| Penn v Amchem Prods. |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 04821 [85 AD3d 475] |
| June 9, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Josephine Penn et al., Appellants, v Amchem Products etal., Defendants, and Kerr Corporation, Respondent. |
—[*1] Marin Goodman LLP, New York (Diane H. Miller of counsel), and Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP, New York (E. Leo Milonas of counsel), forrespondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Marylin G. Diamond, J.), entered June 1, 2009,which granted defendant-respondent Kerr Corporation's posttrial motion insofar as it sought toset aside the verdict and have judgment entered in its favor as a matter of law, and sub silentiodenied the motion as academic, insofar as it alternatively sought a remittitur, unanimouslyreversed, on the law, without costs, the jury's verdict on liability reinstated as against Kerr, andthe matter remanded for a new trial solely on the issue of damages for past and future pain andsuffering and loss of consortium, unless plaintiffs, within 30 days of service of a copy of thisorder with notice of entry, stipulate to reduce the award for past pain and suffering from$3,650,000 to $1,500,000, future pain and suffering from $10,900,000 to $2,000,000, and theaward for loss of consortium from $1,670,000 to $260,000, and to entry of a judgment inaccordance therewith.
Contrary to the trial court's finding, the evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to theprevailing plaintiffs (see Matter of New York City Asbestos Litig., 256 AD2d 250, 250[1998], lv denied 93 NY2d 818 [1999], cert denied sub nom. Worthington Corp. vRonsini, 529 US 1019 [2000]), was sufficient to permit the jury to rationally conclude thatthe asbestos-containing dental liners to which the injured plaintiff (Penn) was exposed weredistributed by Kerr. Such conclusion could be drawn from the evidence that Penn's dentaltechnician school gave him boxes containing dental liners used to make prosthetic teeth that hadKerr's name on them; that Penn followed a chart specifically made for Kerr's casting ring productwhen given a box with Kerr's name on it; that Kerr supplied asbestos-containing dental liners todental technician schools at the time Penn was a student; and that Kerr often packaged its castingring product with its dental liners. That Penn's description of the dental liners he used differedfrom the descriptions given by Kerr's representatives does not conclusively establish that Penndid not use Kerr's liners, and simply raised a credibility issue for the jury.
On the issue of causation, sufficient evidence was provided by Penn's testimony that [*2]visible dust emanated while working with the dental liners and byhis expert's testimony that such dust must have contained enough asbestos to cause hismesothelioma (see Matter of New YorkAsbestos Litig., 28 AD3d 255, 256 [2006]). On the issue of duty to warn, evidence thatKerr did not test or investigate the safety of its asbestos liners permitted the jury to conclude thatKerr failed to adequately warn Penn of a potential danger that it knew or should have knownabout (see George v Celotex Corp., 914 F2d 26, 28 [1990]).
Kerr's argument that the verdict is inconsistent in holding it but not Celotex and Nicoletliable is unpreserved, since it was not raised until after the jury was discharged, and we decline toconsider it (see Barry v Manglass, 55 NY2d 803, 806 [1981]; Gavitt v Citnalta Constr. Corp., 33AD3d 406, 407 [2006]). We do note, however, that the jury need not have credited Kerr'srepresentative's testimony that Celotex and Nicolet supplied Kerr with prepackaged asbestosliners and rolls. Kerr's argument that plaintiffs' counsel's remarks on summation were improper isalso unpreserved, since Kerr failed to object during summation, ask for curative instructions, orseek a mistrial with regard to them, and we decline to consider it (see Wilson v City of New York, 65AD3d 906, 908 [2009]). Were we to consider it, we would find that while some remarkswere improper, they were not so egregious as to warrant a new trial (id. at 909).
The damage awards deviate from what would be reasonable compensation to the extentindicated (CPLR 5501 [c]). Concur—Saxe, J.P., Friedman, Moskowitz and Abdus-Salaam,JJ.
The decision and order of this Court entered herein on May 11, 2010 (73 AD3d 493 [2010])is hereby recalled and vacated (see 2011 NY Slip Op 75116[U] [2011] [decidedsimultaneously herewith]).