Fiallos v New York Univ. Hosp.
2011 NY Slip Op 05623 [85 AD3d 678]
June 30, 2011
Appellate Division, First Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 10, 2011


Alexandra Fiallos, Individually and as Mother and NaturalGuardian of Luciana Vera Fiallos, an Infant, Appellant,
v
New York UniversityHospital, Respondent.

—[*1]Pollack, Pollack, Isaac & DeCicco, New York (Brian J. Isaac of counsel), for appellant.

Martin Clearwater & Bell LLP, New York (Barbara D. Goldberg of counsel), forrespondent.

Order, Supreme Court, Bronx County (Alison Y. Tuitt, J.), entered on or about February 8,2010, which granted defendant's motion for a change of venue, reversed, on the law and the facts,without costs, and the motion denied.

In making its motion, defendant assumed the burden of disproving plaintiff's Bronx Countyresidence (see e.g. Clarke v Ahern Prod. Servs., 181 AD2d 514 [1992]). Counsel'saffidavit by which he cites unspecified "investigative efforts" that revealed that someone otherthan plaintiff occupied the apartment amounts to mere hearsay and is insufficient to carrydefendant's initial burden (see Hurley v Union Trust Co. of Rochester, 244 App Div 590[1935]). Even if accepted, defendant's proof would fall far short of establishing that plaintiff didnot live anywhere in Bronx County when this action was commenced. Accordingly, defendant'sfailure to meet its initial burden of making a prima facie showing of entitlement to relief makes itunnecessary to consider the sufficiency of plaintiff's opposition to the motion (see e.g. Frees v Frank & Walter EberhartL.P. No.1, 71 AD3d 491, 492 [2010]). Concur—Mazzarelli, J.P., DeGrasse,Freedman and Abdus-Salaam, JJ.

Sweeny, J., dissents in a memorandum as follows: I would affirm the granting of the motionto change venue.

The burden is on the defendant, as the movant, to establish that plaintiff improperlydesignated Bronx County as the venue for this action (see Garced v Clinton Arms Assoc., 58 AD3d 506, 509 [2009]).This burden may, under appropriate circumstances, be satisfied by submitting counsel's swornaverment explaining why there are insufficient grounds for venue as laid (see Torres vLarsen, 195 AD2d 285, 286-287 [1993]). Although Torres concerned a CPLR 510(3) motion to change venue due to the inconvenience of witnesses, its reasoning extends to thisCPLR 510 (1) motion seeking to change venue due to the action having been brought in thewrong county.

Here, there is no question that defendant is located in New York County, the alleged [*2]malpractice occurred there and the medical records concerningplaintiff's treatment are also located there. These are facts that support defendant's motion for achange of venue (see Castro v NewYork Hosp. Med. Ctr. of Queens, 52 AD3d 251, 252 [2008]; Goldberg v Bierman, 35 AD3d807, 808 [2006]). While the better practice would have been for defendant to elaborate onand provide documentary evidence of its claims that plaintiff did not reside at the Bronxaddresses she gave in her opposition papers as well as the address listed on the summons, theattorney's affirmation did set forth sufficient information to meet defendant's initial burden. Forexample, the affirmation in response to plaintiff's opposition papers affirmatively stated that theresidents of the apartment plaintiff claimed as her address were listed as two other namedpersons, not plaintiff.

Plaintiff, in response, failed to objectively demonstrate that she resided in Bronx County atthe time she filed the complaint. In opposition to defendant's motion, plaintiff submitted (1) herself-serving affidavit stating that she was a resident of Bronx County at the time the action wascommenced, and (2) a phone bill in Bronx County dated prior to commencement of theaction. Moreover, plaintiff's medical records showing a Bronx address submitted in opposition todefendant's motion related to medical treatment prior to the commencement of this action.

Since plaintiff failed to demonstrate her residence in Bronx County on the date of thecommencement of the action, the motion court acted properly in changing venue to New YorkCounty.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.