| ABKCO Music & Records, Inc. v Montague |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 08664 [90 AD3d 402] |
| Dcmbr 1, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| ABKCO Music & Records, Inc., Appellant, v NathanielMontague et al., Respondents. |
—[*1]
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Emily Jane Goodman, J.), entered August 2,2010, which, after a nonjury trial, granted defendants' motion to dismiss the complaint,unanimously reversed, on the law, without costs, the motion denied, and judgment in the amountof $325,000, with interest from July 27, 2005, granted to plaintiff. The Clerk is directed to enterjudgment accordingly.
It is uncontroverted that from 1999 to 2005 plaintiff advanced funds to defendants to aidthem in cataloging a collection of African American art and memorabilia. Plaintiff asserts thatthe funds advanced constituted a loan, while defendants contend that the advances were intendedas gifts. In support of its claim, plaintiff presented three witnesses who testified that the advanceswere made as loans. At the close of plaintiff's case, defendants moved for a trial order ofdismissal. After the court reserved decision on the motion, defendants rested without presenting acase. The court then granted the motion to dismiss, concluding that plaintiff failed to make out aprima facie case because the testimony in support of its claim was given by interested witnessesand therefore could be discounted. We disagree.
As we understand their position on appeal, defendants acknowledge that the advances theyreceived from plaintiff were to be repaid in the event defendants sold the art collection. In thisregard, defendants state in their brief, "Since the collection has not yet been sold, no payment isdue." Defendants thus recognize that the advances were not gifts. Moreover, at trial, plaintiffintroduced a letter from defendants' accountant that referred to plaintiff as having made a loan todefendants. Defendants, on the other hand, offered no evidence of any kind, but rested at theclose of plaintiff's case. Given that plaintiff established a prima facie case and defendants failedto present any countervailing evidence, plaintiff is entitled to judgment.
We note that the absence of a specified time for repayment in the parties' oral loan agreementdoes not defeat plaintiff's claim. As Supreme Court recognized in denying defendants' pretrialmotion for summary judgment, where no time for repayment is specified in a loan agreement, theloan is payable immediately upon demand (see Bradford, Eldred & Cuba R.R. Co. v NewYork, Lake Erie & W. R.R. Co., 123 NY 316, 326-327 [1890]). Concur—Saxe, J.P.,Friedman, DeGrasse, Freedman and Abdus-Salaam, JJ.
The decision and order of this Court entered May 26, 2011 (84 AD3d 660 [2011]) is herebyrecalled and vacated (see 2011 NY Slip Op 91067[U] [2011] [decided simultaneouslyherewith]).