| Gentile v Grand St. Med. Assoc. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 09059 [79 AD3d 1351] |
| December 9, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| Lisa Gentile, Appellant, v Grand Street Medical Associates,Respondent. |
—[*1] Cook, Netter, Cloonan, Kurtz & Murphy, P.C., Kingston (Robert D. Cook of counsel), forrespondent.
Peters, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Connolly, J.), entered September 3, 2009in Ulster County, which, among other things, granted defendant's motion for summary judgmentdismissing the complaint.
The Daily Freeman, a Kingston-based newspaper, published an article on May 2, 2008 reportingthat a sexual harassment suit had been filed against defendant by three of its former employees. Thearticle detailed the allegations of that lawsuit, and also reported that defendant had previously settled asexual harassment suit brought by plaintiff, another former employee, on confidential terms.Approximately three weeks later, defendant published a "paid advertisement" in the Daily Freemanresponding to the May 2, 2008 article. In that advertisement, defendant denied all current accusationsof wrongdoing and noted that "[t]he prior lawsuits mentioned in the Daily Freeman were resolved bythe parties on confidential terms with no acknowledgment of any wrongdoing by any parties." Theadvertisement went on to state that "[g]enerally, people work hard to make a living and contribute tothe community. It is a shame that several people in the community who do not want to work, hold jobsand want to make easy money, find a few lawyers who make a living exploiting hard working peopleand corporations. These people lower the standards of both the society and country." [*2]Citing this language, plaintiff thereafter commenced the instant actionagainst defendant for defamation. Following joinder of issue, defendant moved and plaintiffcross-moved for summary judgment. Supreme Court granted defendant's motion and dismissed thecomplaint, concluding that the paid advertisement contained nonactionable statements of opinion.Plaintiff appeals.
"Since falsity is a requirement of a defamation claim and only factual assertions are capable of beingproven false, defamation actions can only be premised on assertions of fact, not opinion" (Hassig v FitzRandolph, 8 AD3d 930,931 [2004]; see Brian v Richardson, 87 NY2d 46, 51 [1995]; Versaci v Richie, 30 AD3d 648, 649[2006], lv denied 7 NY3d 710 [2006]). Whether a particular statement constitutes a factualassertion or nonactionable expression of opinion is a question of law for the court to resolve (see Mann v Abel, 10 NY3d 271, 276[2008], cert denied 555 US —, 129 S Ct 1315 [2009]), with consideration tobe given to "(1) whether the specific language in issue has a precise meaning which is readilyunderstood; (2) whether the statements are capable of being proven true or false; and (3) whethereither the full context of the communication in which the statement appears or the broader social contextand surrounding circumstances are such as to signal . . . readers or listeners that what isbeing read or heard is likely to be opinion, not fact" (id. [internal quotation marks and citationsomitted]; see Bonanni v Hearst Communications, Inc., 58 AD3d 1091, 1092 [2009]). Thus,our inquiry distills to whether a reasonable reader would believe that the paid advertisement wasconveying facts about plaintiff (see Brian v Richardson, 87 NY2d at 51; Gross v NewYork Times Co., 82 NY2d 146, 152 [1993]; 600 W. 115th St. Corp. v Von Gutfeld, 80NY2d 130, 139 [1992], cert denied 508 US 910 [1993]).
Considering the content, context, tone and defensive posture of the advertisement (see Mann vAbel, 10 NY3d at 276), we find that a reasonable reader would conclude that the statementsrepresented the opinion of the author. "[E]ven apparent statements of fact may assume the character ofstatements of opinion, and thus be privileged, when made in . . . circumstances in whichan 'audience may anticipate [the use] of epithets, fiery rhetoric or hyperbole' " (Steinhilber vAlphonse, 68 NY2d 283, 294 [1986], quoting Information Control Corp. v Genesis OneComputer Corp., 611 F2d 781, 784 [9th Cir 1980]; see Brian v Richardson, 87 NY2d at52). Here, defendant was in the midst of litigation involving accusations of sexual harassment by three ofits employees. The statement, conspicuously labeled as a "paid advertisement," explicitly informed thereader that defendant was responding to an article regarding the alleged inappropriate conduct of oneof its employees, and which alleged that it "aided and abetted" the abuse through mismanagement ofpersonnel issues. A civil lawsuit, particularly one charging sexual harassment in the workplace, is by itsnature contentious and an average reader would recognize that statements made by the allegedwrongdoer in an "advertisement" published under such circumstances are likely to be the product ofpassionate advocacy. In this context, it is highly unlikely that the challenged statements would beunderstood as statements of fact, rather than a rhetorical expression of the author's opinion as to themotive for bringing the sexual harassment lawsuits (see 600 W. 115th St. Corp. v Von Gutfeld,80 NY2d at 141; Information Control Corp. v Genesis One Computer Corp., 611 F2d at784). Furthermore, the loose and generalized statement that those who brought the lawsuits "do notwant to work" or "hold jobs" and simply "want to make easy money" by "find[ing] a few lawyers whomake a living exploiting hard working people and corporations" is not capable of being proven true orfalse (see 600 W. 115th St. Corp. v Von Gutfeld, 80 NY2d at 142; compare Wilcox vNewark Val. Cent. School Dist., 74 AD3d [*3]1558, 1561[2010]; Rabushka v Marks, 229 AD2d 899, 902 [1996]).[FN*] Under these circumstances, we conclude that the statements at issue constitute nonactionable opinion.
Moreover, a defamation claim requires proof of special damages, meaning economic or financialloss, unless the alleged defamatory statements fall within an exception in which damages are presumed(see Liberman v Gelstein, 80 NY2d 429, 434-435 [1992]). Here, plaintiff has neither allegednor demonstrated special damages, and the statements at issue do not, on their face, allege a seriouscrime or relate to a matter of significance and importance in her profession (see id.;Aronson v Wiersma, 65 NY2d 592, 594 [1985]; Tourge v City of Albany, 285 AD2d785, 786 [2001]; Clemente v Impastato, 274 AD2d 771, 773 [2000]; Warlock Enters. vCity Ctr. Assoc., 204 AD2d 438 [1994]). Thus, in addition to being expressions of opinion,defendant's statements were not defamatory per se and, therefore, not actionable in light of plaintiff'sfailure to allege or establish special damages (see Hassig v FitzRandolph, 8 AD3d at 932;Butler v Ratner, 210 AD2d 691, 694 [1994], lv dismissed 85 NY2d 924 [1995]).
Cardona, P.J., Spain, Kavanagh and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed, withcosts.
Footnote *: With respect to the statement in theadvertisement that plaintiff's lawsuit was settled "with no acknowledgment of any wrongdoing by anyparties," there has been no assertion that it is false.