Halpin v Cheikhet
2011 NY Slip Op 08878 [90 AD3d 1211]
December 8, 2011
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 1, 2012


Kevin M. Halpin et al., Respondents-Appellant, v Igor Cheikhet etal., Appellants-Respondents.

—[*1]Sharon M. Sulimowicz, Ithaca, for appellants-respondents.

Holmberg, Galbraith, Van Houten & Miller, Ithaca (Dirk A. Galbraith of counsel), forrespondents-appellants.

Spain, J.P. (1) Appeal from an order and amended judgment of the Supreme Court (O'Shea,J.), entered September 13, 2010 and October 27, 2010 in Tompkins County, upon a decision ofthe court in favor of plaintiffs, and (2) cross appeals from an order of said court, entered October19, 2010 in Tompkins County, which awarded plaintiffs prejudgment interest.

Defendants Igor Cheikhet and Boris Simkin, doing business as defendant ADISConstruction, contracted with plaintiffs to construct a single-family home in the Town of Danby,Tompkins County. The home was completed in October 2002 and title was transferred toplaintiffs. Water began leaking into the property's basement by the end of 2002 and, in April2003, plaintiffs sent a notice of warranty claim to Simkin. After various unsuccessful efforts bySimkin to remedy the problem, plaintiffs commenced this action in September 2006, claimingthat defendants breached the housing merchant implied warranty, as provided for under GeneralBusiness Law § 777-a (1). A nonjury trial ensued, and Supreme Court ultimatelydetermined that the leakage was the result of defendants' failure to properly install a footer drainand they were unable to remedy the defect despite timely notice from plaintiffs. The courtassessed damages as the diminution in the home's value as a result of the defect and awardedplaintiffs $45,000. In a subsequent order, the court imposed prejudgment interest beginning fromthe action's commencement date, and an amended judgment was entered reflecting theprejudgment interest. Defendants appeal from both orders and the court's amended judgment, andplaintiffs cross-[*2]appeal, challenging only the amount ofprejudgment interest.

When considering an appeal from a trial court's decision rendered after a nonjury trial, thisCourt is vested with broad authority to independently review the evidence, but deference isaccorded to the findings of the trial court where they are based on credibility determinations (see Richmor Aviation, Inc. v SportsflightAir, Inc., 82 AD3d 1423, 1424 [2011]; Shon v State of New York, 75 AD3d 1035, 1036 [2010];Winkler v Kingston Hous. Auth., 259 AD2d 819, 823 [1999]). After independentlyreviewing the record, we agree with Supreme Court's conclusion that plaintiffs met their burdenin proving that defendants breached the housing merchant implied warranty (see GeneralBusiness Law § 777-a [1]; Horwitz v Camelot Assoc. Corp., 66 AD3d 1299, 1300 [2009]).

The premise of plaintiffs' case is that defendants breached the housing merchant warrantybecause their construction of the footer drain system failed to meet applicable building codestandards and/or locally accepted building practices (see General Business Law §777-a [1] [a]; [3]). Defendants do not dispute that relevant building codes and general practicerequire that foundation walls of cellars or basements and floors in contact with the soil should beconstructed so as to prevent the penetration of ground and surface water, and that constructionpractices in the Town required anywhere between 4 and 24 inches of gravel or "number twostone" to be placed above a footer drain. However, they dispute the adequacy of plaintiffs' proofthat insufficient stone was placed above the drain here.

At trial, excavation contractor Francanko Ferrara testified that, when he dug a test holeoutside plaintiffs' basement wall, he discovered that the water penetration was being caused bythe absence of stone above the footer drain. He opined that the only solution was to install a newdrainage system. Engineer Gregory Dende testified and agreed with Ferrara's assessment, addingthat, based on standard practices in the Town, improper tiling of the footer drain was acontributing factor to water penetrating the basement walls. The Town Code EnforcementOfficer testified that she would not have customarily permitted a construction to go forwardwhen the proper materials had not been placed above the footer drain, but she could not recallactually viewing the drain at plaintiffs' home. Likewise, although Simkin stated that it was hiscustomary practice to place one foot of number two stone above a footer drain, he conceded thatthe installation of plaintiffs' drain was performed by a subcontractor and he was uncertainwhether he was present when that work was undertaken. Deferring as is appropriate to the trialcourt's credibility determinations, we find ample proof to support the finding of liability (seeHorwitz v Camelot Assoc. Corp., 66 AD3d at 1300).

Defendants' assertions that Dende's testimony should be disregarded because it includedopinions on structural defects that had not been alleged in the complaint is unpersuasive.Supreme Court explicitly noted that it was only considering such testimony for the purpose ofdeciding plaintiffs' "skillful manner" claim and it did not award damages based upon a claim ofmaterial defect. Likewise, we reject defendants' contention that Ferrara's testimony should bedisregarded as incredible due to inconsistencies in his testimony. Having reviewed the testimony,we find the inconsistencies to be immaterial and insufficient to call his testimony, as a whole,into question.

We also reject defendants' contention that they were not provided with a "reasonableopportunity" to remedy the defective condition of the home as required by General Business Law§ 777-a (4) (a) (see Trificana vCarrier, 81 AD3d 1339, 1340 [2011], lv denied 16 NY3d 710[*3][2011]). Indeed, between the spring of 2003 when plaintiffs firstnotified Simkin that water was leaking into the basement, and the winter of 2006 when plaintiffshired Ferrara to evaluate the situation, Simkin was consistently informed when leaking occurredand repeatedly asked to remedy the problem. Simkin made several, unsuccessful attempts to stopthe leakage. Significantly, when plaintiffs asked Simkin to consider that the problem might bethe footer drain, he flatly rejected the suggestion. Under these circumstances, we find thatdefendants had ample opportunity to remedy the water penetration in the basement but failed todo so effectively (compare Matter of Brandt [Monaco Coach Corp.], 269 AD2d 671, 673[2000]; Matter of Jarvis [Safari Motor Coaches], 248 AD2d 899, 900 [1998]).

In addition, we conclude that Supreme Court did not abuse its discretion in crafting thedamage award (see Matter of Albany County Airport Auth. [Buhrmaster], 265 AD2d720, 722 [1999], lv denied 94 NY2d 758 [2000]; Matter of County of Broome [MillerFacilities Corp.], 133 AD2d 984, 985 [1987]). In an action for the breach of the housingmerchant implied warranty, "[t]he measure of damages shall be the reasonable cost of repair orreplacement and property damage to the home proximately caused by the breach of warranty. . . unless the court finds that, under the circumstances, the diminution in value ofthe home caused by the defect is a more equitable measure of damages" (General Business Law§ 777-a [4] [b]). Here, the parties presented conflicting evidence regarding the cost toremedy the defect. Defendant's expert opined that a sump pump water remediation system couldbe installed for less than $9,000. However, Ferrara and Dende both refuted the effectiveness ofsuch a system under these circumstances and opined that the only acceptable way to remedy theproblem was to, among other things, excavate along the outside of the foundation and install anew drainage system at a cost of $67,658. It was within the discretion of the court to credit thefindings of plaintiffs' experts over defendant's (see Matter of CNG Transmission Corp.[Green], 273 AD2d 726, 728 [2000]; Matter of Albany County Airport Auth.[Buhrmaster], 265 AD2d at 723). Given that the damage award that Supreme Court craftedbased on the evidence of the diminution in value of plaintiffs' home, $45,000, was less than theamount that plaintiffs' experts testified would be required for repairs, we conclude that the courtchose the measure of damages that was more equitable to defendants. Further, we find that theamount that Supreme Court found to represent the diminution in value of the home is adequatelysupported by expert testimony in the record (see Matter of Piotrowski, 25 AD3d 965, 966 [2006], lvdenied 7 NY3d 703 [2006]; Matter of CNG Transmission Corp. [Green], 273 AD2dat 728).

Finally, we agree with plaintiffs that prejudgment interest should have been awardedbeginning from the date that the title to the premises passed to plaintiffs rather than from the datethat the action was commenced. Prejudgment interest "shall be computed from the earliestascertainable date the cause of action existed" (CPLR 5001 [b]; see Environmental Prods. &Servs. v Consolidated Rail Corp., 285 AD2d 700, 702 [2001]). Here, the implied warrantywas breached when title passed to plaintiffs; thus, the interest should be computed from the dateof closing (see Parillo v Salvador, 276 AD2d 1000, 1002 [2000], lv denied 96NY2d 702 [2001]; Weiss v Berardi, 237 AD2d 596, 597 [1997]; Cotazino v BasilDev. Corp., 167 AD2d 632, 635 [1990]).

Rose, Kavanagh, Stein and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order entered September 13,2010 is affirmed, without costs.[*4]

Ordered that the order entered October 19, 2010 and theamended judgment are modified, on the law, without costs, by awarding interest from October 1,2002, and, as so modified, affirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.