $443 representing the alleged cost of repairingdamage to the floor and a door of the property, for a total of $693. At trial, plaintiffacknowledged that she had not subtracted the $250 security deposit from the alleged repaircosts—nor had she applied $250 toward the last month's rent —[FN2]and, thus, the actual amount she was [*2]seeking to recover was$443. Nevertheless, Justice Court awarded plaintiff the sum of $540, plus $10 in costs. Upondefendant's appeal, County Court affirmed the judgment and defendant now appeals.

The trial court in small claims actions is not "bound by statutory provisions or rules ofpractice, procedure, pleading or evidence" (UJCA 1804; see Ellis v Collegetown Plaza,301 AD2d 758, 759 [2003]). Thus, "[t]he scope of appellate review of small claims cases islimited" (H.E.A.T. Enters., Ltd. vWillette, 57 AD3d 1025, 1026 [2008])—the only inquiry being whether"substantial justice has not been done between the parties" (UJCA 1807; see Ellis vCollegetown Plaza, 301 AD2d at 759). However, where, as here, the decision is clearlyerroneous, it must be overturned (see Moses v Randolph, 236 AD2d 706, 707 [1997];compare Borman v Purvis, 299 AD2d 615, 616 [2002]).

Inasmuch as plaintiff acknowledged that she was entitled to recover no more than $443 andJustice Court's judgment exceeded that amount, it is clear that the award of $540 was erroneous.Based upon our review of the record, it is evident that the only logical way that Justice Courtcould have arrived at an amount exceeding $443 was if it failed to account for the $250 paid bydefendant at the outset of the lease term. However, taking into account Justice Court's superiorability to observe witnesses and to make credibility determinations, we otherwise discern nofailure to effect substantial justice between the parties (see Moses v Randolph, 236 AD2dat 707). It was reasonable for Justice Court to determine that a portion of the repairs was due tonormal wear and tear or to plaintiff's desire to improve the space for the next tenant, as opposedto damage inflicted by defendant. Therefore, in the exercise of our authority to render judgmentthat we find warranted by the facts adduced at trial (see CPLR 5501; NorthernWestchester Professional Park Assoc. v Town of Bedford, 60 NY2d 492, 499 [1983]; butsee Thoreson v Penthouse Intl., 80 NY2d 490, 495 [1992]), we reduce the judgment by $250,resulting in a total judgment of $290 plus $10 costs.

Defendant's remaining contentions have been reviewed and are unavailing.

Cardona, P.J., Peters, Rose and Malone Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is modified, onthe facts, without costs, by reducing the amount awarded to plaintiff to $290 plus $10 costs, and,as so modified, affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: The record does not include acopy of the lease.

Footnote 2: We note that, under thecircumstances, it makes no difference how the $250 paid is characterized as it may be offsetagainst the last month's rent that defendant was undisputedly obligated to pay, leaving only thequestion of the cost of repairing the property damage, if any.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.