CNP Mech., Inc. v Allied Bldrs., Inc.
2011 NY Slip Op 03780 [84 AD3d 1748]
May 6, 2011
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 6, 2011


CNP Mechanical, Inc., Respondent,
v
Allied Builders, Inc.,et al., Appellants. (Appeal No. 2.)

—[*1]Ernstrom & Dreste, LLP, Rochester (John W. Dreste of counsel), fordefendants-appellants.

Gates & Adams, P.C., Rochester (Anthony J. Adams, Jr., of counsel), forplaintiff-respondent.

Appeals from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Monroe County (Kenneth R. Fisher, J.),entered August 25, 2010 in a breach of contract action. The judgment, upon a nonjury trial,awarded plaintiff the principal sum of $347,682.14 plus interest and costs against defendants.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously modified on the lawby reducing the award of damages for those items identified as construction change directive(CCD) No. 1 to $4,800, CCD No. 2 to $86,000, CCD No. 3 to $43,305 and CCD No. 4 to$55,758, providing that statutory interest on the reduced awards shall run from September 7,2007 for CCD Nos.1, 2, and 4, and from November 16, 2007 for CCD No. 3, and as modified thejudgment is affirmed without costs in accordance with the following memorandum: Plaintiff, aplumbing subcontractor on the construction of a Walmart store, commenced this action seekingto recover the balance due on its subcontract with defendant Allied Builders, Inc. (Allied), thegeneral contractor, as well as the value of extra work it allegedly performed on the project.Following a nonjury trial, Supreme Court awarded plaintiff damages in the principal amount of$347,682.14, with statutory interest from February 20, 2007, the date on which the action wascommenced.

We agree with defendants that, pursuant to the terms of the subcontract, which incorporatesthe terms of the contract between Allied and Walmart, the liability of Allied with respect to theextra work initiated by Walmart through a CCD is limited to the sum approved by Walmart(see generally Sturdy Concrete Corp. v NAB Constr. Corp., 65 AD2d 262, 268-269[1978], appeal dismissed 46 NY2d 938, 940 [1979]; Joseph Davis, Inc. vMerritt-Chapman & Scott Corp., 27 AD2d 114, 117-118 [1967]). The evidence presented attrial establishes that, with respect to plaintiff's work, Walmart approved $4,800 for CCD No. 1,$86,000 for CCD No. 2, $43,305 for CCD No. 3 and $55,758 for CCD No. 4. We thereforemodify the judgment by reducing the award of damages for those items accordingly. We alsoagree with defendants that the court erred in directing that statutory interest on those items runfrom the date on which the action was commenced. The subcontract contains a valid "pay whenpaid clause," [*2]which required Allied to pay plaintiff for itsCCD work "no later than 15 calendar days after receipt by [Allied] of corresponding paymentfrom [Walmart] for the Work" (see generally Otis El. Co. v Hunt Constr. Group, Inc.[appeal No. 2], 52 AD3d 1315, 1316 [2008]). We therefore modify the judgment by providingthat statutory interest on the sums awarded for the CCDs shall run from the dates on which thepayment for each CCD was due, rather than from the date of the commencement of the action.

With respect to the remaining categories of extra work, we agree with plaintiff that Alliedwaived compliance with the requirement of the subcontract for a written change orderauthorizing such extra work (see Care Sys. v Laramee, 155 AD2d 770, 771 [1989];Mel-Stu Constr. Corp. v Melwood Constr. Corp., 131 AD2d 823, 824 [1987]). Thatrequirement is "not applicable where, as here, the conduct of the parties demonstrates anindisputable mutual departure from the written agreement and the changes were clearly requestedby [Allied] and executed by [plaintiff]" (Austin v Barber, 227 AD2d 826, 828 [1996];see Barsotti's, Inc. v Consolidated Edison Co. of N.Y., 254 AD2d 211, 212 [1998]). Inaddition, contrary to defendants' contentions, we conclude that plaintiff established that each ofthe alleged categories of extra work was outside the scope of the work contemplated by thesubcontract, and that plaintiff presented sufficient evidence establishing the value of its extrawork. Trial testimony provided by a witness with knowledge of the actual value of such extrawork is sufficient and documentary evidence with respect thereto is not required (seeElectronic Servs. Intl. v Silvers, 284 AD2d 367, 368 [2001], lv dismissed 97NY2d 700 [2002], lv denied 99 NY2d 508 [2003]; Reed Paving v Glen Ave.Bldrs., 148 AD2d 934, 935 [1989]). Here, the testimony of plaintiff's president and its expertwas sufficient to establish that plaintiff was entitled to recover in quantum meruit for thecategories of extra work that were not encompassed by the CCDs. That testimony established thenecessary elements for recovery in quantum meruit, i.e., plaintiff's performance of the extra workin good faith, acceptance of that work by Allied, plaintiff's expectation to be compensated for itand the reasonable value of the work (see Tesser v Allboro Equip. Co., 73 AD3d 1023, 1026 [2010]; Capital Heat, Inc. v Buchheit, 46 AD3d1419, 1420-1421 [2007]).

Finally, we conclude that the court properly dismissed defendants' two counterclaims. Withrespect to the first counterclaim, defendants failed to present sufficient evidence establishing thatplaintiff breached the subcontract or that plaintiff owes back charges to Allied for work that wasnot performed or that was improperly performed (see generally Mel-Stu Constr. Corp.,131 AD2d at 825; Sturdy Concrete Corp., 65 AD2d at 273). Defendants also failed tomeet their burden of establishing, in support of their second counterclaim, that the amounts setforth by plaintiff in its mechanic's lien were willfully exaggerated (see Garrison v All Phase StructureCorp., 33 AD3d 661, 662 [2006]; George A. Fuller Co. v Kensington-JohnsonCorp., 234 AD2d 265, 267 [1996]). Present—Scudder, P.J., Fahey, Carni, Green andGorski, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.