| Matter of Finn v Sherwood |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 06500 [87 AD3d 1044] |
| September 19, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Geoffrey Finn et al., Appellants, v WilliamSherwood et al., Respondents-Respondents, et al., Respondent. |
—[*1]
In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law §§ 6-146 and 16-102, inter alia, toinvalidate a petition designating William Sherwood, James B. White, and Karl C. Javanes ascandidates in a primary election held on September 13, 2011, for the nomination of theIndependence Party as its candidates for the public offices of Supervisor, Member of the TownCouncil, and Member of the Town Council, respectively, of the Town of Stony Point, RocklandCounty, the petitioners appeal from a final order of the Supreme Court, Rockland County(Brands, J.), dated August 16, 2011, which, in effect, denied the petition and dismissed theproceeding.
Ordered that the final order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.
Initially, we note that, under the particular circumstances of this case, the appeal is notacademic.
The petitioners contend that the Supreme Court erred in failing to invalidate the challengeddesignating petition on the ground that it was permeated with fraud. Generally, a designatingpetition will only be invalidated on the ground of fraud where there is a showing that the entiredesignating petition is permeated with fraud (see Matter of Harris v Duran, 76 AD3d 658, 659 [2010]; Matter of Robinson v Edwards, 54AD3d 682, 683 [2008]; Matter ofDrace v Sayegh, 43 AD3d 481, 482 [2007]). Even when the designating petition is notpermeated with fraud, the designating petition will generally be invalidated where the candidatehas participated in or is chargeable with knowledge of the fraud (see Matter of Harris vDuran, 76 AD3d at 659; Matter ofPerez v Galarza, 21 AD3d 508, 509 [2005]; see Matter of Drace v Sayegh, 43AD3d at 482). Here, although there were some irregularities relating to the designating petition,the petitioners failed to meet their burden of demonstrating by clear and convincing evidence thatit was permeated with fraud or that the candidates participated in or were chargeable withknowledge of any fraud (see Matter of Harris v Duran, 76 AD3d at 659; Matter of Hennessey v DiCarlo, 21AD3d 505, 506 [2005]; Matter of McRae v Jennings, 307 AD2d 1012, 1013 [2003]).
The petitioners also failed to meet their burden of establishing that all of the signatures on thedesignating petition should have been invalidated on the ground that Douglas J. Jobson, thenotary public who witnessed the signatures, failed to obtain a statement from each of thesignatories attesting to the truth and accuracy of the matter to which they subscribed their names(see [*2]Election Law § 6-132 [3]). Jobson testifiedthat he introduced himself to each signatory, explained to them what they were signing, andadministered to and took an oath from each signatory. Jobson thereby substantially compliedwith Election Law § 6-132 (3) (see Matter of Kutner v Nassau County Bd. of Elections, 65 AD3d643, 644-645 [2009]; Matter ofLiebler v Friedman, 54 AD3d 697, 697-698 [2008]). "Since the Supreme Court had theadvantage of hearing and seeing the witnesses, the Supreme Court's assessment of [Jobson's]credibility is entitled to substantial deference" (Matter of Harris v Duran, 76 AD3d at659; see Matter of Drace v Sayegh, 43 AD3d at 482).
Further, we reject the petitioners' contention that the designating petition should have beeninvalidated on the ground that candidate William Sherwood failed to file a certificate ofacceptance as required by Election Law § 6-146 (1). Sherwood filed a certificate ofacceptance containing his complete and correct name, his correct address, the correct politicalparty, and the correct office. The certificate was duly acknowledged by a notary public. While thecertificate made reference to the general election rather than the primary election, such an "errorpresents no basis to invalidate the designating petition" (Matter of Reagon v LeJeune,307 AD2d 1015, 1015 [2003]; see Matter of Conklin v Canary, 112 AD2d 1062 [1985],affd 65 NY2d 952 [1985]; Matter of Helfer v Amos, 159 Misc 2d 65 [1993]).
The petitioners' remaining contentions are without merit. Therefore, the Supreme Courtproperly, in effect, denied the petition and dismissed the proceeding. Skelos, J.P., Leventhal, Halland Lott, JJ., concur.