| Matter of Ferraro v Town Bd. of Town of Amherst |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 09691 [79 AD3d 1691] |
| December 30, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| In the Matter of Jerrold Ferraro et al., Appellants, v Town Board ofTown of Amherst et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] E. Thomas Jones, Town Attorney, Williamsville (Alan P. McCracken of counsel), forrespondent-defendant-respondent Town Board of Town of Amherst. Whiteman Osterman & Hanna LLP, Albany (John J. Henry of counsel), forrespondents-defendants-respondents Benderson Development Company, LLC, Buffalo-MapleRoad LLC and Buffalo-Anderson Associates, LLC.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Erie County (Rose H. Sconiers, J.), enteredSeptember 15, 2009 in a hybrid CPLR article 78 proceeding and declaratory judgment action.The judgment declared that Local Law No. 8 of the Town of Amherst is valid and lawful andotherwise dismissed the petition and complaint.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is affirmed without costs.
Memorandum: Petitioners-plaintiffs (petitioners) commenced this hybrid CPLR article 78proceeding and declaratory judgment action seeking, inter alia, to annul the determination ofrespondent-defendant Town Board of Town of Amherst (Town Board) in favor of rezoning twoadjacent parcels of property north of Maple Road in the Town of Amherst (Town). The propertyat issue is owned by respondents-defendants Buffalo-Maple Road LLC and Buffalo-AndersonAssociates, LLC, and respondent-defendant Benderson Development Company, LLC is theiragent (collectively, Benderson respondents). The property (hereafter, Benderson property) issituated to the [*2]east of a sports arena, to the south of theUniversity at Buffalo North Campus (University) and to the south and west of the Audubon GolfCourse (golf course). Most of the petitioners reside on the south side of Maple Road,which is a residential area. The Benderson respondents sought to have their property rezoned inorder to construct various commercial buildings, condominiums and a hotel. After petitionersprotested the proposed rezoning, the Benderson respondents amended the petition for rezoning toinclude a 101-foot buffer zone immediately adjacent to Maple Road, which would retain thesame zoning classification. The Town Board approved the amended petition for rezoning by avote of 4 to 3, concluding that the proposed rezoning was "generally consistent" with the Town'sBicentennial Comprehensive Plan (Plan). Supreme Court determined, inter alia, that theresolution approving the proposed rezoning passed by the Town Board's majority vote and that athree-fourths majority vote was not required, and the court otherwise dismissed the petition andcomplaint.
Petitioners contend that reversal is required because the owners of more than 20% of theproperty lying directly opposite the Benderson property had protested the rezoning and thus thepetition for rezoning required the approval of at least three-fourths of the Town Board members(see Town Law § 265 [1] [c]). We reject that contention. Pursuant to Town Law§ 265 (1) (c), the approval of at least three-fourths of the members of a town board isrequired in the event that an amendment is protested by "the owners of [20%] or more of the areaof land directly opposite thereto, extending [100] feet from the street frontage of such oppositeland." Petitioners contend that their properties were "directly opposite" the Benderson propertyand within 100 feet from the south side of Maple Road. Respondents, however, contend thatpetitioners' properties were required to be within 100 feet of the portion of the Bendersonproperty to be rezoned in order for section 265 (1) (c) to apply. We agree with respondents.
Here, we must determine what area of property is referred to by the word "thereto" in TownLaw § 265 (1) (c). The legislative history of that section establishes that subdivision (1) (c)was intended to apply to property directly opposite the property included in the proposedrezoning. The original proposed language of the statute provided that a three-fourths vote wasrequired if written protests were filed by "the owners of [20%] or more of the area of landdirectly opposite to that land included in such proposed change, extending [100] feetfrom the street frontage of such opposite land" (Recommendation of Law Rev Commn, 1990McKinney's Session Laws of NY, at 2311 [emphasis added]). The word "thereto" in the statute asenacted was substituted for the emphasized language in the proposed statute. Inasmuch as therewould be a 101-foot buffer zone between petitioners' properties and the rezoned portion of theBenderson property, we conclude that petitioners' properties are not directly opposite the propertyto be rezoned and that the property to be rezoned is not within 100 feet of the street frontage ofpetitioners' properties. Indeed, the buffer zone created by the Benderson respondents rendersTown Law § 265 (1) (c) inapplicable (see e.g. Matter of Eadie v Town Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 7 NY3d306, 314-315 [2006]; Ryan Homes,Inc. v Town Bd. of Town of Mendon, 7 Misc 3d 709, 712-714 [2005]).
Petitioners further contend that the driveways to the proposed development on the Bendersonproperty should have been rezoned and that petitioners' properties would be within 100 feet ofthat rezoned property. The Commissioner of Building for the Town determined in amemorandum to the Town Board that the driveways would serve a dual purpose and thus werenot required to be rezoned, and petitioners did not appeal that determination to the Zoning Boardof Appeals. Even assuming, arguendo, that petitioners were not required to exhaust theiradministrative remedies with respect to the determination of the Commissioner of Building, weconclude that petitioners' contention lacks merit (see Matter of Hampton Hill Villas Condominium Bd. of Mgrs. v Town ofAmherst Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 13 AD3d 1079 [2004]).[*3]
We reject petitioners' contention that the proposedrezoning violated the Town's Plan. "If the validity of the legislative classification for zoningpurposes [is] fairly debatable, the legislative judgment must be allowed to control. . . Thus, where the [challenging parties] fail[ ] to establish a clear conflict with thecomprehensive plan, the zoning classification must be upheld" (Bergstol v Town of Monroe, 15 AD3d324, 325 [2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 701 [2005] [internal quotation marks omitted];see Matter of Meteor Enters., LLC, vBylewski, 38 AD3d 1356, 1358 [2007]). By its terms, the Plan was not "meant to dictateland use . . . [Rather, it] was intended to communicate the overall direction andconcept of future development." It was "designed to be flexible . . . [and] to providea generalized guide for future development." Pursuant to the Plan, property to the north of thegolf course was set aside for a mixed-use center. The Plan also set aside the area of theBenderson property for park areas and green space, and residential areas along Maple Road wereto be protected "from further encroachments by new commercial development orredevelopment." In addition, however, the Plan sought to encourage commercial developmentnear the University and permitted commercial development in specific corridors, including asection of Maple Road close to the location of the Benderson property. The Town Boardconcluded that the proposed rezoning was consistent with the Plan because of the Bendersonproperty's proximity to the University, the fact that Maple Road was a major arterial road and theunlikely use of the Benderson property for any other development, based on its contaminationand proximity to the sports arena and the University's stadium. Although the Benderson propertyis not adjacent to the University's campus loop or accessible by Millersport Highway, theBenderson property is still in proximity to the University and is close to the Plan's proposedlocation of a mixed-use center. Further, the Plan's proposed location for a mixed-use center isalso across the street from a residential area and is buffered by green area in much the same wayas the Benderson respondents' proposed development. Although the recreation space on the northside of Maple Road, as proposed in the Plan, will give way to commercial development, therewill be a large recreational area preserved to the east of petitioners' properties. Keeping in mindthat the Plan was intended to be flexible and was meant to provide a generalized guide to futuredevelopment, we conclude that it is "fairly debatable" whether the proposed rezoning isconsistent with the overall Plan (Bergstol, 15 AD3d at 325 [internal quotation marksomitted]). It is undisputed that the proposed rezoning of the Benderson property conflicts withthe Plan's intended use of that property, but our review must be based on the Plan as a whole.Thus, because petitioners failed "to establish a clear conflict" with the overall Plan, theTown Board's zoning determination must be upheld (id.).
In view of our determination, we see no need to address petitioners' remaining contentions.
All concur except Fahey, J., who dissents and votes to reverse in accordance with thefollowing memorandum.
Fahey, J. (dissenting). I respectfully dissent inasmuch as I conclude that Supreme Court erredin dismissing the petition and complaint seeking, inter alia, to annul the determination thatapproved the rezoning petition and amended the Bicentennial Comprehensive Plan (Plan) of theTown of Amherst (Town) and in declaring that Local Law No. 8 (2008) of the Town was valid.
This appeal arises from the efforts of respondents-defendants Benderson DevelopmentCompany, LLC, Buffalo-Maple Road LLC and Buffalo-Anderson Associates, LLC (collectively,Benderson respondents) to develop two adjacent parcels of property (collectively, Bendersonproperty) located on Maple Road in the Town. The larger of the parcels, which was the formerhome of the Buffalo Shooting Club, consists of approximately 31.589 acres and had been zonedCommunity Facilities (CF). The smaller of the parcels consists of approximately 1.737 acres andhad been zoned Residential 3 (R-3).[*4]
The Benderson property sits on the north side of MapleRoad and is bordered on its west side by a residential area and on its north and east sides by theAudubon Golf Course (golf course). Both parcels of the Benderson property consist of primarilyopen, cleared space across Maple Road from a residential area. The Plan, which is intended, interalia, "to communicate the overall direction and concept of future development . . .[and] to present a composite picture of the Town at full development," alternatively designatesthe Benderson property as a "Private Recreation Area[ ]," an area of "Recreation, Open Space &Greenways" and "Park/green space."
The Benderson property is within the "University of Buffalo Focal Planning Area" (FPA) setforth in the Plan, and the FPA also includes the University at Buffalo North Campus(University), the Pepsi Center sports arena and an area designated for the development of amixed-use center (mixed-use area). The mixed-use area is situated to the north of the golf course,to the south and east of Millersport Highway, a divided highway that forms part of theUniversity's campus loop, and to the south and west of Ellicott Creek. The mixed-use area is alsolocated directly across Millersport Highway from the University.
The Benderson respondents seek to construct on the Benderson property a mixed-usedevelopment (hereafter, project) consisting of one- to three-story condominiums and townhouses,a five-story hotel and additional buildings housing retail and restaurant tenants. The proposedretail and restaurant buildings would be one- and two-story masonry and wood clapboardbuildings, reminiscent of late nineteenth and early twentieth century buildings that would havebeen typical of "Main Street" towns in Western New York. Nevertheless, the size of the project ismuch more modern in scale. Indeed, plans for the project required four driveways to servicetraffic to and from Maple Road, and one of the traffic studies prepared in conjunction with theproject indicates that those driveways will accommodate average weekday traffic ofapproximately 17,000 vehicles. Moreover, plans for the retail component of the project call forover 200,000 square feet of space and development of that nature is, as one resident who spokeagainst the project accurately noted, equivalent in size to a Wal-Mart.
In any event, in February 2007 the Benderson respondents filed a petition for rezoning withrespect to the Benderson property and proposed to rezone that property from CF and R-3 toGeneral Business (GB) and Multi-Family Residential 67 (MFR-67) in order to construct theproject. The Town of Amherst Planning Board (Planning Board) held a public hearing on thepetition and, in a resolution reached on the same date as the public hearing, made variousfindings "outlining the project's consistency with the . . . Plan."
Shortly thereafter, several Maple Road residents signed petitions protesting the proposedrezoning, and respondent-defendant Town Board of Town of Amherst (Town Board) held apublic hearing on the rezoning petition. From that point forward, the project changed slightly inscope, inasmuch as the Benderson respondents reduced the area to be rezoned to accommodate a4.5-acre conservation project or buffer area extending 101 feet north of Maple Road. Thereafter,the Town Assessor concluded that a supermajority vote of the Town Board would not be requiredto enact the proposed rezoning, and the Commissioner of Building (Building Commissioner)concluded that the driveways providing access to the retail areas of the project would serve a"dual purpose" and thus would not need to be rezoned.
The Town was not the only municipal entity to review the proposed rezoning. By letter datedMay 2, 2008, the Commissioner of the County of Erie Department of Environment and Planning(County) commented that, inter alia, the project "does not comply with the intent and objectivesof the . . . Plan" because the Plan refers to the intended use of the parcels inquestion as a recreation or "green" area; the project would cause commercial development toencroach upon areas of Maple Road that were intended to be protected from encroachments ofnew commercial development or redevelopment; and the Plan called for mixed-use developmentin the mixed-use area. Nevertheless, that letter concluded with the statement that, "[o]ther thanthe foregoing comments, the County has no recommendation concerning the [p]roject." Onemonth later, the Deputy Commissioner of the Erie County Division of Planning signed a GeneralMunicipal Law reply form indicating that it had no recommendation with respect to the proposedrezoning and that the proposed rezoning was deemed to be of local concern.
On June 2, 2008 the Town Board held a public hearing with respect to the proposed rezoningand, at the conclusion of the hearing, it narrowly voted, inter alia, to "accept[ ] therecommendation of the . . . Planning Board that the proposed project and rezoningare consistent with the . . . Plan" and to "amend[ ] the . . . Plan to theextent the rezoning is inconsistent with the Plan and adopt[ ] the attached Statement of Findingsand approve[ ] the rezoning of the [Benderson] property." The Town Board also enacted LocalLaw No. 8, which amended the Town's Code and Zoning Map to reflect the rezoning.
After that vote, petitioners-plaintiffs (petitioners) pursued judicial recourse. In a petition andcomplaint dated June 30, 2008, petitioners sought, inter alia, to annul the determination of theTown Board to rezone the Benderson property and to amend the Plan. The court declared, interalia, that Local Law No. 8 is in all respects valid and lawful and otherwise dismissed the petitionand complaint. This appeal ensued.
Turning to the merits, I first consider the issue whether the rezoning violated the Plan. Onthat question, I agree with the majority's statement of the controlling principles of law. "If thevalidity of the legislative classification for zoning purposes [is] fairly debatable, the legislativejudgment must be allowed to control . . . Thus, where the [challenging parties] fail[] to establish a clear conflict with the comprehensive plan, the zoning classification must beupheld" (Bergstol v Town ofMonroe, 15 AD3d 324, 325 [2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 701 [2005] [internalquotation marks omitted]; see Matter ofMeteor Enters., LLC, v Bylewski, 38 AD3d 1356, 1358 [2007]). I further note that thecore of this appeal requires a two-part analysis, i.e., whether there was a clear conflict betweenthe Plan and the rezoning and, if so, whether the Town Board properly amended the Plan toaccount for that inconsistency.
With respect to the first prong of that analysis, I conclude that petitioners established a "clearconflict" between the rezoning and the Plan (Bergstol, 15 AD3d at 325), and I begin withan examination of the nature of the Benderson property. The Plan characterizes the intended useof that property as recreation or "green" space. In sum and substance, at the heart of this case isthe effort of the Benderson respondents to make the drastic conversion of the Benderson propertyfrom green space to a large plaza. The Benderson respondents characterize the project as a"mixed[-]use development," but the true character of the project is retail-oriented inasmuch asthe plans call for the development of an extraordinary amount of retail space designed to attractan equally extraordinary amount of traffic to what is basically a "green" and residential area.Even the environmental attorney for Benderson Development Company, LLC acknowledged thatthe project is intended to house "higher[-]end stores" in what is an affluent and densely populatedarea. Put bluntly, the question before us is whether retail development on the Benderson propertyequivalent in scale to a Wal-Mart clearly conflicts with the Plan's intent to protect the "green"nature of that property and the residential fabric of the surrounding area, and I cannot agree withthe Town Board and the Benderson respondents that the [*5]question is even remotely debatable.
I further conclude that the rezoning is in clear conflict with the Plan inasmuch as the projectwill result in the encroachment of commercial development into "green" residential areas ofMaple Road. The figures included in the Plan demonstrate that commercial development withinthe Town has largely been clustered around major thoroughfares and interchanges that areremoved in distance from the project. The development of the project on the Benderson propertywould be an obvious departure from that strategy and pattern.
I also conclude that the placement of the project on Maple Road conflicts with the Plan'sintent for development on the periphery of the University. The "Concept Plan" for the MapleRoad area included within the Plan establishes why the part of that area designated for amixed-use center is on the east side of Millersport Highway. That location is accessible by aportion of the University's campus loop that is a divided highway with two lanes of travel in eachdirection and, more importantly, it is isolated from nearby residential areas by the golf course onthe south, Millersport Highway and the University campus on the west and a creek on the east. Amixed-use facility in that location would not interfere with residential areas and would beaccessible to University students. By contrast, the project proposed by the Benderson respondentsdoes exactly the opposite inasmuch as it interferes with residential areas and is reasonablyaccessible from the University only by vehicle.
Finally, with respect to the question of the conflict between the rezoning and the Plan, Iconclude that the logic underpinning the determination of the Town Board that the proposedrezoning was consistent with the Plan is specious. The majority explains that "[t]he Town Boardconcluded that the proposed rezoning was consistent with the Plan because of the. . . proximity [of the Benderson property] to the University, the fact that MapleRoad was a major arterial road and the unlikely use of the Benderson property for any otherdevelopment, based on its contamination and proximity to the sports arena and the University'sstadium." Although the Benderson property has some degree of proximity to the University, it issignificantly further from campus than the area designated for mixed-use development by thePlan. Contrary to the conclusion of the Town Board, the Plan does not designate Maple Road as amajor arterial, and the alleged impediment to development presented by the nearby sports arenaand stadium is simply not supported by the record. To reach the Benderson property from eitherof those venues, one would in all likelihood either travel in a circuitous route by vehicle ortraverse on foot a four-lane highway, part of the area designated for mixed-use development bythe Plan and a large part of the golf course. In any event, even assuming, arguendo, that thosevenues impede development of the Benderson property, I conclude that such an outcome is moreconsistent with the Plan's intent that the Benderson property constitute "green" space at theTown's full development.
In view of my determination that there is a "clear conflict" between the rezoning and the Plan(Bergstol, 15 AD3d at 325), it is necessary for me to address the question whether theTown Board properly amended the Plan to reconcile that conflict. Before reaching the merits ofthat question, however, I note one of the fundamental problems with this case. On June 2, 2008,and as noted above, the Town Board resolved to accept the Planning Board's recommendationthat the project and rezoning are consistent with the Plan and at the same time voted to amend thePlan to the extent that the rezoning is inconsistent with the Plan. That resolution is obviouslyinconsistent and, in layman's terms, the issue of the amendment of the Plan is not one that theTown Board can have "both ways." The Plan either did not require amendment for the rezoningto be lawful or it did require such amendment.[*6]
In any event, I conclude that the Town Board did notlawfully amend the Plan because the Town Board did not give proper notice of the proposedamendment and the Planning Board did not make a recommendation on the proposed amendmentbefore the Town Board resolved to amend the Plan. With respect to the issue of notice, TownLaw § 272-a (6) (a) provides that an amendment to a comprehensive town plan shall bepreceded by at least one public hearing "to assure full opportunity for citizen participation in thepreparation of such proposed . . . amendment." Notice of that hearing "shall bepublished in a newspaper of general circulation in the town at least [10] calendar days in advanceof the hearing," and the amendment shall be made available for public review during that period(§ 272-a [6] [c]).
Here, the record establishes that the Town Board resolved to amend the Plan at its June 2,2008 meeting, and there is no indication of any public notice given with respect to that meeting.Indeed, the notices that actually appear in the record are deficient both in terms of their timingand content. Those notices pertain only to the September 4, 2007 meeting that commenced withthe statement of the Town Supervisor that the Town Board would consider "the rezoning ofMaple Road" and concluded with the Town Supervisor's indication that the Town Board wouldawait the final draft environmental impact statement and another public hearing before acting onthe issue. Moreover, the content of those notices is deficient inasmuch as they made no referenceto an amendment to the Plan and, at some points, grossly understated the amount of retail spacethe project was expected to include.
Further, with respect to the input of the Planning Board on the proposed amendment to thePlan, I note that, according to the "Opportunity Review" part of the Plan's "Amendment Process,"amendment of the Plan by the Town Board may be accomplished after the required publichearing on the action but not before the Planning Board has made a recommendation on theproposed amendment. Here, although the Planning Board resolved on June 28, 2007 that theproject is consistent with the Plan, it did not adopt recommendations regarding the amendment tothe Plan until October 16, 2008, four months after the June 2, 2008 hearing. Even at that time,the Planning Board's recommendation was unclear inasmuch as the Planning Board simplyagreed to "[c]onsider [the] issue as part of the next annual review" and stated that "[n]o change tothe Plan is recommended."
I next address petitioners' contention that the driveways to the proposed development shouldhave been rezoned, and I reluctantly agree with the majority that petitioners are not entitled torelief with respect to that contention. The majority relies on Matter of Hampton Hill Villas Condominium Bd. of Mgrs. v Town ofAmherst Zoning Bd. of Appeals (13 AD3d 1079 [2004]) in rejecting petitioners'contention, but, in my view, that case is inapposite to the facts of this case. The determination ofthe respondent zoning board of appeals in Hampton Hill Villas Condominium Bd. of Mgrs.that the driveway at issue did not require rezoning appears to have been based on the desireof the town's building commissioner to avoid harm to an existing business that used thedriveway. The rezoning of the property around the driveway was intended to facilitate theconstruction of an office building that would be accessible by the driveway, and the rezoning ofthe driveway to the office building classification would have rendered the use thereof by theexisting business nonconforming (id.). There is no similar existing business to protecthere and, for that reason, Hampton Hill Villas Condominium Bd. of Mgrs. is irrelevant.Nevertheless, because they did not challenge the determination of the Building Commissionerwith respect to the driveways to the proposed development before the Zoning Board of Appeals,petitioners "failed to exhaust [their] administrative remedies with respect to [that] issue" (Matter of Peek v Dennison, 39 AD3d1239, 1240 [2007], appeal dismissed 9 NY3d 860 [2007]), and their contention thatthe driveways should have been rezoned is not properly before us.[*7]
For the foregoing reasons, I would reverse the judgment, grant the petition, annul thedetermination that, inter alia, approved the rezoning petition and amended the Plan, and declarethat Local Law No. 8 is invalid. Present—Smith, J.P., Centra, Fahey, Peradotto and Pine,JJ.