| Matter of Dennis D. (Justesen) |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 02874 [83 AD3d 700] |
| April 5, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Dennis D. Suffolk County Department of SocialServices, Appellant; Dennis D., Respondent. Elizabeth A. Justesen, Nonparty Appellant.(Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Molly D. Suffolk County Department of Social Services,Appellant; Dennis D., Respondent. Elizabeth A. Justesen, Nonparty Appellant. (Proceeding No.2.) In the Matter of Anna D. Suffolk County Department of Social Services, Appellant; DennisD., Respondent. Elizabeth A. Justesen, Nonparty Appellant. (Proceeding No.3.) |
—[*1] Robert C. Mitchell, Riverhead, N.Y. (Elizabeth A. Justesen pro se of counsel; Kari Heyisonon the brief), for nonparty appellant. Arza Feldman, Uniondale, N.Y., for respondent.
In three related child neglect proceedings pursuant to Family Court Act article 10, ElizabethA. Justesen, the Attorney for the Children, appeals, as limited by her brief, from stated portionsof an order of the Family Court, Suffolk County (Tarantino, Jr., J.), dated April 26, 2010, which,inter alia, after a hearing, denied that branch of her motion which was to prevent the paternalgrandparents from supervising the father's visitation with the subject children, granted the, ineffect, application of the father for supervised overnight visitation with the subject children, andfailed to require the father to obtain a mental health evaluation at the direction of the SuffolkCounty Department of Social Services as a condition of the extension of the father's supervisionby the Suffolk County Department of Social Services, and the Suffolk County Department ofSocial Services separately appeals from stated portions of the same order. By decision and orderon motion of this Court dated May 17, 2010, enforcement of so much of the order as permittedthe father to have supervised overnight visitation with the subject children was stayed pendingthe hearing and determination of the appeal.[*2]
Ordered that the order is modified, on the facts and in theexercise of discretion, (1) by deleting the provision thereof granting the, in effect, application ofthe father for supervised overnight visitation with the subject children, and substituting therefor aprovision denying that application, and (2) by adding a provision thereto requiring the father toobtain a mental health evaluation at the direction of the Suffolk County Department of SocialServices as a condition of the extension of the father's supervision by the Suffolk CountyDepartment of Social Services; as so modified, the order is affirmed insofar as appealed from,without costs or disbursements.
In an order of fact-finding and disposition dated October 31, 2007, made upon the father'sadmission, the Family Court determined that the father had neglected the subject children byengaging in acts of domestic violence. The Family Court placed the father under the supervisionof the Suffolk County Department of Social Services (hereinafter the DSS) for a period of oneyear upon the conditions, inter alia, that, at the DSS's direction, he obtain a mental healthevaluation and participate in a sex offender treatment program. The Family Court also directedthe father to have no contact with the children, who were in the mother's custody.
In September 2008 the DSS commenced a proceeding to extend the period of supervision ofthe father, alleging that he had not yet obtained a mental health evaluation or participated in a sexoffender treatment program. In an order dated October 10, 2008, the Family Court extended theperiod of supervision of the father for an additional year, upon the conditions, inter alia, that, atthe DSS's direction, he obtain a mental health evaluation and participate in a sex offendertreatment program. Additionally, the Family Court allowed the father to have therapeuticvisitation with the children. In a separate order of protection issued on the same date, the FamilyCourt directed the father to stay away from the children "except for visitation supervised byDSS/approved person(s)." According to the Attorney for the Children, in April 2009 the FamilyCourt approved the paternal grandparents (hereinafter the grandparents) to supervise visitsbetween the father and the children, and scheduled supervised visits on Sundays between 9:00a.m. and 5:00 or 6:00 p.m. In September 2009 the DSS commenced another proceeding to extendthe period of supervision of the father, alleging that the father still had not complied with theFamily Court's mandate to obtain a mental health evaluation at the DSS's direction. Separately,the Attorney for the Children moved, inter alia, to prevent the grandparents from supervising thefather's visitation with the children, alleging that the grandparents were not providing propersupervision during the visits. At the ensuing hearing, at which the father, the mother, and thegrandparents testified, the father, in effect, made an application for supervised overnightvisitation with the children.
In the order appealed from, the Family Court, inter alia, granted the, in effect, application ofthe father for supervised overnight visitation, denied that branch of the motion of the Attorneyfor the Children which was to prevent the grandparents from supervising the father's visitation,and extended the period of supervision of the father without requiring him to obtain a mentalhealth evaluation at the direction of the DSS as a condition of his supervision.
The Family Court did not improvidently exercise its discretion in denying that branch of themotion of the Attorney for the Children which was to prevent the grandparents from supervisingthe father's visitation with the children. The determination of visitation to a noncustodial parent iswithin the sound discretion of the hearing court, based upon the best interests of the children, andit should not be set aside unless it lacks a sound and substantial basis in the record (see Matter of Khan v Dolly, 39 AD3d649, 651 [2007]; Matter of Thomasv Thomas, 35 AD3d 868, 869 [2006]). Here, the Family Court's determination thatcontinuing to allow the grandparents to supervise the visits between the father and the childrenwas in the best interests of the children has a sound and substantial basis in the record, as thehearing evidence established that the grandparents were appropriately and responsiblysupervising those visits (see Matter ofTaylor v Fry, 47 AD3d 1130, 1132 [2008]; cf. Matter of Wormuth v Mathis, 58AD3d 923, 924 [2009]; Matter of Anayav Hundley, 12 AD3d 594, 595-596 [2004]).
However, the Family Court should have required the father to obtain a mental healthevaluation at the direction of the DSS as a condition of his supervision when it extended theperiod of the father's supervision by the DSS. The Family Court itself previously appreciated theneed for such an evaluation, as it set forth this requirement as a condition of the father'ssupervision by the DSS [*3]in both the October 2007 order ofdisposition and the October 2008 order extending the supervision period (see Matter ofNeuman v Neuman, 243 AD2d 481, 481-482 [1997]), and it did not provide any rationale forsubsequently omitting this requirement as a condition of supervision (see generallyFamily Ct Act § 1057). Accordingly, we modify the order appealed from so as to requirethe father to obtain a mental health evaluation at the direction of the DSS as a condition of hissupervision.
Finally, in light of the father's failure to comply with the condition of his supervisionrequiring him to obtain a mental health evaluation at the direction of the DSS, a court-orderedcondition which, at the time of the hearing, had been in effect since 2007, the Family Courtimprovidently exercised its discretion in granting the, in effect, application of the father forsupervised overnight visitation with the children. The record does not support a finding that, inthe absence of the completion of this mental health evaluation, awarding the father supervisedovernight visitation was in the children's best interests (cf. Matter of Lamarche v Jessie, 74 AD3d 1341, 1342 [2010]; Matter of Jave v Danial, 70 AD3d696 [2010]; Matter of SaharaK., 66 AD3d 1024, 1025 [2009]).
In light of our determination, we need not reach the remaining contentions of the Attorneyfor the Children. Covello, J.P., Hall, Lott and Cohen, JJ., concur.