Matter of Vector Foiltec, LLC v State Univ. Constr. Fund
2011 NY Slip Op 03955 [84 AD3d 1576]
May 12, 2011
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 6, 2011


In the Matter of Vector Foiltec, LLC, et al.,Appellants,
v
State University Construction Fund et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Couch White, L.L.P., Albany (James J. Barriere of counsel), for appellants.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Paul Groenwegen of counsel), for StateUniversity Construction Fund and another, respondents. McNamee, Lochner, Titus & Williams,P.C., Albany (Kevin Laurilliard of counsel), for Sano-Rubin Company, Inc.,respondent.

Lahtinen, J. (1) Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (McDonough, J.), enteredSeptember 28, 2010 in Albany County, which, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78,granted respondents' motions to dismiss the petition, and (2) motion to dismiss appeal.

Respondent State University Construction Fund solicited bids for a project that includedconstructing extensive skylights using a technology known as ETFE (ethylenetetrafluoroethylene). The Fund's specifications required that the contractor have the ETFEinstalled by one of three approved companies, including petitioner Vector Foiltec, LLC.Respondent Sano-Rubin Company, Inc. was the successful bidder and its ETFE subcontractor,Novum Structures, LLC, was an approved provider of ETFE. Although Vector Foiltec did notbid on the project, it desired to be the ETFE subcontractor. Thus, when Novum was selected bySano-Rubin as its subcontractor, Vector Foiltec, together with residenttaxpayers—petitioners Herbert S. Ellis (a member of Vector Foiltec) and Alexander Jafari(a director of Vector Foiltec)—protested the Sano-Rubin bid by asserting to the Fund andrespondent Comptroller that Novum [*2]did not satisfy the Fund'sETFE specifications. The Comptroller determined that petitioners lacked standing and dismissedthe protest. This proceeding ensued and respondents made motions to dismiss asserting, amongother things, that petitioners did not have standing. Supreme Court granted the motions uponsuch ground. Petitioners appeal contending that they have standing under State Finance Law§ 123-b and also that they have common-law taxpayer standing.

Prefatorily, we address Sano-Rubin's motion, made shortly before oral argument, to dismissthe appeal as moot because installation of the ETFE skylights was scheduled to commence inMarch 2011. Petitioners promptly commenced this proceeding, they sought injunctive relief, theyexpeditiously perfected their appeal, and Sano-Rubin's submissions in support of its motionfailed to establish that the project is substantially completed. Hence, the appeal is not moot andSano-Rubin's motion is denied (see e.g.Matter of Schupak v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Marbletown, 31 AD3d 1018,1019 [2006], lv dismissed and denied 8 NY3d 842 [2007]; Matter of Defreestville Area NeighborhoodAssn., Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 16 AD3d 715, 717-718 [2005]).

Turning to the issues on appeal, we are unpersuaded that petitioners have establishedstanding under State Finance Law § 123-b. A citizen-taxpayer may bring a lawsuit underthis statute to "prevent the unlawful expenditure of state funds 'whether or not such person is ormay be affected or specially aggrieved' by the challenged action" (Saratoga County Chamberof Commerce v Pataki, 100 NY2d 801, 813 [2003], cert denied 540 US 1017 [2003],quoting State Finance Law § 123-b [1]; see Matter of Transactive Corp. v New YorkState Dept. of Social Servs., 92 NY2d 579, 588-589 [1998]). However, "[t]he statute isnarrowly construed . . . and claims seek[ing] review of a [s]tate actor's allegedmismanagement of funds or the arbitrary and capricious distribution of funds lawfully allocatedto an agency are not covered by section 123-b" (Matter of Humane Socy. of U.S. v Empire State Dev. Corp., 53 AD3d1013, 1016 [2008], lv denied 12 NY3d 701 [2009] [internal quotation marks andcitations omitted]).

Here, the money for the project had been lawfully allocated to the Fund, the Fund wasauthorized to spend state money on the project, and it had authority to seek and analyze bids forthe project. Petitioners assert that the Fund violated the competitive bidding procedures inawarding the contract to Sano-Rubin with Novum as the ETFE subcontractor because allegedlyNovum failed to meet the experience and independent testing specifications for the project. Inessence, petitioners are challenging the review and award method used by the Fund regarding thecontract, which goes to issues of alleged mismanagement or arbitrariness; issues that are notsufficient to establish statutory citizen-taxpayer standing. We agree with Supreme Court thatpetitioners failed to show that they have standing under State Finance Law § 123-b (seeMatter of Transactive Corp. v New York State Dept. of Social Servs., 92 NY2d at 589; Matter of Quigley v Town of Ulster, 66AD3d 1295, 1297 [2009]; Matter of Humane Socy. of United States v Empire State Dev.Corp., 53 AD3d at 1016).

Next, we consider common-law taxpayer standing. This doctrine was developed as "a remedyfor taxpayers to challenge important governmental actions, despite such parties being otherwiseinsufficiently interested for standing purposes, when 'the failure to accord such standing would bein effect to erect an impenetrable barrier to any judicial scrutiny of legislative action' "(Matter of Colella v Board of Assessors of County of Nassau, 95 NY2d 401, 410 [2000],quoting Boryszewski v Brydges, 37 NY2d 361, 364 [1975]; see Matter of TransactiveCorp. v New York State Dept. of Social Servs., 92 NY2d at 589; Matter of Diederich vSt. Lawrence, 78 [*3]AD3d 1290, 1292 [2010]). Petitionersdid not participate in the bidding process. They merely hoped to be selected as the subcontractorfor the winning bidder. A losing bidder could bring an action and, thus, there is no impenetrablebarrier to judicial review (see Matter of Transactive Corp. v New York State Dept. of SocialServs., 92 NY2d at 589; Matter ofMadison Sq. Garden, L.P. v New York Metro. Transp. Auth., 19 AD3d 284, 286 [2005],appeal dismissed 5 NY3d 878 [2005]; see also Saratoga County Chamber ofCommerce v Pataki, 100 NY2d at 814-815). We need not address the further elements forcommon-law taxpayer standing of public significance beyond the immediately affected partiesand whether the challenged action is legislative in nature.

Mercure, J.P., Malone Jr., Kavanagh and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the motion todismiss the appeal is denied, without costs. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.