| Matter of Coleman v Bezio |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 09052 [79 AD3d 1332] |
| December 9, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Mark Coleman, Petitioner, v Norman R. Bezio,as Director of Special Housing and Inmate Disciplinary Programs,Respondent. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
McCarthy, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of the Commissioner ofCorrectional Services which found petitioner guilty of violating a prison disciplinary rule.
Petitioner was charged in a misbehavior report with using a controlled substance after a specimenof his urine twice tested positive for the presence of cannabinoids. He was found guilty of the charge atthe conclusion of a tier III disciplinary hearing and the determination was affirmed on administrativeappeal. This CPLR article 78 proceeding ensued.
Petitioner asserts, among other things, that the determination is not supported by substantialevidence because the chain of custody of the specimen was not established in accordance with theregulations (see 7 NYCRR 1020.4). Specifically, petitioner claims that the correction officerwho tested the specimen was seen in the yard after the specimen was taken and did not have it in hispossession at all times. The request for urinalysis form set forth in detail the times that the specimen wastaken, tested and disposed of, as well as the name of the individual who handled it. The form wascompleted by the correction officer who collected and tested the specimen. Although he could notrecall if he stayed in the room with the urine sample from the time it was obtained until it was tested andthe remainder destroyed, he testified regarding his routine, namely, that if he went anywhere else hewould have left the specimens in the testing machine in the locked urinalysis testing room. That officerwas the only person with keys to the testing room. This testimony demonstrates that the specimen waseither in the correction officer's physical possession or locked in a secure location under his exclusivecontrol, sufficient to establish that the chain of custody was properly maintained (see Matter of Odome v Goord, 8 AD3d921, 922 [2004]). The misbehavior report, the officer's testimony, the positive urinalysis testresults and supporting documentation provide substantial evidence to support the determination of guilt(see Matter of Lindo v Fischer, 72AD3d 1295, 1295-1296 [2010]; Matterof Duffy v Fischer, 69 AD3d 1073, 1074 [2010]).
Petitioner's remaining contentions have either not been preserved for our review or are lacking inmerit.
Peters, J.P., Rose and Kavanagh, JJ., concur.
Egan Jr., J. (dissenting). In my view, the testimony of the correction officer who conducted theurinalysis testing fell below the minimum necessary to establish a reliable chain of custody, and Irespectfully dissent.
The concept of chain of custody by no means requires a correction officer performing a urinalysistest on an inmate to literally keep the sample in his or her physical possession from the moment of thedraw to the moment of testing. Circumstances may require the officer to put the sample aside andattend to other duties before performing the actual test; assuming the security of the sample can bedocumented in the interim, I have no quarrel.
In this case, it is apparent from the record that the officer performed tests on multiple inmates thatday, and there was a gap of approximately one hour and 25 minutes between receiving and testingpetitioner's sample. While first contending that petitioner's sample went from "him to me the wholetime," the officer then stated that if it was not in his custody the entire time, it would have been in theurinalysis room. Stating that "anything's possible," the officer explained that, because of the multiple testsconducted that day, he was unsure of the actual sequence of events without checking other records, butthat he could explain his "routine," what he does "on a daily basis." Because I believe that hearingtestimony as to how the chain of custody is routinely maintained can never be a substitute forthe case specific testimony, such as we have previously approved in Matter of Odome v Goord (8 AD3d921, 922 [2004]) and Matter ofGraziano v Selsky (9 AD3d 752, 752 [2004]), I find that an insufficient foundational basis forpetitioner's guilt was established and would annul the determination.
Adjudged that the determination is confirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.