| Matter of Anne FF. v New York State Off. of Children & FamilyServs. |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 04587 [85 AD3d 1289] |
| June 2, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Anne FF., Petitioner, v New York State Office ofChildren and Family Services et al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Robert M. Goldfarb of counsel), forrespondents.
Peters, J.P. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondent Office ofChildren and Family Services which denied petitioner's application to have a report maintainedby respondent Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment amended to be unfounded andexpunged.
Petitioner was employed part time at a day-care center in the City of Albany. As a member ofits relief staff, petitioner would be assigned to various classrooms on any given day based uponneed. On October 9, 2008, petitioner was assigned to the "red room" where she was supervisingfour three-year-old children. As was typical, the students in petitioner's class joined with those inthe "green room" to play outside on the fenced-in playground. Pursuant to the day-care centerrules, petitioner conducted a head count, which was documented on a transition sheet, both whenher group left the classroom and upon arriving at the playground. After playing for approximately10 minutes, one of the children had a bathroom-related emergency and, since protocol requiredtwo employees to be present at the playground at all times, petitioner and the green room teacherquickly gathered the children to go inside. Petitioner did not conduct a head count of her studentsupon leaving the playground, inadvertently leaving one of the children [*2]behind. Upon entering the facility, one of petitioner's studentsbecame upset upon seeing his mother at a distance and began running towards her, causingpetitioner to chase after the child and bring him to his mother in an effort to calm him down.Petitioner then immediately returned to the classroom, conducted a head count and realized thatone child had been left on the playground. Petitioner rushed to the playground and found thechild unharmed in the care of another employee.
After petitioner reported the incident to her supervisors and the child's parents, the day-carecenter reported the incident to Albany County Child Protective Services. Following aninvestigation, a report was "indicated" for maltreatment and filed with respondent CentralRegister of Child Abuse and Maltreatment. Upon petitioner's request that the report be amendedto unfounded, respondent Office of Children and Family Services determined that the report wassupported by a fair preponderance of the evidence and scheduled an administrative hearingpursuant to Social Services Law § 422 (8). Following that hearing, an Administrative LawJudge sustained the finding of maltreatment and denied petitioner's request to amend the report.Petitioner then commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding.
In order to establish that maltreatment occurred, it was necessary for the agency todemonstrate by a fair preponderance of the evidence that "the child's physical, mental oremotional condition has been impaired or is in imminent danger of becoming impaired as a resultof the [caregiver's] failure to exercise a minimum degree of care" (Matter of Tonette E. v New York State Off.of Children & Family Servs., 25 AD3d 994, 995 [2006]; see 18 NYCRR 432.1[b] [1]; Matter of Stephen C. vJohnson, 39 AD3d 932, 933 [2007], lv denied 9 NY3d 804 [2007]). While,under certain circumstances, leaving a child unattended will give rise to a finding ofmaltreatment (see e.g. Matter of SusanXX. v Tioga County Dept. of Social Servs., 74 AD3d 1543, 1544-1545 [2010];Matter of Stephen C. v Johnson, 39 AD3d at 933-934; Matter of Brown vJohnson, 294 AD2d 241 [2002], lv denied 99 NY2d 509 [2003]), we find insufficientevidence on the present record to support a finding of maltreatment against petitioner.
While petitioner admittedly got caught up in the frenzy of rushing the students back into thefacility and the emotional outburst of one of her charges and, in so doing, failed to ensure thateach child was present and accounted for, there is no dispute that she immediately recognized heroversight upon arriving back to the classroom. The record reveals that the child was leftunattended by petitioner for no more than six minutes, at which point petitioner discovered thechild physically, mentally and emotionally unharmed in the care of a day-care employee.Notably, there is no evidence that the child was actually unobserved for any portion of thatsix-minute period during which petitioner was attending to the other children in her care.Moreover, "the physical setting of the alleged wrongdoing supports petitioner's claims that [her]actions did not place [the child] in imminent danger" (Matter of Matthew WW. v Johnson, 20 AD3d 669, 671 [2005]).The playground at issue is located at the rear of the building, is not visible from any publicthoroughfare, is surrounded on all sides by a chain link fence and is accessible by twogates—both of which lead to the facility—that remain locked at all times.Furthermore, the playground is visible to other trained employees and is subjected to videosurveillance. Under the particular facts of this case, we conclude that insufficient evidence existsto support the finding that petitioner's conduct fell below a minimum degree of care and placedthe child in imminent danger of harm (see id.; Matter of Steven A. v New York StateOff. of Children & Family Servs., 307 AD2d 434, 435 [2003]).[*3]
Spain, McCarthy, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur.Adjudged that the determination is annulled, without costs, and petition granted.