| Matter of Searfoss v Anchor Glass Container Corp. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 08050 [78 AD3d 1368] |
| November 10, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Victor Searfoss, Respondent, v AnchorGlass Container Corporation et al., Appellants, and Special Disability Fund, Respondent. Workers'Compensation Board, Respondent. |
—[*1] Steven M. Licht, Special Funds Conservation Committee, Albany (Jill B. Singer of counsel), forSpecial Disability Fund, respondent.
Kavanagh, J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed December 23,2009, which discharged the Special Disability Fund from liability upon the ground that the claim forreimbursement was not timely filed.
In 2000, claimant injured his neck and shoulder in the course of his employment, and he promptlysought medical treatment. Claimant began missing work due to the injury in 2005, and his workers'compensation claim was indexed in July of that year. His claim was established, and the workers'compensation carrier for the employer filed a C-250 form applying for reimbursement from the SpecialDisability Fund in February 2006. A workers' compensation law judge ruled that the application forreimbursement was timely, and the Fund sought review. The Workers' Compensation Board reversed,finding the application to be untimely, and the [*2]employer and itscarrier (hereinafter collectively referred to as the employer) now appeal.
We reverse. The employer argued that the Fund's application for review was untimely and shouldbe rejected, but the Board did not address the issue in its decision. While the Board has broaddiscretion to accept a late application for review (see Matter of Doner v Nassau County Police Dept., 24 AD3d 978, 979[2005]), its failure to make any findings on the issue require reversal (see Workers'Compensation Law § 23; Matter ofTucker v Fort Hudson Nursing Home, 65 AD3d 1442, 1442 [2009]; Matter of Rawlingsv Reliable Sample Co., 23 AD2d 921, 921-922 [1965]).
Remittal is further required for the Board to make necessary findings with regard to the merits. Inorder to obtain reimbursement from the Fund, an employer or carrier must file a form C-250 "prior tothe final determination that the resulting disability is permanent, but in no case more than [104] weeksafter the date of disability or death or [52] weeks after the date that a claim for compensation isfiled with the chair, whichever is later" (Workers' Compensation Law § 15 [8] [f] [emphasisadded]; see Matter of Cassata v GeneralMotors Powertrain, 71 AD3d 1342, 1343-1344 [2010]). The employer argued that its formC-250 was timely filed under either measurement, and the Board determined that its application hadbeen filed more than 104 weeks after the date of disability. The Board did not, however, determinewhen the underlying workers' compensation claim was filed or if the employer timely applied forreimbursement under the alternate measure (see e.g. Matter of Tagliavento v Borg-WarnerAuto, 252 AD2d 753, 753-754 [1998]). As any review of that issue would accordingly be"premised upon speculation rather than upon the controlling substantial evidence standard," the Boardmust address that issue upon remittal (Matter of Patterson v Long Is. Jewish Med. Ctr., 296AD2d 774, 776 [2002]).
Spain, J.P., Stein, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is reversed,without costs, and matter remitted to the Worker's Compensation Board for further proceedings notinconsistent with this Court's decision.