Matter of Winners Garage, Inc. v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y.
2011 NY Slip Op 07762 [89 AD3d 1166]
November 3, 2011
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 4th, 2012


In the Matter of Winners Garage, Inc., Petitioner, v Tax Appeals Tribunalof The State of New York et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Winners Garage,Inc., et al., Petitioners,
v
Tax Appeals Tribunal of the State of New York et al., Respondents.(Proceeding No. 2.)

—[*1]Andrew B. Schultz, Jericho, for petitioners.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Kathleen M. Arnold of counsel), forCommissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.

Peters, J.P. (1) Proceeding No. 1 pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant toTax Law § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal which, amongother things, sustained a proposed refusal to renew a certificate of authority to petitioner, and (2) [*2]proceeding No. 2 pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Courtpursuant to Tax Law § 2016) to review determinations of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunalwhich, among other things, dismissed petitioners' applications for redetermination of sales and use taxesas untimely.

Petitioner Lev Wolkowicki is the manager of petitioner Winners Garage, Inc., a New Yorkcorporation that leases taxicabs to drivers in the City of New York. In October 2007, the Departmentof Taxation and Finance audited Winners Garage and determined that it had failed to pay sales and usetaxes in the amount of $211,907.10 from December 1, 2004 to August 31, 2007.[FN1]After the parties had twice consented to the extension of the limitations period for action by theDepartment on the audit, the Department sent a Statement of Proposed Audit Change to WinnersGarage in January 2009. In response to this statement, Wolkowicki, on behalf of Winners Garage,disagreed with the audit and requested a conciliation conference. Jose Rances, the auditor who auditedWinners Garage, subsequently sent a conciliation conference request form to Wolkowicki to fill out andreturn on behalf of Winners Garage. Petitioners never returned this form.

In February 2009, before the limitations period for the Department to act was set toexpire,[FN2]the Department issued notices of determination to Winners Garage and Wolkowicki for the sales anduse tax deficiencies. Both notices set forth that Winners Garage and Wolkowicki had 90 days tochallenge the notice by filing a request for a conciliation conference or a petition for a Division of TaxAppeals hearing. Neither Winners Garage nor Wolkowicki made any contact with the Department untilJune 2009, after the 90-day period to challenge the notices had expired. At that time, they attempted torenew Winners Garage's sales tax certificate of authority.[FN3]Due to the sales and use taxes owed by Winners Garage and Wolkowicki, the Department denied suchrenewal.

Thereafter, in October 2009, Winners Garage and Wolkowicki filed petitions seeking aredetermination of the sales and use tax deficiencies, and Winners Garage filed a petition to review theDepartment's proposed refusal to renew its certificate of authority. The Administrative Law Judge(hereinafter ALJ), in separate determinations, dismissed petitioners' applications for redetermination asuntimely and denied Winners Garage's petition for a review of the denial of its renewal request due toits failure to timely challenge the sales and use tax deficiencies determined by the Department. Upon thefiling of exceptions by petitioners, respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal issued separate decisionsupholding the ALJ's determinations. Petitioners then commenced these CPLR article 78 proceedings tochallenge the determinations of the tribunal.

"The deadline to request a conciliation conference or petition for redetermination of a notice ofdetermination assessing sales and use taxes is 90 days from the mailing of the notice of [*3]determination" (Matter of Moore v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin., 4 AD3d 682, 683[2004], lv denied 3 NY3d 603 [2004]; see Tax Law § 1138 [a] [1], [3] [B]).This 90-day period is "absolute" (Matter of Halperin v Chu, 138 AD2d 915, 917 [1988],lv dismissed and denied 72 NY2d 938 [1988]), and if a petitioner does not request aconciliation conference or petition for redetermination within that time, the amount set forth in the notice"shall be an assessment of the amount of tax [owed]" (Tax Law § 1138 [a] [1]; see§ 1138 [a] [3] [B]; Matter of Mareno v State of N.Y. Tax Commn., 144 AD2d 114,115 [1988]; Matter of Halperin v Chu, 138 AD2d at 917).

Here, the parties do not dispute that the notices of determination were mailed to Winners Garageand Wolkowicki on February 19, 2009 and February 20, 2009, respectively, and that petitionersreceived the notices. These notices clearly and repeatedly stated that, if petitioners disagreed with theamounts assessed, they had 90 days to either "file[ ] a Request for Conciliation Conference or aPetition for a Division of Tax Appeals hearing." Petitioners, however, did not file petitions seekingreview by the Division of Tax Appeals of the Department's determinations until October 2009, almostfive months after the 90-day period had expired. Although Wolkowicki had previously protested theproposed audit issued by the Department and requested a conciliation conference, a protest to aproposed statement of audit before the notice of determination is issued is insufficient to meet thestatutory requirements (see Matter of West Mtn. Corp. v State of New York Dept. of Taxation &Fin., 105 AD2d 989, 990 [1984], affd 64 NY2d 991 [1985]). Even if this protest hadoccurred after the notices of determination were issued, petitioners never filed a request for conciliationconference form as explicitly required by the notices of determination. Therefore, as petitioners failed torequest a conciliation conference or petition for redetermination within 90 days of the issuance of thenotices of determination, the tribunal's dismissal of their belated petitions to review those determinationswas not arbitrary, capricious or irrational (seeMatter of Voelker v State of N.Y. Commr. of Taxation & Fin., 50 AD3d 1187, 1188[2008]; Matter of Halperin v Chu, 138 AD2d at 917; Matter of West Mtn. Corp. v Stateof New York Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 105 AD2d at 989-990). Furthermore, given the taxliability imposed by those determinations which remained unpaid by petitioners, we discern no error inthe denial of the petition to review the Department's refusal to renew Winners Garage's certificate ofauthority (see Tax Law § 1134 [a] [4] [B]).

Petitioners also contend that, inasmuch as the Department engaged in a series of confusing andinconsistent actions that led to their untimely filings, the Department should have been estopped fromraising the statute of limitations as a defense. It is firmly established that, absent unusual circumstancessupporting "a finding of 'manifest injustice,' the doctrine of estoppel does not apply in taxation cases"(Matter of Suburban Restoration Co. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 299 AD2d 751,753 [2002]; see Matter of Diaz v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 243 AD2d 995, 997[1997]; Matter of AGL Welding Supply Co. v Commissioner of Taxation & Fin., 238 AD2d734, 736 [1997], lv denied 90 NY2d 808 [1997]; Matter of Moog, Inc. v Tully, 105AD2d 982, 983 [1984]). "Additionally, in order to impose an estoppel upon a party, three elementsmust be established: (1) conduct which amounts to a false representation or concealment of materialfacts; (2) intention that such conduct will be acted upon by the other party; and (3) knowledge of thereal facts" (Matter of Rashbaum v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 229 AD2d 723, 725[1996] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]).

Petitioners maintain that, having requested a conciliation conference in response to theDepartment's Statement of Proposed Audit Change, they reasonably believed that they had already[*4]complied with the requirements to challenge the notices ofdetermination. However, the record fails to reveal any promises or actions on the part of theDepartment or its employees that would lead petitioners to believe that this request would comply withsuch requirements. To the contrary, Rances responded to petitioners' request by sending them a"Request for Conciliation Conference" form and advising them to complete and return it in order for aconciliation conference to be scheduled. Thus, he clearly indicated that petitioners' informal request forsuch a conference was not sufficient. Although, as the ALJ noted, it is "somewhat disconcerting" thatRances sent this form to petitioners given that a timely request for a conciliation conference cannot bemade prior to a notice of determination, "it is well established that erroneous advice given by anemployee of a governmental agency is not considered to rise to the level of an unusual circumstance"warranting invocation of the doctrine of estoppel (Matter of Walsh v Tax Appeals Trib. of State ofN.Y., 196 AD2d 367, 370-371 [1994] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]). In anyevent, petitioners never filed the Request for Conciliation form and, therefore, did not rely to theirdetriment on any misinformation or misdirection on the part of Rances. Furthermore, no confusion couldhave existed when petitioners received the notices of determination that clearly and unambiguouslystated that they had 90 days from the date of the notices to challenge the Department'sdetermination,[FN4] that any challenge must be made by filing a request for conciliation conference or a petition for ahearing, and that, if the Department did not receive a response within the 90-day period, "[t]his Noticewill become an assessment subject to collection action."

Petitioners' additional claim that they were under the impression that the Department would holdthe proceedings for the present audit in abeyance until the conclusion of the proceedings involving anaudit of an earlier period is belied by the record. Although petitioners were in fact advised by letter thatthe Department was willing to hold the present audit in abeyance, they failed to execute and return theenclosed consent forms that would have extended the limitations period for action by the Departmenton the audit. Moreover, any such impression should have been dispelled upon receiving the notices ofdetermination which, as previously noted, clearly informed petitioners of the procedure to be followedto challenge the assessments. On this record, we find no manifest injustice resulting to petitioners and,therefore, no basis for the invocation of the doctrine of estoppel.

Petitioners' remaining contentions, including their assertion that the Tribunal failed to adhere to itsprior precedent, have been fully reviewed and found to be without merit.

Spain, Lahtinen, Stein and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determinations are confirmed,without costs, and petitions dismissed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1: The audit also determined thatWinners Garage owed interest and penalties in the amount of $180,802.36.

Footnote 2: Pursuant to the most recent consentto the extension of the limitations period executed by Wolkowicki, the limitations period was set toexpire on March 20, 2009.

Footnote 3: In the interim, the Department hadsent notices of demand of payment of tax due to Winners Garage and Wolkowicki.

Footnote 4: Indeed, the respective notices evenlisted, in boldface, the deadline for filing a petition for a hearing or request for a conciliation conference,which was May 20, 2009 with respect to the notice issued to Winners Garage and May 21, 2009 withrespect to the notice issued to Wolkowicki.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.