| Matter of Regeneron Pharms., Inc. v McCarthy |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 07649 [77 AD3d 1246] |
| October 28, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Respondent, vSusan McCarthy, as Assessor of the Town of East Greenbush, et al., Appellants, et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Kaye Scholer, L.L.P., New York City (H. Peter Haveles, Jr. of counsel), forrespondent.
Mercure, J.P. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Lynch, J.), entered January 5,2010 in Rensselaer County, which, among other things, granted petitioner's application, in aproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, to annul a determination of respondent Assessor of theTown of East Greenbush classifying certain real property as taxable.
Petitioner owns and operates a pharmaceutical manufacturing facility in the Town of EastGreenbush, Rensselaer County. In 2003, petitioner and respondent Rensselaer County IndustrialDevelopment Agency (hereinafter RCIDA) entered into three agreements for the purpose ofproviding financial assistance to petitioner in connection with its proposed expansion of itsexisting facility (see General Municipal Law § 854 [14]; § 874 [1]; RPTL412-a [1]). Specifically, petitioner agreed to grant RCIDA a leasehold interest in its property;RCIDA then subleased the property back to petitioner with restrictions on the use of the property;and the parties entered into a payment in lieu of tax (hereinafter PILOT) agreement pursuant towhich the property would be granted tax exempt status, but petitioner would make annual PILOTpayments to the various taxing entities having jurisdiction over the property. As relevant here, thePILOT [*2]agreement was to be effective until December 31,2013, and provided that payments to taxing entities would be calculated based upon an "assessedvalue" of $4.5 million multiplied by the applicable tax rate.
Thereafter, petitioner filed an application for a real property tax exemption (seeRPTL 412-a [2]) and made PILOT payments to respondent Town of East Greenbush based uponthe assessed value set forth in the PILOT agreement. In July 2008, however, respondent Assessorof the Town of East Greenbush reassessed all real property located in the Town, including thesubject property, which was reassessed at $20 million and treated as only partially tax exempt.Petitioner then commenced this proceeding challenging the new assessment, and seeking anorder directing respondents to restore the exemption and comply with the PILOT agreement.Following joinder of issue, Supreme Court granted petitioner's application, annulled the newassessment of petitioner's property on the 2008 and 2009 tax rolls, and directed the Assessor torestore petitioner's exemption in accord with the PILOT agreement. The Town Assessor,respondent Town of East Greenbush Board of Assessment Review and respondent Town of EastGreenbush (hereinafter collectively referred to as the Town) now appeal.
General Municipal Law § 874 (1) provides that an industrial development agency"shall be regarded as performing a governmental function in the exercise of the powers conferredupon it by this title and shall be required to pay no taxes or assessments upon any of the propertyacquired by it or under its jurisdiction or control or supervision or upon its activities"(emphasis added). Similarly, RPTL 412-a (1) states that "[r]eal property owned by or underthe jurisdiction, supervision or control of industrial development agencies enumerated in the[G]eneral [M]unicipal [L]aw shall be entitled to such exemption as may be provided therein"(emphasis added). It is well settled that although "the statute[s] explicitly confer[ ] thisexemption only on the industrial development agency, private developers who act as the agency'sagent for project purposes may also enjoy this tax benefit" (Matter of Fagliarone, Grimaldi &Assoc. v Tax Appeals Trib., 167 AD2d 767, 768 [1990]). Furthermore, it must be noted thatGeneral Municipal Law § 888 provides that "[i]nsofar as the provisions of this title areinconsistent with the provisions of any other act . . . or of any local laws of [a]municipality, the provisions of this title shall be controlling."
The parties are in agreement that entitlement to the exemption herein turns upon whether theproperty at issue is under the jurisdiction, supervision or control of RCIDA (see GeneralMunicipal Law § 874 [1]; RPTL 412-a [1]). The Town concedes that a conveyance ofproperty to an industrial development agency, followed by a subsequent leaseback of property,creates the necessary jurisdiction, supervision or control required to demonstrate entitlement tothe exemption (see Matter of Pyramid Co. of Watertown v Tibbets, 76 NY2d 148, 151[1990]; see also 9 Ops Counsel SBEA No. 17 [1987] [concluding that land leased to anindustrial development agency is also entitled to the exemption]). The Town argues, however,that the lease and leaseback transaction here do not result in any change in jurisdiction,supervision or control over the property because, the Town maintains, RCIDA has taken noresponsibility or authority over petitioner or its property. We disagree.
It is undisputed that the entire property has been demised and leased to RCIDA. In contrast,the sublease back to petitioner imposes various conditions and limitations on petitioner and itsuse of the property. Petitioner is obligated, for example, to proceed as RCIDA's agent in theproposed expansion of the facilities with "due diligence" and according to the plans to whichRCIDA agreed. In addition, petitioner is prohibited from using the facility as anything other than[*3]a pharmaceutical manufacturing plant or altering its businessstructure without RCIDA's consent. Further, petitioner is required to maintain the facility in goodcondition and repair and to allow RCIDA to inspect the property.
Given these limitations, along with authority establishing that land leased both to and by anindustrial development agency is under the agency's jurisdiction, supervision, or control (seeMatter of Pyramid Co. of Watertown v Tibbets, 76 NY2d at 151; 9 Ops Counsel SBEA No.17 [1987]), Supreme Court properly concluded both that the property is entitled to the exemptionand that petitioner is entitled to make PILOT payments pursuant to its agreement withRCIDA.[FN*]We have considered the Town's remaining arguments and conclude that they do not require adifferent result.
Rose, Malone Jr., Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs. [Prior Case History: 26 Misc 3d 1203(A), 2009 NY Slip Op 52638(U).]
Footnote *: We note that while the 2008reassessment reduced the tax rate in the Town of East Greenbush from $81 to $21 per $1,000 ofassessed property value—resulting in a substantially lower PILOT owed by petitioner onits property assessment of $4.5 million—the Town of East Greenbush and its Assessorwere given the required notice and opportunity to participate in the process that resulted in theformula for calculation of the PILOT payments set forth in the agreement (see Matter of Steel Los III/Goya Foods, Inc.v Board of Assessors of County of Nassau, 10 NY3d 445, 455-456 [2008]).Nevertheless, the Town of East Greenbush chose not to participate and, after petitioner filed itsapplication for a real property tax exemption, accepted petitioner's PILOT payments from 2003until the reassessment in 2008 (see generally Troy Towers Redevelopment Co. v City ofTroy, 51 AD2d 173, 175-176 [1976], affd for reasons stated below 41 NY2d 816[1977]).