| Matter of Haight v Con Edison |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 08678 [78 AD3d 1468] |
| November 24, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Robert Haight, Appellant, v ConEdison et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board, Respondent. |
—[*1] Cherry, Edson & Kelly, Tarrytown (Ralph E. Magnetti of counsel), for Con Edison and another,respondents.
Kavanagh, J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed March 9, 2009,as amended by decision filed August 28, 2009, which, among other things, ruled that claimant wasentitled to permanent partial disability benefits rather than a schedule loss of use award for his shoulderinjury.
In separate incidents at work, claimant sustained injuries to his right shoulder and back, and hisensuing workers' compensation claims were established. Among other things, the parties disputedwhether claimant should receive a schedule loss of use award for the shoulder claim or an ongoingaward of disability benefits that included both the shoulder and back claims. The Workers'Compensation Board ultimately determined that the shoulder and back injuries jointly warranted apermanent, partial disability classification, and claimant appeals.
"Whether a condition warrants a schedule loss award or an award of continuing disability benefits isa question of fact for resolution by the Board," and its determination will be [*2]upheld if supported by substantial evidence (Matter of Jweid v Vicks Lithograph &Print., 25 AD3d 930, 931 [2006] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; seeMatter of Paoletti v Ellis & Kustell, 289 AD2d 733, 734 [2001]). An award of continuingdisability benefits, rather than one for a schedule loss of use, is appropriate "[w]here there is acontinuing condition of pain or continuing need for medical treatment or the medical condition remainsunsettled" (Matter of Clark v General Elec. Co., 68 AD2d 960 [1979]; accord Matter ofDillabough v Jaquith Indus., 305 AD2d 884, 884-885 [2003]). Here, the physicians who offeredopinions on the issue concluded that claimant's shoulder injury was amenable to a schedule loss of useaward. Claimant's treating physician, however, testified that claimant would require ongoing treatmentfor pain. Moreover, his shoulder disability arose in part from work-related arthritis and adhesivecapsulitis, conditions that support a classification under the Board's medical guidelines if certain factorsare present. While claimant argues that those factors are not present here, the guidelines only "provideuseful criteria" that need not be slavishly followed by the Board if its factual determination is properlysupported (Matter of Floyd v Millard Fillmore Hosp., 299 AD2d 610, 612 [2002]; see Matter of Barager-Dieter v Kelly TemporaryServs., 1 AD3d 725, 726 [2003]). As the Board's determination is supported by substantialevidence, it will not be disturbed (see Matter of Dillabough v Jaquith Indus., 305 AD2d at884-885; Matter of Jett v Mark Baking Co., 192 AD2d 895, 897 [1993]; Matter ofManfredi v Babcock Constr. Corp., 33 AD2d 852, 853 [1969]).
Mercure, J.P., Malone Jr., Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decision is affirmed,without costs.