Matter of Valenti v Bugbee
2011 NY Slip Op 07152 [88 AD3d 1056]
October 13, 2011
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 7, 2011


In the Matter of Franklin Valenti et al., Appellants, v Larry Bugbeeet al., as Commissioners of the Rensselaer County Board of Elections, Respondent, and Jack B.Cox Jr., Respondent.

—[*1]James E. Walsh, Schenectady, for appellants.

Thomas V. Kenney Jr., Troy, for Jack B. Cox Jr., respondent.

Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Jacon, J.), entered September 12,2011 in Rensselaer County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a proceeding pursuant toElection Law § 16-102, to declare invalid an independent nominating petition namingrespondent Jack B. Cox Jr. as the Revolutionary Party candidate for the office of Mayor of theCity of Troy in the November 8, 2011 general election.

Respondent Jack B. Cox Jr. filed an independent nominating petition with the RensselaerCounty Board of Elections seeking nomination as the Revolutionary Party candidate for theoffice of Mayor of the City of Troy in the November 8, 2011 general election. After objectionswere filed, petitioners commenced this proceeding to invalidate Cox's independent nominatingpetition on various grounds, including fraud. Following a hearing, Supreme Court dismissed thepetition. Petitioners appeal.

Courts will invalidate an independent nominating petition if the challengers show "that [*2]the entire petition is permeated with fraud or that the candidateparticipated in, or can be charged with knowledge of, fraudulent activity" (Matter of Kraham v Rabbitt, 11 AD3d808, 809 [2004]; see Matter ofNolin v McNally, 87 AD3d 804, 805 [2011]). These are alternative grounds; the fraudneed not permeate the entire petition if the candidate was involved with or knew of the fraud, andthe petition may be invalidated even if it contains "a sufficient number of valid signaturesindependent of those fraudulently procured" (Matter of Drace v Sayegh, 43 AD3d 481, 482 [2007]; see Matter of Tapper v Sampel, 54AD3d 435, 436 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 701 [2008]). The parties challenging thepetition must demonstrate the existence of fraud by clear and convincing evidence (seeMatter of Nolin v McNally, 87 AD3d at 805; Matter of Harris v Duran, 76 AD3d 658, 659 [2010]).

Here, petitioners presented five witnesses who testified that signatures attributed to themwere not their own. Four of them testified that they had given a family member permission tosign their names. The fifth witness testified that she signed the petition once, but a secondsignature attributed to her on another page of the petition was not hers. Cox, who gathered all ofthe signatures himself, testified that four of the testifying witnesses did not sign their names tothe petition, at least three or four other signatures were also placed on the petition by proxy, andhe had no explanation as to how the fifth witness's signature appeared twice. Cox testified that hedid not solicit the proxy signatures, he realized that they were improper, family members simplyaffixed proxy signatures before he had an opportunity to object, and he purposely collected moresignatures than necessary to compensate for those that might be invalid. Only 544 signatureswere needed and Cox gathered 941. Despite these uncontested facts, Cox signed the witnessstatement at the bottom of each page of the petition, which is "the equivalent of an affidavit,"attesting that each person whose name appeared thereon had subscribed his or her name "in mypresence" and "identified himself [or herself] to be the individual who signed this sheet"(see Election Law § 6-140 [1] [b]).

The testimony, including Cox's own, established by clear and convincing evidence that, onseveral pages of the petition, Cox signed the witness statements despite knowing that thosestatements were materially false (see Matter of Flower v D'Apice, 104 AD2d 578, 578[1984], affd 63 NY2d 715 [1984]). There was no conflicting testimony at the hearing thatwould necessitate giving deference to a credibility determination by the trial court (compareMatter of McHugh v Comella, 307 AD2d 1069, 1070 [2003], lv denied 100 NY2d509 [2003] [validating petition where trial court apparently accepted candidate's testimony thatshe mistakenly signed witness statement on one page of petition she had not witnessed, believingit was a different page of signatures that she had witnessed]). All of the witnesses agreed that thefive signatures were not placed on the petition by the purported signers and Cox testified that hesigned the witness statements although he had not actually witnessed several of the signaturesbeing affixed to the petition by the purported signer in his presence. He then filed the petitioncontaining those false statements and invalid signatures without informing the Board of Electionsof any irregularity, and did nothing to correct those false statements until confronted with them atthe hearing where his petition was challenged (see Matter of Tapper v Sampel, 54 AD3dat 436; cf. Matter of Cirillo vGardiner, 65 AD3d 638, 639 [2009]). Although we do not ascribe any nefarious motiveto Cox's conduct, his actions still constituted a fraud. Because the candidate participated in afraud in procuring signatures on his independent nominating petition, we invalidate that petitionand strike Cox's name from the ballot even though the petition contained a sufficient number ofvalid signatures (see Matter of Drace v Sayegh, 43 AD3d at 482; Matter of Leonard vPradhan, 286 AD2d 459 [2001], lv denied 96 NY2d 718 [2001]; Matter ofLayden v Gargiulo, 77 AD2d 933, 934 [1980]).[*3]

Peters, J.P., Lahtinen, Stein, McCarthy and Garry, JJ.,concur. Ordered that the order is reversed, on the law, without costs, petitioners' applicationgranted, and the independent nominating petition naming respondent Jack B. Cox Jr. as theRevolutionary Party candidate for the office of Mayor of the City of Troy in the November 8,2011 general election is declared invalid.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.