| Matter of Funke v Eastern Suffolk BOCES |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 00144 [80 AD3d 971] |
| January 13, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Sandra R. Funke, Appellant, v EasternSuffolk BOCES et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent. |
—[*1] Jones, Jones & O'Connell, L.L.P., New York City (Lauren Camo of counsel), for EasternSuffolk BOCES and another, respondents.
Mercure, J. Appeal from an amended decision of the Workers' Compensation Board, filedDecember 30, 2009, which ruled that claimant had involuntarily retired but that subsequent lostearnings were not causally related to claimant's work-related disability.
Claimant, a former teacher's assistant for special needs students, sustained a work-relatedinjury to her neck, back and shoulder when she was assaulted by a student in 2005. She wasawarded workers' compensation benefits and returned to work a month later. In 2007, the claimwas amended to include consequential post-traumatic stress disorder, and claimant wassubsequently awarded benefits for six days of intermittent lost time between February 2006 andJune 2008. She retired in March 2009, but continued to work sporadically for the employer as asubstitute teacher's assistant. The Workers' Compensation Board ultimately denied herapplication for postretirement benefits. Although the Board determined that claimant's retirementwas involuntary—that is, causally related to her disability—it further concluded thather subsequent loss of earnings was due to unrelated factors not caused by her disability.Claimant appeals, and we now reverse and remit.[*2]
Initially, we note that this Court has "long held that aretirement is an involuntary withdrawal if the claimant's disability caused or contributed to thedecision to retire" (Matter of Pittman vABM Indus., Inc., 24 AD3d 1056, 1057 [2005]; see Matter of Yamonaco v UnionCarbide Corp., 42 AD2d 1014, 1014 [1973]; see also Burns v Varriale, 9 NY3d 207, 216 [2007]). Here, theBoard credited claimant's testimony that she retired due to pain caused by her disability. Thattestimony provides substantial evidence to support the Board's initial finding that "claimant'sretirement was causally related as she was not able to continue working in the same capacity forthe employer"—i.e., that her retirement was involuntary (see Matter of Bryant v New York City Tr.Auth., 31 AD3d 936, 937-938 [2006]; Matter of Pittman v ABM Indus. Inc., 24AD3d at 1057).
Upon a finding of involuntary retirement, "an inference arises that . . . earningcapacity is reduced by the disability and claimant is [therefore] entitled to compensation until theinference is removed from the case" (Matter of Leeber v LILCO, 29 AD3d 1198, 1199 [2006]; accord Matter of Burns v Town ofColonie, 66 AD3d 1068, 1069 [2009]; cf. Matter of Peck v James Sq. Nursing Home, 34 AD3d 1033,1034 [2006]). Moreover, once "the withdrawal [is] found to be involuntary, . . . itbecome[s] inherently inconsistent to hold that a claimant is obligated to search for work withinmedical limitations" (Matter of Laing vMaryhaven Ctr. of Hope, 39 AD3d 1125, 1126 [2007], lv denied 9 NY3d 805[2007]; see Matter of Jiminez vWaldbaums, 9 AD3d 99, 100 [2004]). Thus, this Court has repeatedly "emphasize[d]that '[p]roof that the claimant has not sought work postretirement, by itself, does not defeat theinference or shift the burden to claimant to show that the disability was a cause of the reduction[in earnings]' " (Matter of Bryant v New York City Tr. Auth., 31 AD3d at 938, quotingMatter of Leeber v LILCO, 29 AD3d at 1199; see Matter of Tipping v National Surface Cleaning Mgt., Inc., 29 AD3d1200, 1200-1201 [2006]). Rather, "the workers' compensation carrier must demonstrate thatsomething other than the disability was the sole cause of claimant's reduced earning capacityafter retirement, such as age, economic conditions or other factors unrelated to the disability" (Matter of Pepe v City & Suburban, 29AD3d 1184, 1185 [2006] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter ofLa Pietra v County of Suffolk, 294 AD2d 794, 795 [2002]; Matter of Dudlo v PolythermPlastics, 125 AD2d 792, 793 [1986]).
Here, claimant testified that she had returned to work as a substitute teacher's aide on anintermittent basis after retiring, signing up for work only when she felt well enough to do so. TheBoard relied upon this testimony in determining that her postretirement loss of earnings was dueto unrelated factors not caused by her disability, evidently concluding that because claimantchose the days and classes that she would work, her reduction in earnings was unrelated to herdisability. As noted above, however, the failure to seek additional work does not defeat theinference that arises upon a finding of involuntary retirement or constitute proof that somethingother than the disability is the cause of a claimant's reduced earnings (see Matter of Burns vTown of Colonie, 66 AD3d at 1070; Matter of Pepe v City & Suburban, 29 AD3d at1185-1186; see also Matter of Meisner v United Parcel Serv., 243 AD2d 128, 131[1998], lv dismissed 93 NY2d 848 [1999], lv denied 94 NY2d 757 [1999]).Accordingly, in the absence of any "direct and positive proof that something other than thedisability was the sole cause of claimant's reduced earning capacity after retirement" (Matterof Pittman v ABM Indus., Inc., 24 AD3d at 1058), we conclude that the Board'sdetermination is not supported by substantial evidence.
Cardona, P.J., Malone Jr., Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the amended decision isreversed, with costs, and matter remitted to the Workers' Compensation Board for furtherproceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.