| Matter of Smelyansky v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town ofBethlehem |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 02996 [83 AD3d 1267] |
| April 14, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Sonya Smelyansky et al.,Appellants, v Zoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Bethlehem,Respondent. |
—[*1] Young Sommer, L.L.C., Albany (Michael J. Moore of counsel), for respondent.
McCarthy, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (O'Connor, J.), entered January12, 2010 in Albany County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78, to, among other things, review a determination of respondent denyingpetitioners' request for an area variance.
In 2008, petitioners purchased a parcel of property in the Town of Bethlehem, AlbanyCounty. The property contained a house that was built in 1986 and given a certificate ofoccupancy as a duplex, but was utilized as a three-family dwelling for many years. The priorowners removed part of a wall between two of the units, so the house was a duplex whenpetitioners purchased it. Petitioners applied for a building permit to convert the duplex into athree-family dwelling, but the building inspector denied the application because the lot was only14,520 square feet and the zoning ordinance requires a lot size of 18,500 square feet for athree-family dwelling (see Town of Bethlehem Zoning Law § 128-100). Petitionersappealed the building inspector's finding that they needed a variance and simultaneouslyrequested an area variance. Respondent denied both applications. Petitioners commenced thisproceeding challenging respondent's determinations. Supreme Court dismissed the petition,prompting petitioners' appeal.
Respondent correctly confirmed the building inspector's decision that petitioners were [*2]required to apply for an area variance. The Town's zoningordinance provides that a "nonconforming lot may be built upon for any purpose permitted in thezoning district in which it is located, without a variance," as long as the "nonconformity resultssolely from the adoption" of the most recent version of the zoning ordinances (Town ofBethlehem Zoning Law § 128-55 [B] [1]). Two- and three-family dwellings are among thepermitted uses in the zoning district where petitioners' property lies. The problem withpetitioners' argument is that the lot conformed to the zoning ordinances. It was always consideredby the Town as a two-family dwelling, was a duplex at the time petitioners submitted theirapplication for a building permit, and complied with the requirements for such a building. Theproperty only would have become nonconforming once the building was converted to athree-family dwelling. Additionally, although the building may have been used—inviolation of the certificate of occupancy issued by the Town—as a three-family dwelling atthe time the most recent zoning ordinances were adopted in 2005,[FN*]the nonconformity resulted from the illegal use of the property by petitioners' predecessors, not"solely from the adoption" of the zoning ordinances (Town of Bethlehem Zoning Law§ 128-55 [B] [1] [emphasis added]). Thus, giving deference to respondent's interpretationof the Town's ordinances (see Matter ofRivendell Winery, LLC v Donovan, 74 AD3d 1594, 1595 [2010]; Matter of Kantor v Olsen, 9 AD3d814, 815 [2004]), respondent rationally determined that petitioners were required to applyfor an area variance.
We also affirm respondent's decision to deny petitioners' request for an area variance.Reviewing courts must refrain from substituting their own judgment for the reasoned judgmentof a zoning board, even if the court would have decided the matter differently in the first instance(see Matter of Pecoraro v Board ofAppeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 608, 613 [2004]; Matter of Cowan vKern, 41 NY2d 591, 599 [1977]). Local zoning boards have broad discretion whenconsidering applications for area variances and courts will uphold a zoning board's determinationunless its actions were illegal, arbitrary or an abuse of discretion (see Matter of Pecoraro vBoard of Appeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d at 613; Matter of Matejko v Board of ZoningAppeals of Town of Brookhaven, 77 AD3d 949, 950 [2010]); the key is rationality(see Matter of Sasso v Osgood, 86 NY2d 374, 384 n 2 [1995]; Matter of Center Sq. Assn., Inc. v City ofAlbany Bd. of Zoning Appeals, 19 AD3d 968, 970 [2005]).
By statute, when considering the application for an area variance, respondent was required toweigh the benefit to petitioners if the variance were granted against the detriment to thecommunity from a grant of the variance (see Town Law § 267-b [3] [b]).Respondent was required to consider the following factors: "whether (1) granting the areavariance will produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or a detrimentto nearby properties; (2) the benefit sought by the applicant can be achieved by some method,feasible to the applicant, other than a variance; (3) the requested area variance is substantial; (4)granting the proposed variance would have an adverse effect or impact on physical orenvironmental conditions in the neighborhood or district; and (5) the alleged difficulty isself-created. While the last factor is not dispositive, it is also not irrelevant" (Matter ofPecoraro v Board of Appeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d at 613 [citation omitted];see Town Law § 267-b [3] [b]).
Respondent considered those factors when weighing the benefits versus the detriments [*3]associated with granting the variance. Petitioners submittedevidence that the neighborhood was comprised of mostly two-family residences and a majority ofthe residents are renters. Respondent held that the neighborhood contained one- and two-familyresidences and a three-family dwelling would change the character of the neighborhood. A seniorcitizen complex, apartment complex and shopping plazas are in the district, but respondentmainly compared the property at issue with other parcels on the same street—apparentlyall built as part of a residential subdivision—when evaluating the character of theneighborhood.
Petitioners averred that they could not purchase additional property from neighbors to obtainenough square feet to convert to a three-family house without a variance. Although there is nofeasible method for petitioners to make the conversion without a variance, respondent noted thatpetitioners already have a two-family dwelling and can receive a benefit from this investmentproperty by renting out at least one, if not both, of the two units in the duplex (see Matter ofBivona v Town of Plattekill Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 268 AD2d 877, 880 [2000]). Therequested variance would require an exception of nearly 4,000 square feet, or approximately 21%of the total area. It was not arbitrary or irrational for respondent to find this substantial (seeMatter of Four M Constr. Corp. v Fritts, 151 AD2d 938, 940 [1989]). There was no evidencethat the conversion would have an impact on physical or environmental conditions. Finally, thedifficulty was self-created because petitioners purchased the property as a duplex and they wereaware of the zoning requirements for a three-family dwelling at the time (see Matter ofBivona v Town of Plattekill Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 268 AD2d at 880-881; see also Matter of Inlet Homes Corp. vZoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 769, 770 [2004]). Asrespondent considered all of the factors, weighed them and reached a decision that was notarbitrary, irrational or an abuse of discretion, we will not disturb that determination.
Mercure, J.P., Rose and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed, withoutcosts.
Footnote *: The record is unclear as toexactly when petitioners' predecessors converted the dwelling into a duplex.