Sabia v Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.
2011 NY Slip Op 06684 [87 AD3d 1291]
September 30, 2011
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, November 9, 2011


Mark V. Sabia, as Administrator of the Estate of Mario V. Sabia,Deceased, Respondent,
v
Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation, Doing Business asNational Grid, Defendant, and Northern Erie Sno-Seekers, Inc.,Appellant.

—[*1]Hancock & Estabrook, LLP, Syracuse (Janet D. Callahan of counsel), fordefendant-appellant.

Law Offices of Eugene C. Tenney, Buffalo (Edward J. Schwendler, III, of counsel), forplaintiff-respondent.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Erie County (John F. O'Donnell, J.), enteredDecember 8, 2010. The order, inter alia, denied the motion of defendant Northern ErieSno-Seekers, Inc. for summary judgment dismissing the complaint and granted the cross motionof plaintiff to dismiss the General Obligations Law § 9-103 affirmative defense ofNorthern Erie Sno-Seekers, Inc.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously modified on the law bydenying that part of the cross motion for summary judgment dismissing the affirmative defenseof defendant Northern Erie Sno-Seekers, Inc. pursuant to General Obligations Law § 9-103and granting the motion of defendant Northern Erie Sno-Seekers, Inc. for summary judgmentdismissing the complaint against it and as modified the order is affirmed without costs.

Memorandum: Plaintiff's decedent was killed while operating a snowmobile on a trailmaintained by defendant Northern Erie Sno-Seekers, Inc. (Sno-Seekers) on property owned bydefendant Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation, doing business as National Grid (NiMo). Afterleaving a restaurant where he had consumed several alcoholic beverages, decedent, followed by afriend on another snowmobile, drove directly into a metal gate near a portion of the trail he hadpassed earlier that evening. By his friend's estimate, decedent was traveling at a speed ofapproximately 45 miles per hour when he hit the gate. Decedent was rendered unconsciousimmediately and died within one hour after the accident. Plaintiff commenced this action seekingto recover damages for decedent's wrongful death and conscious pain and suffering, contendingthat the "accident was caused by the willful or malicious failure to guard or to warn against adangerous condition, use, structure or activity of the [d]efendants." Following discovery, bothdefendants moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint against them, respectively,based upon General Obligations Law § 9-103, which they each asserted as an affirmativedefense. That statute provides in relevant part that "an owner, lessee or occupant of [*2]premises . . . owes no duty to keep the premises safefor entry or use by others for . . . motorized vehicle operation for recreationalpurposes[ ] [or] snowmobile operation . . . or to give warning of any hazardouscondition or use of or structure or activity on such premises to persons entering for suchpurposes" (§ 9-103 [1] [a]), unless the owner, lessee or occupant of the premises is guiltyof a "willful or malicious failure to guard, or to warn against, a dangerous condition, use,structure or activity" (§ 9-103 [2] [a]), or receives consideration for the use of the premisesto pursue, inter alia, the above enumerated activities (§ 9-103 [2] [b]). Plaintiff, in turn,cross-moved to strike defendants' affirmative defenses under section 9-103.

Supreme Court granted NiMo's motion, denied Sno-Seekers' motion, and granted that part ofplaintiff's cross motion with respect to Sno-Seekers. The court reasoned that Sno-Seekers'affirmative action in directing riders in the direction of the metal gate without adequate warningsrendered General Obligations Law § 9-103 inapplicable. The court further determined thatSno-Seekers had failed to establish that the $25 membership dues charged to members, includingdecedent, did not constitute "consideration" for the use of the trail within the meaning of section9-103 (2) (b). We conclude that the court erred in denying Sno-Seekers' motion and in grantingthat part of plaintiff's cross motion with respect to Sno-Sneekers. We therefore modify the orderaccordingly, thus dismissing the complaint in its entirety.

General Obligations Law § 9-103 "grants a special immunity to owners, lessees oroccupants from the usual duty to keep places safe" when those using the property are engaged inspecified recreational activities (Farnham v Kittinger, 83 NY2d 520, 525 [1994]). Here, itis undisputed that decedent was engaged in a covered activity, i.e., snowmobiling, and that theproperty had been used extensively for snowmobiling for years and was suitable for that purpose.The court erred in determining that the statute was inapplicable because Sno-Seekers was guiltyof "affirmative" acts of negligence, thereby rendering the statute inapplicable pursuant to section9-103 (2) (a). Indeed, we held in Sauberan v Ohl (239 AD2d 891 [1997]) that GeneralObligations Law § 9-103 does not immunize a landowner or occupant from liability foraffirmative acts of negligence unrelated to the condition of the land itself. Thus, inSauberan, we held that the statute did not shield the landowner/occupant from liabilityfrom a hunting accident that occurred on his property, where liability was not predicated upon his"status as owner or occupant of the land" but, instead, was predicated "upon his allegedlyimproper conduct in telling [the] defendant [in question] . . . to shoot at a target that[the owner/occupant] could not see" (id.). Similarly, in Del Costello v Delaware &Hudson Ry. Co. (274 AD2d 19, 21 [2000]), the Third Department held the statute wasinapplicable in a case where the injured plaintiff was struck by a train while operating asnowmobile on property owned by the defendant. The Del Costello Court reasoned that"the statute does not immunize [the defendant] landowner [or one of its employees] from itsseparate and distinct duty to operate a vehicle on its recreational property with reasonable care"(id. at 23; see Lee v Long Is. R.R., 204 AD2d 280, 282 [1994]). Here, thenegligence alleged by plaintiff is related solely to the condition of the property itself, not to anyindependent duty separate and distinct therefrom, and thus the affirmative negligence doctrine isinapplicable.

We reject plaintiff's contention that Sno-Seekers was guilty of willful or malicious conductso as to trigger the statutory exception under General Obligations Law § 9-103 (2) (a).That exception " 'must be strictly construed in order that the major policy underlying thelegislation itself is not defeated,' with all doubts resolved in favor of the general provision ratherthan the exception" (Farnham, 83 NY2d at 529). For a party successfully to invoke theexception, there must be "a high-threshold demonstration . . . to show willful intentby the alleged wrongdoer" (id.), a showing that plaintiff has failed to make in this case.

Finally, the fact that Sno-Seekers, a not-for-profit group, charged a nominal membership feeof $25 per year does not trigger the "consideration" exception to the statute (General [*3]Obligations Law § 9-103 [2] [b]). It is undisputed that themembership fee was not charged as a prerequisite to use of the trails, which were open to thepublic at large. Indeed, the friend of decedent who was riding with him that night was not adues-paying member of Sno-Seekers at the time. Under the circumstances, we conclude thatthere was an insufficient nexus between the nominal membership dues and the maintenance ofthe trail to trigger the statutory exception (see Heminway v State Univ. of N.Y., 244AD2d 979 [1997], lv denied 91 NY2d 809 [1998]; see also Martins v SyracuseUniv., 214 AD2d 967 [1995]). Present—Scudder, P.J., Smith, Carni, Lindley andMartoche, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.