Matter of Zamora v New York Neurologic Assoc.
2010 NY Slip Op 09425 [79 AD3d 1471]
December 23, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 16, 2011


In the Matter of the Claim of Rocio Zamora, Appellant,
v
NewYork Neurologic Associates et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent.

—[*1]Grey & Grey, L.L.P., Farmingdale (Robert E. Grey of counsel), for appellant.

Vecchione, Vecchione & Connors, Garden City Park (Sean J. McKinley of counsel), for NewYork Neurologic Associates and another, respondents.

Spain, J. Appeal from a decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed March 13, 2009,which, among other things, denied claimant's claim for workers' compensation benefits.

In 2003, claimant, a phlebotomist, was injured at work when she was struck by a falling computermonitor. She applied for and received workers' compensation benefits, and was ultimately found tosuffer from a permanent partial disability. Claimant left her employment in 2007, leading the employerand its workers' compensation carrier (hereinafter collectively referred to as the employer) to questionwhether she had voluntarily withdrawn from the labor market. After a hearing, a workers' compensationlaw judge concluded that she had not. Upon review, the Workers' Compensation Board agreed, butheld that her subsequent efforts to find work were insufficient to establish an attachment to the labormarket and suspended benefits as of August 2008. Claimant now appeals.

We reverse. The parties do not take issue with the Board's finding that claimant did not voluntarilywithdraw from the workforce when she left her job in 2007. Accordingly, an [*2]inference arose that claimant's subsequent loss of wages was attributableto her disability, and it was incumbent upon the employer "to rebut the inference of causation or provethat the reduction in employment was solely due to factors unrelated to the disability" (Matter ofJohnson v Onondaga Heating & A.C., 301 AD2d 903, 905 [2003]; see Matter of Dudlo vPolytherm Plastics, 125 AD2d 792, 793 [1986]). This inference arises regardless of whether theBoard's finding of involuntary withdrawal from the labor market was caused by retirement or, as here,simply a failure to return to work (see Matterof Laing v Maryhaven Ctr. of Hope, 39 AD3d 1125, 1126 [2007], lv denied 9NY3d 805 [2007]; Matter of Louman vPremier Staffing, LLC, 12 AD3d 815, 816 [2004]; Matter of Johnson v OnondagaHeating & A.C., 301 AD2d at 904-905).

While a claimant's failure to look for work may be relevant in challenging a claimant's continuedright to benefits in these situations, such evidence, standing alone, is insufficient to rebut the inference(see Matter of Laing v Maryhaven Ctr. of Hope, 39 AD3d at 1126; Matter of Bryant v New York City Tr.Auth., 31 AD3d 936, 938 [2006]; Matter of Tipping v National Surface Cleaning Mgt., Inc., 29 AD3d1200, 1200-1201 [2006]; Matter ofPepe v City & Suburban, 29 AD3d 1184, 1185-1186 [2006]). Indeed, the employer mustshow "that the failure to seek employment was the sole cause of the subsequent reduction" (Matter of Pittman v ABM Indus., Inc., 24AD3d 1056, 1058 [2005] [emphasis added]; see Matter of Tipping v National SurfaceCleaning Mgt., Inc., 29 AD3d at 1200-1201). Here, claimant not only sought work after leavingemployment but found it on two occasions, only to discover that her disability prevented her fromperforming her new duties. As the employer produced nothing to show that any inadequacies inclaimant's job search were the sole cause of her continued unemployment, substantial evidence doesnot support the Board's determination.

Mercure and Lahtinen, JJ., concur.

Cardona, P.J. (dissenting). Respectfully, we dissent. In our opinion, there is a distinction betweenthose cases where a claimant has involuntarily retired and other cases where a claimant has involuntarilywithdrawn from the labor market, but has not retired. That distinction centers on when the inferencethat the claimant's subsequent loss of wages was attributable to his or her disability applies. It isimportant to note that, where, as here, "a claimant has a permanent partial disability but there has beenno finding of involuntary retirement, the claimant has an obligation to demonstrate attachment to thelabor market with evidence of a search for employment within medical restrictions" (Matter of Peck v James Sq. Nursing Home,34 AD3d 1033, 1034 [2006]; seeMatter of Stevenson v Sunoco Flexible Packaging, 43 AD3d 1260, 1261 [2007]; see e.g.Matter of Johnson v Onondaga Heating & A.C., 301 AD2d 903, 905 [2003]). In our view, onlyafter the non-retired claimant has met that burden does the inference arise that the subsequent loss of orreduction in wages, if any, was caused by the permanent partial disability. To hold otherwise wouldmean, for practical purposes, that a claimant with a permanent partial disability who has involuntarilywithdrawn from his or her particular employment but has not retired from the work force has noobligation to minimize the loss or reduction in earnings by searching for work within their medicallimitations, and results in an unfettered entitlement to compensation. Accordingly, inasmuch as therecord herein does not establish that claimant remained attached to the labor market by searching foremployment within her medical restrictions, we would affirm the decision of the Workers'Compensation Board.[*3]

Garry, J., concurs. Ordered that the decision is reversed, withcosts, and matter remitted to the Workers' Compensation Board for further proceedings notinconsistent with this Court's decision.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.