Matter of Duchmann v Town of Hamburg
2011 NY Slip Op 09709 [90 AD3d 1642]
December 30, 2011
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 1, 2012


In the Matter of Peter S. Duchmann et al., Appellants, v Town ofHamburg et al., Respondents, and Lamar Advertising of Penn, LLC, et al.,Respondents.

—[*1]Harter Secrest & Emery LLP, Buffalo (Marc A. Romanowski of counsel), forpetitioners-appellants.

Jaeckle Fleischmann & Mugel, LLP, Buffalo (Howard S. Rosenhoch of counsel), forrespondents-respondents.

Appeal from a judgment (denominated order and judgment) of the Supreme Court, ErieCounty (John A. Michalek, J.), entered December 30, 2010 in a proceeding pursuant to CPLRarticle 78. The judgment, inter alia, dismissed the petition against respondents Lamar Advertisingof Penn, LLC, TLC Properties, Inc., Lamar Company, LLC and Lamar Texas LimitedPartnership.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.

Memorandum: Petitioners appeal from a judgment in this CPLR article 78 proceeding that,inter alia, dismissed the petition against respondents Lamar Advertising of Penn, LLC, TLCProperties, Inc., Lamar Company, LLC and Lamar Texas Limited Partnership (collectively,Lamar respondents). In 2004, the Lamar respondents entered into a lease agreement withpetitioners that allowed the Lamar respondents to place a billboard on petitioners' property. Onthe same day in 2004, respondent Town of Hamburg (Town) issued the Lamar respondents apermit for the construction of the billboard (hereafter, 2004 permit). After an eminent domaintaking, the Lamar respondents and petitioners entered into a new lease agreement that allowedfor the relocation of the billboard to other property owned by petitioners, and the Town issued abuilding permit for that relocation in 2007 (hereafter, 2007 permit).[*2]

Petitioners thereafter granted the Lamar respondents aperpetual easement that included "the right to service, maintain, improve or replace any outdooradvertising structure on the property [in question]." The Lamar respondents subsequently appliedto the Town for a permit to convert part of the billboard to a digital display screen. Petitionersobjected to the issuance of the permit because, as the owners of the property, they did not consentto the modification. Although that permit was revoked for other reasons, the Lamar respondentsagain applied for a permit to convert the billboard to an electronic format, and petitionersobjected on the same ground. After the Town issued the permit (hereafter, 2010 permit),petitioners appealed to respondent Town of Hamburg Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA), whichdenied the appeal. Petitioners commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seeking, inter alia, toannul the BZA's determination. Supreme Court granted the cross motion of the Lamarrespondents for summary judgment dismissing the petition against them. We affirm.

Petitioners contend that the 2010 permit is unlawful because they objected to the issuancethereof and the Lamar respondents did not obtain their written consent. Our review of anadministrative determination "is limited to whether the administrative action is arbitrary andcapricious or lacks a rational basis" (Matter of Concetta T. Cerame Irrevocable Family Trust v Town of PerintonZoning Bd. of Appeals, 6 AD3d 1091, 1092 [2004]). The BZA is " 'vested with greatdiscretion' . . . , [and its] determinations are entitled to 'great deference' "(id.).

Pursuant to the Code of the Town of Hamburg (Town Code), "[p]rior to the issuance of anysign permit for the erection, alteration, construction, relocation or enlargement of a sign,application for such permit shall be made" (Code of the Town of Hamburg § 280-250 [A]),and the application must contain "[t]he written consent of the owner[s] of the . . .property" (§ 280-250 [A] [2]). We conclude that it was not arbitrary and capricious for theBZA to conclude that the language of the easement provided the necessary written consent.Whether the change in format for the billboard is viewed as an improvement or a replacement,further consent from petitioners was not required.

Petitioners' contention that both the 2004 and 2007 permits are unlawful because they violatethe dimension requirements set forth in the Town Code is time-barred. An appeal of a permitissuance "shall be taken within [60] sixty days" (Town Law § 267-a [5] [b]). "A challengeto 'the issuance . . . of a building permit accrues when the permit is issued. . . and does not constitute a continuing wrong' " (Matter of Letourneau v Town of Berne,56 AD3d 880, 881 [2008]). Here, petitioners did not appeal to the BZA with respect to eitherthe 2004 or 2007 permit. In any event, we conclude that petitioners' contention lacks merit.Although billboards are prohibited under the Town Code (see § 280-252), a 2004federal court order and settlement between the Town and the Lamar respondents permitted themto place up to two billboards that measured 14 feet by 48 feet on the property. Because "'[s]tipulations of settlement are judicially favored and may not be lightly set aside' " (IDT Corp. v Tyco Group, S.A.R.L., 13NY3d 209, 213 [2009]), we conclude that the federal court order and settlement arecontrolling with respect to whether the billboard at issue could be erected and what itsdimensions could be.

Petitioners further contend that the determination of the BZA was improper because it failedto make findings of fact. We reject that contention and conclude that it may be ascertained from areview of the record that the BZA's determination had a rational basis (see generally Matter ofCommittee to Preserve Brighton Beach & Manhattan Beach v Council of City of N.Y., 214AD2d 335, 337 [1995], lv denied 87 NY2d 802 [1995]). Present—Scudder, P.J.,Centra, Fahey, Carni and Sconiers, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.