Bishop v Maurer
2011 NY Slip Op 02932 [83 AD3d 483]
April 12, 2011
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 8, 2011


Lisa Bishop et al., Appellants-Respondents,
v
RonaMaurer, Respondent-Appellant.

—[*1]Lawrence H. Silverman, Commack, for appellants-respondents.

Richard L. Herzfeld, P.C., New York (Richard L. Herzfeld of counsel), forrespondent-appellant.

Order, Surrogate's Court, New York County (Troy K. Webber, S.), entered November 23,2009, which, to the extent appealed from as limited by the briefs, granted plaintiffs' motion forleave to amend their complaint insofar as it sought to include an allegation of forgery in theirexisting claim for undue influence, and denied the motion insofar as it sought to add a cause ofaction for fraud, without prejudice to bringing such a motion before the Supreme Court, NewYork County, unanimously modified, on the law, to deny leave to add a cause of action for fraud,and otherwise affirmed, without costs.

Contrary to defendant's claim, decedent did not previously acknowledge that he signed theretainer agreement on which defendant allegedly forged his signature. On the contrary, he allegedthat defendant retained the lawyers who prepared the documents that he sought to setaside (a trust agreement and an agreement relating to his individual retirement account [IRA] andemployee stock ownership plan [ESOP]). The reference in decedent's brief on a prior appeal to aconflict waiver did not unambiguously mean the conflict waiver in the retainer agreement, asthere was also a conflict waiver in the IRA/ESOP agreement.

The question of whether decedent signed the retainer letter was not at issue on the priorappeal (33 AD3d 497 [2006], affd 9 NY3d 910 [2007]). Accordingly, law of the casedoes not apply here (see generally People v Evans, 94 NY2d 499, 502 [2000]). The Courtof Appeals' reference to "the estate planning documents decedent signed" (9 NY3d at 911) musthave meant the trust agreement and the IRA/ESOP agreement, since a retainer letter is not anestate planning document.

Defendant contends that plaintiffs' motion for leave to amend the complaint was untimely.However, "[m]ere lateness is not a barrier to the amendment. It must be lateness coupled withsignificant prejudice to the other side" (Edenwald Contr. Co. v City of New York, 60NY2d 957, 959 [1983] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]). In opposition toplaintiffs' motion, defendant did not show how she would be prejudiced. We decline to considerarguments that she advanced for the first time in her motion for renewal and reargument, as wepreviously denied her request to enlarge the appellate record to include the papers from thatmotion (see Bishop v Maurer, 2010 NY Slip Op 87017[U] [2010]).

The fraud claim that plaintiffs sought to add was based on entirely different facts from the[*2]fraud claim that Supreme Court had previously dismissed.Therefore, plaintiffs were neither seeking to vacate or modify Supreme Court's decision(cf. CPLR 5015 [a] [5]), nor to renew or reargue it (cf. CPLR 2221).Accordingly, Surrogate's Court should have decided the motion instead of referring it to SupremeCourt. On the merits, the motion should have been denied. "A motion for leave to amend thecomplaint pursuant to CPLR 3025 (b) should be freely granted unless the proposed amendment ispalpably insufficient to state a cause of action or is patently devoid of merit" (Smith-Hoy v AMC Prop. Evaluations,Inc., 52 AD3d 809, 811 [2008] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]). Here,the proposed fraud claim is clearly insufficient because there is no allegation of anymisrepresentation or reliance on the part of decedent (see e.g. Sehera Food Servs. Inc. v Empire State Bldg. Co. L.L.C., 74AD3d 542 [2010]).

We have considered the parties' remaining arguments for affirmative relief and find themunavailing. Concur—Mazzarelli, J.P., Acosta, DeGrasse, Richter and Manzanet-Daniels,JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.